Delayed discharges and fair deal funding
Gerry Adams described the national trolley crisis, citing 479 patients waiting in hospitals, HIQA warnings and large numbers awaiting Fair Deal support, and sought emergency measures. The Taoiseach acknowledged the serious challenge but defended transitional beds, home-care packages, Fair Deal reforms and the Government’s health service plan.
This morning there were 479 citizens - I use the term "citizen" advisedly - languishing on trolleys in hospital corridors. The second highest number, 40 citizens, are in Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital in Drogheda in my constituency. I have raised this issue consistently on Leaders' Questions. It predates my election to this institution.
I have raised with the Taoiseach three times a letter from HIQA which points out that if recommendations it made in 2012 had been implemented, the current risk to patients would have been significantly reduced. The Taoiseach has yet to respond adequately to me on this issue. This deepening crisis is absolutely unacceptable and he should start his answer to me by acknowledging that.
What does the Minister for Health say when he is not talking to the Minister for Justice and Equality or smirking at Fianna Fáil? He says that this problem is a feature of our dysfunctional health system and that this is nothing new. He says that it only stands to reason that lives could be lost. He is the Minister for Health; he is not a neutral commentator. One could presume from his answers that lives have already been lost.
Is this not a national crisis? Is this not a totally unacceptable situation? The Taoiseach has refused to deal with it. There has been a Punch and Judy act between him and Fianna Fáil on these deadly serious issues. He allocated €25 million to the fair deal scheme.
Comment on this
That deals with only 300 citizens, or a quarter of those who have been clinically discharged. The Government gave more to the consultants in Irish Water. Will the Taoiseach acknowledge that this is a national crisis? Will he put in place emergency measures to tackle it?
Comment on this
I said in response to the leader of the party with no health policy that this is a matter of challenge for the Government. The Minister, Deputy Varadkar, has the full support of the Government in making arrangements to deal with this. That is why he set up the emergency task force to deal with delayed discharges.
Comment on this
The Minister, Deputy Reilly, got the same support until you shafted him.
Comment on this
That is why €25 million was made available which reduced the time people had been waiting for the fair deal and allowed for the beds I mentioned to be opened on both a transitional and an emergency basis. Of course it is realistic to say there are serious challenges facing the health system. The profession and system, while still challenged, is working better than it was when €16 billion was allocated to it.
Comment on this
On 17 February, there were 755 delayed discharges nationally, of which 370 were in the Dublin academic teaching hospitals.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach made choices in the budget.
Comment on this
Some 555 of those delayed discharges were destined for long-term residential care. The point made by the eminent doctor is of course true. It is not an acceptable situation to have so many elderly people in these situations, and nobody wants to see that. That is why the review of the fair deal will allow for the Minister to present a report to Government on dealing with the challenges and how best to manage the situation effectively for the future. The report will also examine the consequences of the extra moneys allocated to deal with the opening of transitional and emergency beds. As I said, the budget for 2015 included an allocation of €600 million to cover the overrun of €500 million, and about €150 million which is modest in the context of the overall budget.
Comment on this
It is paltry in the context of people dying.
Comment on this
It is part of implementing the health service plan presented by the HSE which has been accepted by Government.
Comment on this
There have been many warnings that patients' lives are at risk as a result of Government policy. Last night's "Prime Time" focused on this issue. This time the warning came from the former national director of acute hospitals, Dr. Tony O'Connell. That warning was issued last September, but the Oireachtas was not told about it by the Taoiseach or the Minister for Health. It came by dint of a freedom of information inquiry from an investigative journalist. So much for transparency or Paddy or Patricia needing to know.
Comment on this
In response to my first question, the Taoiseach said the system is working better.
Comment on this
When Dr. O'Connell wrote his analysis, there were 703 delayed discharge patients in the acute hospital system. Last week there were 755. How is the system working better when more patients and citizens are experiencing difficulties? He also said that some patients live permanently in our acute beds and have been waiting for more than three years for placements. Many of those affected are elderly.
Comment on this
They are all sick and most, if not all, have been approved for private nursing care under the fair deal scheme, but they have not received the funding. There are currently 1,239 citizens waiting 11 weeks for fair deal funding. This situation is scandalous. Whatever Fianna Fáil did, this is happening on the Taoiseach's watch. He has been Taoiseach for four years. Dr. O'Connell concluded that-----
Comment on this
-----the long-term solution to this problem is adequate funding of the social care sector. It is ABC stuff. If it is not safe to send citizens home, then we have to provide the social protections they deserve. That then frees up hospital beds and so on. Why has the Government ignored this building crisis? Why have the warnings from Dr. O'Connell and the HIQA recommendations been set to one side? I put it to the Taoiseach earlier that this is a national emergency.
Comment on this
The Government should take emergency measures to deal with it.
Comment on this
Deputy Martin has no policy and Deputy Adams has no faith. Deputy Adams decided to go elsewhere to get his health treatment, which is his choice.
Comment on this
I beg your pardon. The policy the Taoiseach put before the House would take ten years.
Comment on this
He would not answer on "Morning Ireland".
Comment on this
I apologise. I was taken by the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
He wants it all funded by increases in income tax. Deputy Adams has no faith in the Irish health system which we are now trying to fix for everybody.
Comment on this
The Minister for Health has presented, from the HSE, the health service plan for 2015.
Comment on this
The Government was going to disband it.
Comment on this
The Government responded to that by not only dealing with the €500 million overrun of last year but also by putting more than €100 million into the budget for this year. Clearly, there are challenges. Nobody wants to see elderly people on trolleys and people who do not need to be in a hospital being kept there when they should be in transitional beds, nursing homes or other accommodation in order that they can have their medical needs properly supplied, but are prevented from accessing those services because of costs.
That is why it is important that there should be a review of the fair deal scheme-----
Comment on this
The review has taken four years.
Comment on this
-----included some in the Deputy's locality. There were 400 home care packages approved for Dublin and 80 home care packages currently deployed throughout the country and the rate is increasing daily.
Comment on this
In order to support the Dublin academic teaching hospitals and Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital and Naas General Hospital, a further 165 transitional beds were approved on 5 December to alleviate delayed discharges.
Comment on this
The health service plan was accepted by the Government and the Minister has our full support in attempting to manage this.
Comment on this
The Minister today said it is going to get worse.
Comment on this
We accept that this is a challenge and we want to see how best we can manage this in the interests of every patient.
Comment on this
It is a bigger challenge for the patients.