Budget Statement 2016
Contributions 1–167 of 311. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
A Cheann Comhairle, 2016, the centenary of the Easter Rising, is an opportunity to reflect on the journey travelled over the past 100 years and to recall the many major social and economic challenges along the way. It is an opportunity to celebrate the achievements and to remember how we overcame the challenges and emerged from each stronger than ever before.
The banking, fiscal and economic crisis of recent years will rank as one of the greatest of such challenges but we have emerged from this challenge too and we are now on a new path. The last few budgets have been hard but they made it possible for Ireland to exit the bailout, reduce its debts and move into a real recovery. The top priority of this budget is to keep that recovery going, while providing relief and better services for the Irish people. It includes measures such as a cut in the USC, more nurses and doctors for the health service, more affordable and quality child care and an end to the unfair treatment of the self-employed. These are sensible, affordable steps that will keep the recovery going and bring its benefits to every family.
The economy is growing strongly, with 1,100 jobs being created on average every week. The public finances are in a strong position and we will exit the corrective arm of the Stability and Growth Pact this year. The banking system has been strengthened, with domestically focused, well capitalised banks operating within a European-wide banking union. Most important, our people and our country are in a much stronger and certain position than in 2011 when this Government took office. The Irish people gave this Government the task of fixing a broken economy and getting Ireland working again. We put in place a plan and the people stuck with us. It is a testament to the commitment and resilience of the Irish people that Ireland is on course to be the fastest growing economy in Europe for a second consecutive year.
Both parties in government, Fine Gael and the Labour Party, know that the job of recovery is not yet complete. Though strong, the recovery remains fragile and the benefits of a growing economy have not yet been felt inside the door of every family. We must keep the recovery going and provide relief and better services for the people. We must not gamble with the future. The Government will not take chances that destabilise the recovery.
To raise living standards for all citizens in the medium term, we need to boost productivity, foster innovation and remove barriers to employment. We must invest in the critical infrastructure needed in a modern economy and our plans to do so are set out in the Government’s capital investment framework, Building on Recovery. We must create the conditions in which new ideas, innovation and entrepreneurship will be encouraged, leading to increased long-term growth and well-being. We must ensure work pays.
This is the final budget of the 31st Dáil, but it is also the start of a new series of budgets in which we start to meet these challenges.
Economic and fiscal position
The economy has been transformed. It is growing strongly across all sectors and, most importantly, sustaining and creating jobs. It has recovered all of the output lost during the crisis and is bigger than ever before in our history. Ireland is forecast to be the fastest growing economy in Europe again in 2015 and my Department is forecasting growth at 6.2% in 2015. This forecast has been endorsed by the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council. The Department of Finance is forecasting growth of 4.3% in 2016 taking account of the figures endorsed by the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council and the full impact of today's overall budget package. Economic growth is expected to average around 3% per annum thereafter.
Risk
Despite the strong economic position emerging, we must remember that Ireland is a small and open economy and that there are international concerns about the outlook for the global economy. These risks which are discussed in the Economic and Fiscal Outlook of the budget inform our policy choices. This emphasises the importance of managing the public finances and the economy prudently.
Labour market
Some 130,000 more people are now in work than at the low point in 2012 and this growth in employment is spread across the vast majority of the sectors of the economy. The Action Plan for Jobs, the Pathways to Work initiative and the strategy in successive budgets of focusing resources on small and medium enterprises in key sectors of the economy such as agriculture, tourism and construction are supporting businesses to create new jobs. The pursuit of foreign direct investment means that Ireland continues to attract and retain a higher proportion, relative to our size, of new jobs and investment than any other European country.
The 53,000 new jobs forecast to be created this year will bring the number in employment close to 1.97 million people by the end of the year and the Department of Finance is forecasting that 48,000 jobs will be created in 2016. This will bring the total number of people in work in Ireland to just over 2 million. We are on track to recover all of the jobs lost and have more people working in Ireland by the end of this decade than ever before.
Importantly, unemployment continues to fall. My Department is forecasting that the unemployment rate will fall to 8% by the end of 2016, down from 9.4% now and the peak of over 15% in 2012, a significant improvement but still too high. Unemployment is forecast to drop to 6.25% by 2021.
Public finances
The public finances continue to improve, with a broad and growing tax base, providing stable funding for vital public services. Our reformed budgetary framework and fiscal rules are designed to protect the public finances and ensure the mistakes of the past will not be repeated. The National Economic Dialogue held in Dublin Castle last July has helped to frame the policy choices in the budget.
The forecast deficit for 2015 of 2.1% is well ahead of our original target of 2.7% and our excessive deficit requirement of less than 3% of gross domestic product, GDP. Consequently, we will exit the corrective arm of the Stability and Growth Pact and move into the preventive arm of the pact. The Government has consigned to the history books the days of boom and bust and the attitude of "if I have it, I'll spend it."
My Department forecasts that we will balance the books in headline terms in 2018 with balance in structural terms following in 2019. While headline deficits will continue to reduce, the anchor for fiscal policy is now a balanced budget in structural terms. This is our medium term objective and in 2016 we will make significant progress towards this target with the structural balance reducing by 0.8% of GDP, ahead of the 0.6% requirement of the Stability and Growth Pact.
This fiscal stance will enable the Government to comply with the fiscal rules and introduce a total budget package of €1.5 billion; to reduce the headline deficit to 1.2% of GDP; and to reduce the debt to just under 93% of GDP, just slightly below the eurozone average.
The benefits of this Government’s approach to managing the public finances can be seen in expenditure and revenue trends. Between the end of 2014 and the end of 2016, my Department is forecasting that the economy will grow by 18% in nominal terms with revenue from taxation and PRSI increasing by just under €7.2 billion or 14.7%, while gross voted expenditure will increase by €2.25 billion or 4.2%. This sustained difference between our revenue and expenditure growth rates is why we will reduce the deficit from 3.9% of GDP in 2014 to 2.1% in 2015 and to 1.2% next year.
Against this background, talk of an excessively expansionary budget is well off the mark.
Reducing the high debt levels
The high level of Ireland’s debt has been an obvious risk to our economic progress in recent years. We are moving into a much better position now and having peaked at over 120% of GDP in 2012, general government debt is forecast to drop to 97% of GDP in 2015. Following the introduction of the budget, as I have outlined, the debt will fall to just under 93% of GDP by the end of 2016, just below the European average.
Taking account of cash and liquid assets, including those held by the NTMA and the Ireland Strategic Investment Fund, our net debt position will be 80% of GDP by the end of this year.
This debt level, while sustainable, remains too high and remains our biggest internal risk. Debt reduction is a critical goal as building fiscal capacity or an ability to borrow is the best way to mitigate the risks of crises as yet unforeseen and undreamt of.
This Government has made significant progress in reducing both the size and cost of servicing the national debt. In addition to bringing the public finances under control, specific initiatives such as the promissory note transaction, the extension of maturities on our EU loans and the early repayment of the IMF loans, have also resulted in real and substantial savings to the Irish taxpayer. The interest cost of the general government debt is forecast to drop below €7 billion in 2015. It is worth recalling upon entering office it was estimated that interest costs for 2015 would be in excess of €10 billion.
The economic and fiscal outlook section in the budget book forecasts that the debt to GDP ratio should be below 80% of GDP by 2021, with the exact level depending on the fiscal stance pursued over that period. This forecast does not take account of the value of the State’s shareholdings in AIB, Bank of Ireland and Permanent TSB. These shares are now valuable assets belonging to the taxpayer and I remain confident, based on the best advice available to me at this time, that we will recoup the investment the taxpayer has made in these institutions.
The proceeds from the sale of the shareholdings in these banks will be used to reduce the debt levels further and there will be a major impact on the debt level when these assets are sold and the proceeds are used for this purpose.
I will now turn to the specific tax measures of the budget.
The budget package includes €750 million in revenue relieving measures in 2016. This cost is partially offset by a single revenue raising measure, specifically the excise duty on a pack of 20 cigarettes is being increased by 50 cent, including VAT, with a pro rata increase on other tobacco products.
Comment on this
This public health measure will take effect from midnight tonight and will bring the price of cigarettes in the most popular price category to €10.50.
This measure will raise €61.4 million in a full year and the additional revenue will enable the funding of new initiatives in the health sector to support young families with children. This is the only tax increase in this budget.
Making work pay
Creating jobs and rewarding work is a key driver of growth and prosperity in the economy. More important, it is essential to ensure the benefits of a growing economy are felt inside the door of every family in the country. Just under 2 million people in Ireland have a job and by the end of the decade we hope we will have more people at work in Ireland than ever before. It is critical that work pays for every family. The Taoiseach has set out a key objective for the years ahead of ensuring that every family is better off and in employment. However, we must strike the right balance between rewarding work for the very lowest paid and keeping the tax base as broad as possible. This was a key issue discussed during the national economic dialogue.
The many barriers to taking up employment include taxation, wage levels for the low paid and childcare costs, which have a very negative impact on female participation in the labour force. These three issues are also barriers to growth and investment and are discouraging many of our young people who have emigrated from returning home. In budget 2016 we have put a particular emphasis on addressing these challenges. I will address the taxation issues and my colleague, the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, Deputy Howlin, will address the other two issues, namely, the issue of low-paid workers and affordable child care costs.
The changes I introduced in budget 2015 resulted in every worker in Ireland receiving increases in his or her pay this year. For many, this was the first increase in years. I also supported job creation across the economy. Focusing the majority of the available resources for tax reductions on low and middle-income families was the right thing to do last year. By reducing the marginal rate of tax for people earning less than €70,000, workers kept more money in their pocket. I will continue with this approach this year.
From 1 January, I am increasing the entry threshold to universal social charge from €12,012 to €13,000, removing approximately 42,500 workers from the scope of the charge entirely. It is estimated that more than 700,000 income earners will not be liable for universal social charge at all from next year. I am also reducing the three lowest rates of universal social charge. I am reducing the 1.5% rate to 1%. This applies on the first €12,012 of income. I am reducing the 3.5% rate to 3%. This applies on income in excess of €12,012 up to an increased threshold of €18,668. I am reducing the 7% rate to 5.5%. This applies on income in excess of €18,668 up to €70,044. This will reduce the marginal rate of tax to 49.5% for all earners under €70,044. This is the first time that the marginal rate has dropped below 50% for middle-income earners since the supplementary budget in April 2009. I am retaining the exemption from the top rate of USC for all medical card holders and those over-70 earning less than €60,000. This group, of course, will benefit from the reduction in the second USC rate to 3% from 3.5%.
As with the measures I introduced in budget 2015, I have crafted these measures to restrict the benefit to people’s incomes up to €70,000 per annum. People with higher incomes will not receive any benefit on their income above €70,000 but, of course, will benefit on the portion of their income below that level.
Supporting single-income families
I am also announcing an increase to the home carer's tax credit of €190 to bring it to €1,000 per year to assist single-income married couples with children and those who care for an elderly or incapacitated relative. The income threshold up to which the home carer can earn has also been increased by €2,120. This measure will help lower-income families by allowing the home carer to earn up to €7,200 and still benefit in full from the tax credit.
These changes mean that every worker and every pensioner who currently pays income tax or USC, or both, will benefit from today’s budget changes, taking account of the tax and expenditure measures.
There are many examples given in the documents accompanying the budget but to mention some now, a one income family with two children earning €35,000 will see their take home pay increase by €57 a month due to this budget, which is €684 per annum; a single person working full time on the minimum wage, earning €17,542, will see an increase of 4.2% or €708 a year;-----
Comment on this
-----a family with three children with parents working in two public service jobs earning €55,000 and €50,000, respectively, will have an additional €196 per month in their pocket, which is in excess of €2,300 for the family; and a self-employed worker earning €40,000 will see a gain of €1,002 in his or her annual net income due to this budget, which is an increase of 3.5%.
The average increase is 1.8% of income. If people are wondering how much they will gain, it will be approximately a full extra week's wages at all points of income. It is an easy way of assessing what the income gain might be. It is an additional week's wages for all workers. These changes enhance the progressivity of our income tax system, with the top 1% of income earners estimated to pay 22% of all income tax and USC collected. In contrast, the bottom 75% of income earners will pay 19% of the total.
Keeping the benefits of minimum wage increases in workers pockets
The Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, Deputy Howlin, will announce the Government’s decision relating to the recommendations of the Low Pay Commission. The PRSI system as currently structured resulted in a situation where an employee could receive a pay increase in the minimum wage but find themselves with less money. Following the publication of the report of the Low Pay Commission, the Government committed to taking action to address this step effect in the PRSI system.
I am introducing a tapered PRSI credit with a maximum level of €12 per week or €624 in annualised terms to alleviate the step effect across a range of incomes. This change will ensure that low income earners will see a significant improvement in net incomes, arising from the announcement which will be made shortly by my colleague, Deputy Howlin.
For employer PRSI, I am increasing the entry point to the top rate of 10.75% by €20 per week to €376 per week. All of the PRSI changes will be brought forward by the Minister for Social Protection in the social welfare Bill.
Capital acquisitions tax
Capital acquisitions tax thresholds were reduced considerably over the period of the financial crisis and at a time of falling asset prices to help maintain the yield from capital taxes.
In recognition of the recovery in asset prices, particularly property and the family home, I have decided to increase the group A tax-free threshold, which broadly applies to transfers between parents and their children, from €225,000 to €280,000.
Local property tax
I will be making a proposal to Government to postpone the revaluation date for the local property tax from 2016 to 2019. This is one of the recommendations in the review of the local property tax submitted to me by Dr. Don Thornhill, which is being published online today.
The postponement of the revaluation date means that home owners will not be faced with significant increases in their LPT in 2017 as a result of increased property values, and it gives sufficient time for the other recommendations in the Thornhill report to be considered in full. Legislation to implement the postponement will be brought forward in due course.
Exemptions for properties significantly affected by pyrite
Regarding exemptions for properties significantly affected by pyrite, I am accepting the recommendations made by Dr. Thornhill. Accordingly, I have asked the Revenue Commissioners to agree to a change in LPT procedures on an administrative basis, pending the implementation of necessary legislative amendments. Full details are included in the review.
Pension fund levy
Deputies may recall that the Government introduced a pension fund levy to finance the reduced rate of VAT and the other measures in the jobs initiative that I presented to the House in 2011, shortly after taking office. The pension fund levy has done its job and is no longer needed to fund the 9% VAT rate because it is more than made up by increased activity and employment, particularly in the hospitality sector.
Therefore, I can confirm that the remaining pension fund levy of 0.15%, introduced for 2014 and 2015, will end this year and not apply to 2016. The original 0.6% levy, as Deputies will recall, ended in 2014.
Extension of bank levy to 2021
I turn now to the bank levy. The current financial institutions levy which I originally introduced for the three-year period from 2014 to 2016 allows for a contribution from the banking sector to the economic recovery. The levy which brings in €150 million per annum is currently calculated on the basis of DIRT payments made in 2011. I propose to extend the bank levy to 2021, subject to a review taking place of the methodology used to calculate the levy. This measure will bring in an additional €750 million over the period, a very significant additional contribution to the Exchequer. The scale of the levy over the period is equivalent, for example, to the cost of the new national children’s hospital.
Encouraging entrepreneurs and supporting small business owners
Small and medium enterprises right across the country are critical to our economic well-being and, in the business community, account for 99.7% of all enterprises and 68% of all employment, some 730,000 jobs. All of these SMEs are being run by entrepreneurs. We will need to encourage new entrepreneurs and support existing entrepreneurs.
Earlier this year I launched a public consultation seeking the views of Irish entrepreneurs on additional tax measures we could take to sustain the progress we have made to date and keep the recovery going. Income tax, as currently structured, means that an employee will take home a greater proportion of their salary than a small business owner or entrepreneur on the same gross income. This disparity was raised frequently during the public consultation process. To start addressing this disparity, I am introducing today an earned income tax credit to the value of €550. It will be available to those with earned income who do not have access to the PAYE credit. This will be a significant benefit to small business owners right across the country, including small retailers, publicans, farmers and tradesmen. I see this measure as a first step and further steps will be taken in future budgets, as resources permit.
Capital gains tax was also highlighted as an issue during the consultation process. Successful entrepreneurs often look for new challenges. To assist them and reward their hard work, I am introducing a revised capital gains tax relief from 1 January 2016. Rather than the 33% rate which applies now, a reduced capital gains tax rate of 20% will apply to the disposal in whole or in part of a business, up to an overall limit of €1 million in chargeable gains. The relief will represent a simplified and up-front benefit for individuals who propose to sell their business.
Based on the findings of a review of the three-year tax relief for certain start-up companies, I propose to extend this relief in its current form for a further three years until the end of 2018. The relief has been identified by entrepreneurs as an important support. The review which is being published today found that, in 2013, the relief supported 1,038 companies, which employ 11,750 people at an estimated cost of €4.9 million.
Continuing to build strong sectors
In the past four years I introduced and extended a wide range of targeted tax measures to promote the growth of new enterprises and sustain existing ones. These supply side initiatives assisted the rebuilding of the economy, sector by sector. An economy built on a number of strong sectors is more stable, more resilient and less susceptible to shocks. One key lesson we have learned from the most recent crisis is the danger of an over-reliance on one sector for growth, jobs and taxation. I am continuing this approach this year.
Tourism sector
The reduction in VAT to 9% in the tourism sector and the abolition of the air travel tax improved Ireland competitiveness. The benefit of these policies can be seen in tourist numbers, new businesses, the survival of established businesses and, most of all, employment. The 9% VAT rate is a major benefit to the tourism sector and much sought after by other sectors of the economy.
While the case for retaining the measure for the hotel sector in Dublin is diminishing each year, with room rates rising, particularly during major events, the case for retention of the measure for the rest of the country remains. Therefore, I will not be making any change to the 9% VAT rate in this budget.
The agri-food sector
I have often stated how important the farming and agrifood sector is to the economy. It is not just the sheer economic importance of a sector that is responsible for over 12% of our exports and 169,000 jobs, it is the fact that this economic activity and these jobs are located the length and breadth of the country. Consequently, I am announcing the extension of the general stock relief, the stock relief for young trained farmers, the stock relief for registered farm partnerships and the stamp duty exemption for young trained farmers for a further three years to the end of 2018.
I am introducing a new succession transfer proposal to provide increased certainty about the timing of the transfer of a family farm to the next generation of farmers. This will greatly assist with long-term planning and farm productivity. The proposal which is subject to state aid approval will allow two people, for example, family members, to enter into a partnership with an appropriate profit sharing agreement which makes provision for the transfer of the farm to the younger farmer at the end of a specified period, not exceeding ten years. To support this transfer, an income tax credit worth up to €5,000 per annum for five years will be allocated to the partnership and split according to the profit sharing agreement.
Micro-breweries
The production of drinks is an increasingly important sub-sector of the agrifood sector. Last year I increased the amount of beer that micro-breweries could produce and still qualify for this excise relief. To further assist this development, the relief will now be available up front, thus reducing the cash flow burden of the current rebate scheme.
Supporting retailers by reducing costs and incentivising electronic payments
Retailers have had great difficulty during the recession and are probably the last group to pull out of it. I wish to support retailers and other merchants by reducing costs and incentivising electronic payments. Payments are the lifeblood of a modern economy and the national payments plan aims to modernise payment practices and help Ireland to take full advantage of modern payment methods. Many retailers and service providers have made significant investments in their electronic payment systems, with debit card and contactless payment facilities available in nearly all shops, restaurants and pubs. The improvements in mobile technology mean that the majority of service providers and sales people can also now offer their customers the option of paying by card. This has benefited retailers, consumers and the wider economy.
However, retailers in Ireland currently face excessive fees for accepting card payments. This needs to be addressed. A new EU regulation is halving the so-called interchange fees faced by retailers to 30 basis points for credit cards. I am today halving the corresponding fee for debit cards to ten basis points. These changes significantly reduce the costs of accepting card payments and, combined, these reductions will save retailers an estimated €36 million in fees per year. These changes will come into effect on 9 December this year. It is important that this saving be passed on to the consumer in lower prices and this new fee regime will be monitored closely to ensure this happens.
In parallel, the transaction limit on contactless payment cards is being raised from €15 to €30 on 31 October. Together with the reduction in bank fees, retailers should now be able to end practices such as requiring a minimum payment for card use. To further encourage and incentivise greater usage of card payment by consumers, I will recast the €5 stamp duty levy on debit and ATM cards. From 1 January 2016, this stamp duty will be removed and replaced with a 12c charge per ATM transaction. There will be no charge for debit card transactions. No consumer will lose out as a result of this change as the stamp duty will be capped at the existing levels of €2.50 or €5, depending on card type.
Supporting businesses in Ireland by reducing transportation costs
Almost every business in Ireland is reliant on transportation by road for its raw materials and to get its product to the market. As a result, transportation costs are a major issue for every business in Ireland, big and small. To keep Ireland competitive and help businesses, I have decided to significantly reduce the commercial motor tax rates.
Road tax for large goods vehicles in Ireland is too high by comparison with the regime applying in Northern Ireland and the rest of the UK. This is causing distortions in the haulage industry and increasing costs across the economy. I am simplifying the rates of commercial motor tax by replacing the 20 existing rates with just five rates of commercial motor tax, ranging from €92 to €900 with effect from 1 January 2016. Over 28,500 commercial vehicles will benefit from these reductions. The most significant reductions are concentrated on the larger goods vehicles. The maximum rate of commercial motor tax will be €900 per annum whereas the maximum at present is €5,195.
Comment on this
This should help with transport costs across the country.
This is an interim measure pending the replacement of the current commercial motor tax regime with a fairer basis for calculating commercial motor tax, which will be based on the gross design vehicle weight of the goods vehicles.
Film relief
Ireland has a significant opportunity as a location for the production of films and television programmes. Having reviewed the film tax credit, I am increasing the cap on the eligible expenditure to €70 million. This limit will be kept under review going forward. It is my hope that the industry will now make the necessary investments in studio space in order to attract high quality films and create new jobs. This change is subject to state aid approval.
Fostering innovation
As I have outlined, fostering innovation in Ireland will be critical to our new economic model. To incentivise substantive research and development and innovation, as committed to last year, I will introduce in the Finance Bill a knowledge development box, KDB. This will be the first OECD-compliant KDB in the world. This puts Ireland in a unique position to offer long-term certainty to innovative industries planning their research and development investments.
Income that qualifies for the KDB will be subject to a reduced rate of corporation tax of 6.25%. The KDB adds a further dimension to our "best in class" competitive corporation tax offering, which includes the 12.5% headline rate; the research and development tax credit; and the intangible asset regime. This significant enhancement to our corporation tax regime shows Ireland’s ability to retain our core strengths, while keeping a keen competitive edge in attracting and retaining quality jobs and investment in our country.
International tax strategy
Today I am publishing an update on our international tax strategy. This update explains our approach to the implementation of the OECD base erosion and profit shifting reports and how we will engage with the emerging EU tax agenda. Ireland is well positioned to compete in this international environment. Our corporation tax system is transparent and statute based. Our long-standing policy has been to align our tax system with substantial economic activity, investment and jobs. To enhance transparency, we will provide in the Finance Bill for the introduction of country by country reporting, in line with the OECD recommendations.
Independent review of marine taxation supports
The budget book contains details of various reviews. This includes the independent review of marine taxation supports that I am publishing today and my officials will be examining the proposals in conjunction with the relevant Departments, with a view to establishing the feasibility of their implementation in future budgets and in the forthcoming Finance Bill.
Employment and investment incentive scheme
I announced changes to the employment and investment incentive scheme last year subject to compliance with European state aid provisions. The changes I am making ensure this compliance, so with effect from midnight tonight, the amount of finance that can be raised by a company is doubled to €5 million annually subject to a lifetime maximum of €15 million, up from €10 million. The scheme is also being improved by allowing investments in the extension, management and operation of nursing homes, and all eligible small and medium-sized enterprises can qualify for the scheme irrespective of geographical location.
Increasing the supply of residential housing
It is clear that there is a market failure in the provision of new housing across the country but particularly in Dublin. Driven by demographic demands and strong economic growth, there is a requirement for a minimum of 10,000 new units per annum in the Dublin area but the market only delivered 3,300 units in the last year. In line with the NAMA Act, I asked the NAMA board to review the residential sites under its control and to estimate what it could deliver on a commercial basis in terms of residential units over the next five years, consistent with NAMA’s mandate to deliver the best financial return to the taxpayer.
Comment on this
It is only Deputy Mattie McGrath.
Comment on this
Are they social houses that NAMA will build?
Comment on this
What a disgrace. Commercial houses - brilliant.
Comment on this
In response, NAMA is aiming to deliver a target of 20,000 residential units before the end of 2020. Some 90% of these units will be in the greater Dublin area. About 75% of these units will be houses, mainly starter homes. NAMA will deliver these units by working with developers. Achieving this new target by the end of 2020 means delivering on average 80 new housing units every week across some 100 active sites. The Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform and the Minister for the Environment, Community and Local Government will deal very effectively with the question of social housing. The Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform has allocated €3.8 billion for the provision of social housing across the local authorities. The NAMA commitment will require funding of the order of €4.5 billion, which will all be recovered, and will support 30,000 house building and ancillary jobs based on peak funding. This initiative will not compromise NAMA's debt repayment commitments.
Conclusion
As we look forward and plan for 2016 and the years ahead, the opportunity now exists to build an economy that delivers secure and well-paid jobs, incomes and pensions, world-class infrastructure, high-quality public services and certainty - certainty about the future, no more booms and busts. Every measure in this budget is designed to grow the economy, create additional jobs and increase living standards. When implemented, the measures will deliver real benefits, boost confidence across the country and give families the prospect of a stable future with living standards increasing steadily year by year.
To further increase confidence and to enhance the stability that is so essential to growth and prosperity, I would like to indicate how today's announcement will be further developed if we are returned to Government. As resources become available, we will progressively abolish the USC to reward work and reduce the marginal rate of tax to no more than 50% for all workers to make Ireland more attractive for mobile foreign investment and skills and to ensure that our tax rates are not inhibiting our young emigrants from returning home. Second, we will complete tax equalisation for the self-employed and other measures to support job creators. Third, we will increase public spending within a reformed public service, built on a solid platform of steady economic growth. Fourth, we will promote innovation as a driver of economic growth. Lastly, we will defend our 12.5% corporation tax rate and promote innovation as the linchpin of our jobs policy, underpinned by strong alliances with our European partners.
The budget I have announced today will help to secure the recovery. It will provide stability to families across the country. It will reward work, enterprise and innovation. It will provide the resources for investment in essential public services. It will provide working families with more money in their pockets and high-quality public services. It will give Irish people the certainty of a better future but more important than anything else, it will keep the recovery going. I commend this budget to the House.
Comment on this
I call the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, Deputy Howlin, to make his Budget Statement. Could Deputies please be silent while he presents it?
Comment on this
Today we are announcing this Government’s fifth budget.
I am pleased to report that, due to our strong recovery and stable public finances, it is the second budget in succession in which we are able to increase support for our public services.
The days of spending cuts are behind us. In April, in the spring economic statement, I said that there may be up to €750 million available next year for additional public expenditure measures. I am happy to say today that we are now in a position to allocate that money.
It is worth remembering the distance we have travelled since 2011. When the Government was elected, the budget deficit stood at 12.5% of GDP. This year it will be 2.1%. In 2010, the year of the infamous promissory notes, the headline deficit rate stood at 30%, a staggering deficit.
Comment on this
The Government may burn the bondholders.
Comment on this
The Minister should sit down and take his medicine.
Comment on this
There is a long tradition in this House that when Ministers stand at budget time to make their statements we pay them the courtesy of listening to them. The Deputies should stay quiet and cut out the comedian stuff.
Comment on this
Next year, notwithstanding the increases I am announcing today, the forecast deficit will be 1.2% of GDP, one of the lowest in Europe. Only a few years ago, some commentators questioned the sustainability of our debt. As the Minister for Finance has stated, from a peak of over 120%, next year our debt to GDP ratio is forecast to be 93%, that is below the European average. We have made tremendous progress in bringing our national debt down towards European norms. Unemployment, which peaked at over 15%, is now 9.4%.
Comment on this
We have created over 130,000 jobs since 2012. We have the highest level of economic growth in the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, OECD. Our economy is now larger than it was at the pre-crisis peak. By any standards, we have witnessed in the past four and a half years a remarkable turnaround, a tribute to the resilience of the Irish people.
Fairness
I want to deal with one issue that generates considerable debate. It has become popular among some to say that under this Government, inequality has risen. That is simply not true.
Comment on this
It is true. The Minister should go down the road and find out.
Comment on this
Let us hear the facts. There are some economic illiterates-----
Comment on this
Members should listen to the facts. Our adjustment has been a difficult one, but it has been a fair one. Those with the most have given the most. Income inequality after taxes and social transfers has reduced during the crisis in Ireland. The progressivity of our income tax system means we have been one of the most effective countries in the OECD at reducing inequality. To ignore this fact and to point to income inequality before tax transfers is to ignore the central role of any Government, to protect the most vulnerable of our citizens.
The best weapon against inequality is not social welfare. It is decent jobs and fair wages. A fair society is one where those who work hard receive decent rewards. One of the first acts of this Government was to reverse-----
Comment on this
-----the unnecessary and cruel €1 per hour cut to the minimum wage introduced by our predecessors-----
Comment on this
-----a cut of over 11%. In July of this year, the Low Pay Commission recommended that the minimum wage be increased further, by 50 cent to over €9 per hour. The commission recognised that a recovery based on low wages was no recovery at all. Today, I am pleased to confirm that the Government will implement the commission’s proposal. From 1 January 2016, the statutory minimum wage will rise from €8.65 to €9.15 per hour. This means that under this Government the minimum wage has been increased by nearly 20%. This Government is committed to making work pay.
During the first three years of this Government, despite necessary reductions in public expenditure, resources were targeted where they were most needed. We protected core social welfare benefits. I am especially proud that we maintained the State pension. Since the beginning of 2012, we have invested more than €1.25 billion in school buildings. We have built 102 new schools and completed 71 large-scale school extensions. We did more in the worst of times than our predecessors did in the best of times. Despite huge pressure, we sought to protect the young, the old and the vulnerable but we are conscious of the need to continue to address the challenges that face Irish families. Our aim is to ensure the recovery is felt in every home and in every community across the land. Later, I will outline the measures contained in this budget which will help us achieve that objective.
Fiscal rules
First, however, I repeat the context in which all budgetary decisions must now be made. The fiscal rules - ratified through referendum by our people in 2012 - ensure that public expenditure cannot rise above the potential growth rate of our economy. Our commitments under the Stability and Growth Pact are real.
In 2015, economic growth and greater than expected tax receipts have allowed the Government to improve services in a number of key areas. While remaining firmly within the fiscal parameters, we have had an opportunity to plan for the long term by targeting areas with demographic and demand pressures. The extra funding allocated this year will ensure that enough resources are also available for all Departments to provide quality services next year.
The measures give us a platform from which we can build. They mean that resources will be directed at areas with the greatest need and are consistent with long-term sustainable planning and development.
National economic dialogue
At the national economic dialogue in July, we listened to employers, trade unions, community organisations and many more. Our engagement with these groups helped to ensure that additional funding would be targeted at areas in which they would have the greatest impact. The spending measures contained in Budget 2016 are consistent with that approach.
Lansdowne Road agreement
The Lansdowne Road agreement typifies our commitment to responsible expenditure management. Legally, pay reductions in the public sector were predicated on there being a financial emergency. Thankfully, those emergency days are receding behind us. Therefore, an orderly unwinding of the financial emergency legislation which reduced pay is the prudent and correct thing to do. Moreover, as economic growth returns and private sector wages increase, it is only right that our nurses, gardaí, teachers and public servants generally see an improvement in their take home pay. During the crisis, their sacrifices allowed us to sustain quality public services. Efficient public services are essential to a modern society. When we came into office, reform of the public service was a key component of our strategy to meet the enormous challenges we faced. I am proud of the considerable reforms we have delivered since 2011. I commend public servants for their effort and commitment in this regard. I believe that the implementation of our Civil Service renewal plan and the wider programme of public service reform will continue to be a key driver of Ireland’s recovery. Unwinding the financial emergency legislation can only be done in a way that does not jeopardise our public finances. We learned the hard way that sustainability is the key to progress. Pay levels, like the public finances, need to be managed in a responsible, sustainable way, with the long-term interests of all our people at their core.
Expenditure ceilings
The expenditure allocations outlined today reflect this approach. In 2016, gross current expenditure will be over €51.4 billion. Capital expenditure will be an additional €3.7 billion.
Capital plan
The departmental ceilings in the documentation before the House include funding for the first year of expenditure on projects announced as part of the six-year capital programme, which we published in recent weeks. That €27 billion Exchequer investment will allow for large-scale investment in education, health, transport and all other sectors.
Current expenditure
Under current expenditure, allocations will target critical needs in child care, education, social protection, employment, health and housing. Multi-annual ceilings allow Departments to plan ahead. They take account of new measures and provide for population growth across our country. In line with economic growth, and within the parameters of the fiscal rules, planned public expenditure will rise again moderately in 2017 and 2018.
Child care
Child care is a key priority for Government. At the national economic dialogue in July and, indeed, in a range of reports published in this area, there was broad agreement on the need to focus on the issues of affordability and quality in relation to child care. Investment in child care has both social and economic returns. It acts as a key labour activation measure, particularly for women, allowing those who wish to work to take up the opportunity of work. It improves educational and social outcomes by providing our children with the best possible start. I am, therefore, increasing the current expenditure allocation to the Department of Children and Youth Affairs to over €1.1 billion.
I am happy to say that the increased allocation allows me to bring forward a package of measures to ease the burden on working families. We are extending the amount of time parents can avail of the very successful early childhood care and education scheme. From now on, children will be eligible for free child care from three years of age up until they are five and a half, or until they start primary school.
Comment on this
I am particularly pleased to be able to announce over €15 million in new funding to facilitate the full participation of children with disabilities in this scheme. We are also introducing a range of quality measures for early education, including audits, inspections and training, and restoring capitation levels in the sector.
To support parents in low-paid employment, we are going further. We are creating 8,000 places through the community child care subvention programme. To help with after school care, we are providing €3 million to develop school services in existing school buildings. Last year, I said that if circumstances allowed, we would increase child benefit by €5. I am happy to say that our success in reducing unemployment allows me to do this. In 2016, child benefit will be €140 per month for every child. Finally, to recognise the needs of modern families and the role of fathers in the household, I am happy to announce that we will legislate for statutory paternity leave of two weeks. This change will take affect from next September. The improvement in our public finances has given us the opportunity to assist hard-working parents. The package announced today will be of particular help to working mothers and by increasing participation in the labour force, these measures will also be a key contributor to economic growth.
Education
I am allocating €8.5 billion to education for current expenditure next year. Education depends on educators. Teachers have the capacity to transform a child's life. The quality of our teachers is consistently recognised in OECD comparisons. Education is also the engine of economic growth. Our teachers have a big responsibility. They teach the citizens of tomorrow. We have an excellent cadre of highly qualified young people coming into the teaching profession and I am pleased that the job openings they feared would not be there are now materialising. I can confirm that the allocation for 2016 will provide for over 2,260 new additional teaching posts, including 600 new resource teachers. This is in addition to the extra 610 special needs assistants and 190 resource teachers we already announced for next year.
We will also reduce the pupil-teacher ratio. At primary level, we are reducing it from 28:1 to 27:1 and at second level, it will fall from 19:1 to 18.7:1. Over the past five years, we have supported education. As our public finances improve, we will continue to invest in and develop this important sector.
Social protection
I am allocating €19.6 billion to the Department of Social Protection next year. Within this allocation, I am particularly anxious to protect and support our older citizens. We will, therefore, increase all pension payments by €3 per week from the start of next year. This is the first increase since 2009.
Comment on this
I remind Deputy Mattie McGrath that the only actual cut in pensions was voted for by him under Fianna Fáil. To help the thousands of men and women who take care of their loved ones with dignity and compassion, I am restoring the value of the respite care grant to €1,700.
Comment on this
I am also pleased to announce that we are increasing the fuel allowance by €2.50 per week to €22.50. This increase will benefit people dependent on long-term social welfare payments and those unable to provide for their own heating needs.
A shared prosperity is one where every person, regardless of income, feels the benefit of our new recovery. To complement the changes in the universal social charge that help the low paid, as announced by the Minister for Finance, we are increasing the threshold for the family income supplement by €5 per week for families with one child, and by €10 per week for families with two or more children. Together with the rise in the minimum wage, this budget confirms our commitment to helping the low paid. We want to make work pay.
Finally, our strong record of reducing unemployment and restoring the public finances means that this year we can increase the Christmas bonus for all those in receipt of social welfare to 75%, a threefold increase on last year's payment. The Tánaiste will announce further details of the social welfare package later today.
Jobs/enterprise
The best form of social protection is a job. The reduction in unemployment from a peak of 15.2% to 9.4% has been this Government's single biggest achievement but this is still too high. Budget 2016 will support greater and accelerated job creation. Total funding for the Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation will be €792 million. Some 385,000 Irish jobs, around one in five, are in businesses supported by our enterprise agencies. Under the capital plan, a further €500 million will be provided next year to support these agencies. Many of the businesses they support are at the forefront of research and innovation. They create well-paid jobs and enhance opportunities for young graduates and the unemployed. A key focus of activity next year is to ensure that the benefits of economic recovery, particularly in terms of employment, reach all parts of the country. In this regard, a specific IDA regional property programme will support the regional action plans launched by my colleague, the Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation, in recent months.
Comment on this
It should have happened two years ago.
Comment on this
The Deputy is obviously not focused on what is happening in the real world.
Health
I am providing €13.2 billion for the delivery of health services next year. I am happy to say that this quantum of money restores the resourcing of our health services to its pre-crisis level.
Comment on this
There are no excuses for incompetence, then.
Comment on this
This year, free GP care for the under-sixes and over-70s was put in place, one of the most innovative things to happen in the health service in recent years. This represented the first step in the phased introduction of a universal GP service and is already benefitting 300,000 senior citizens and children.
Linked to this was the introduction of cycles of care for those with type-2 diabetes and asthma. Next year, subject to successful negotiation with doctors' representatives, it is planned to extend GP care without fees to all children under 12.
Comment on this
The Government should give it to the sickest.
Comment on this
This marks the next phase in the implementation of universal GP care.
Funding is also being made available next year to provide therapeutic services for children, particularly for speech and language therapy. Over 2 million children are now covered by a medical or GP-visit card. This is 25% more than in 2010 and substantially improves people’s access to primary care services.
In our hospitals, 880,000 day-cases will be carried out by the end of the year, an increase of nearly 20% over the past five years.
This year, for the first time, the Government placed the fair deal nursing home scheme on a fully funded, demand-led basis. This will continue next year, with Government funding of €940 million for the fair deal alone. Everyone who needs fair deal funding will have approval within four weeks.
Comment on this
We have also protected front-line staff numbers. This may come as a surprise to some Deputies in the House. Since the beginning of last year, hospital staffing has increased by 3,000. Since the beginning of last year we have hired 1,000 additional nurses.
Comment on this
As our recovery continues, we will continue to support and expand our health services.
Housing
One of the worst legacies of the economic crisis is our dysfunctional housing market. Years of underinvestment in social housing has led to an accommodation crisis, particularly in our main urban areas. Last year, the Government announced a €2.2 billion package to begin to deal with this legacy. The package was a multiannual investment aimed at addressing more than a decade of neglect. Under our social housing strategy, over €500 million is available this year to build or acquire new homes.
Comment on this
I am also increasing the current allocation for social housing by a further €69 million, to €414 million. This funding will enable local authorities to secure accommodation for a further 14,000 households. I am keen to make use of all available funding to address immediate housing needs. So, pending further developments on the special purpose vehicle that we announced, I am making €10 million available from the proceeds of the sale of Bord Gáis Éireann for an affordable housing pilot scheme. This will be an ongoing annual commitment to secure long-term increases in the housing supply.
The human cost of the legacy of boom-and-bust housing development is the number of people without a home. Addressing homelessness, particularly among families, is a key Government priority. Under the capital plan announced recently, funding is available to provide 500 modular housing units for homeless families as an emergency measure.
Comment on this
I am also increasing the current allocation for emergency accommodation of homeless people, by an additional €17 million.
Comment on this
The increase will bring Exchequer support to €70 million, up 56% since 2014, and will help homeless families make the transition to long-term sustainable housing.
Arts and heritage
The year 2016 will be an historic year for our country. It is right that we mark the centenary of 1916 with commemorative events that everybody in the nation can be proud of.
Comment on this
The Rising was the event that propelled our nation on the path to independent statehood.
Comment on this
We need to mark it with respect, be aware of its complexities and appreciate its idealism. We are the beneficiaries of that legacy. In recognition of this, €50 million has been provided for an extensive range of events and initiatives under the commemorative programme we launched. It will also allow for the development of the GPO interpretative centre, the national monument on Moore Street, Teach an Phiarsaigh in Ros Muc and the Athenaeum in Enniscorthy.
Comment on this
The allocation for the Department of Arts, Heritage and the Gaeltacht will also provide an additional €3 million for a new scheme of once-off grants to arts and cultural centres throughout the country.
I would like briefly to outline some other measures.
Justice
I am providing €2.2 billion to the Department of Justice and Equality for current expenditure. Last year, the Minister for Justice and Equality announced that the Garda training college in Templemore would re-open and remain open. I am happy to announce that in 2016, funding has been made available to recruit and train an additional 600 gardaí.
Comment on this
Resources have also recently been made available for improved ICT and for the new policing authority. The Government is committed to supporting An Garda Síochána.
Comment on this
Open the Garda stations, please.
Comment on this
The human tragedies in Carrickmines and Omeath over the weekend are a stark reminder of the fragility of life. In the aftermath of such terrible events, the moral support of the community and the professional help of our An Garda Síochána, fire crews, medical staff and social workers, marks out definitively what we are as a society and as a people. In the same way as we need to care for and protect our own people in these dreadful times, we must also be prepared to do the same for others. The refugee crisis on Europe’s borders demands a practical and generous response from the Irish people, who have a long and proud history of international humanitarianism. The spontaneous and heartfelt response of communities across the country, which is evident in the huge number of offers of assistance and volunteerism, shows that the Irish people will not be found wanting.
Some €25 million will be provided to ensure Ireland is not found wanting in this regard. Funds will be spent on accommodation, additional staffing, integration programmes, and on a new emergency resettlement and orientation centre.
Defence
Some €903 million has been allocated to the Department of Defence. Ireland’s participation in humanitarian operations in the Mediterranean and ongoing peacekeeping missions in the Middle East and elsewhere is a testament to the professionalism and dedication of our armed forces. Everybody in the nation is proud of them. The recently published White Paper on defence provides a framework for a modern, adaptable force that can carry out operations at home and abroad.
For services at home, I am happy to announce that €2 million has been made available to put an emergency aeromedical service on a permanent footing. This service will save lives and give comfort particularly to rural communities.
International development
Even in the most difficult of times, the Government maintained our commitment to fighting global poverty and hunger. As the public finances improve, we will strengthen that commitment. Today, I am allocating over €640 million to official development assistance. Some €486 million will be managed by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade through Irish Aid, with the remainder being administered through other Departments and the EU development co-operation budget.
Irish funding will make a significant contribution to the international aid effort in suffering countries such as Syria, Iraq, Ethiopia and Somalia. The programme will also continue to help people in our key partner countries in some of the worst and poorest parts of the world.
Agriculture
I am allocating €1.3 billion to the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine. Additional funding has been allocated, in particular, to a new agri-environment scheme and to capital investment schemes under the rural development programme. This year’s allocation will also fund a range of new schemes under the seafood development programme set out by the Minister. The programme will drive investment in fisheries and seafood development from now until 2020. Further details of the Estimates are set out in the Estimates report that I have circulated.
Investing in the future
This budget is about the future. It is about using our resources to support communities in every part of the country.
Comment on this
It is about winning the election.
Comment on this
It is about creating jobs, so that people can look forward to a better life. It is about using the results of our hard-earned stability to improve our lives, better our communities and plan ahead with confidence. I said last year that the budget marked a turning point - the end of the era of austerity budgets.
Conclusion
At the election in 2011, this Government made two key promises. We promised we would fix the public finances and restore growth to our economy.
Comment on this
You made a few more than that now, Minister. You made an awful lot more than that.
Comment on this
We promised we would fix the public finances and restore growth to our economy.
Comment on this
You are a master of understatement.
Comment on this
It is wry indeed to hear Fianna Fáil talk about broken promises.
Comment on this
Who speaks of Eamon Gilmore now?
Comment on this
It is like Tesco. Every little hurts.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil and Mattie are the ones who took the lifeboat before the ship sunk.
Comment on this
Labour's way or Frankfurt's way.
Comment on this
We promised that we would fix the public finances and that we would restore growth to our economy. We have made good on those promises.
Comment on this
Labour's way or Frankfurt's way.
Comment on this
We promised too that we would never allow the State to fall into similar peril. The spending increases announced today are moderate, sensible and commensurate with our economic requirements. We continue to make good progress. Our debt is falling. Our deficit is narrowing. Unemployment is coming down. The previous Government’s budgetary failure helped to lead us to crisis.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil did not answer that one.
Comment on this
Between 2000 and 2008, gross spending increased by 139%.
Comment on this
Did you hear that lads? Did you hear that Micheál? You were there for that.
Comment on this
Would you hold on please? Just stay quiet. The Minister is nearly finished. Thank you.
Comment on this
In the run-up to the 2007 election, between 2005 and 2007, public spending was ramped up by 25%, or more than €11 billion in nominal terms. That is election bribery for you, Deputy Martin.
Comment on this
Labour's way or Frankfurt's way.
Comment on this
The Minister wanted way more than that. You are a hypocrite.
Comment on this
By comparison, next year public expenditure will be just 4% ahead of 2014.
Comment on this
There is a 4% increase in expenditure at a time when tax revenues are forecast to increase by over 14% and GDP is forecast to increase by 18%. Through prudent and careful management of the State’s finances, this Government brought the country back from the brink. Our recovery, though not yet complete, is not only a justification of the policies we pursued for the past four and a half years, but a condemnation of the easy alternatives proffered by some. Who speaks of Syriza now?
Comment on this
Who speaks of Eamon Gilmore now?
Comment on this
While maintaining the responsible approach-----
Comment on this
While maintaining the responsible approach that got our country to where we are today, we are committed to investing in public services; assisting those most in need; creating jobs; providing a platform for future growth; and ensuring that every family and every community, in every part of the country, can share in a better future.
Comment on this
Why are you praising Fianna Fáil?
Comment on this
Today, we reap the benefits of the hard work and resilience of the Irish people, as we set our course for a better Ireland.
Comment on this
Tell me why you are hanging onto power.
Comment on this
Settle now, Billy. Bring back Noel.
Comment on this
A Cheann Comhairle, could we have a recess so that the Fianna Fáil opposition party can rewrite its lines?
Comment on this
You will have your retirement party later.
Comment on this
This budget is the final roll of the dice from a Government that has run out of ideas and is about to run out of road. This budget presented a golden opportunity to the Government to make a statement about our values as a country and to set out a vision for our Republic as we approach a series of centenary commemorations. It was an opportunity to make the right choices. The decision the Government has made in the budget says a lot about its priorities. The essential task it faced in today's budget was to get the balance right between rewarding work and investing in vital services on which citizens depend. The Government has failed to strike the right balance.
There is no getting away from the fact that as we approach the end of this Government's term in office, 1,500 children will sleep in emergency accommodation in our country tonight. There is no getting away from the fact that almost half a million people are on hospital waiting lists and that it is almost impossible for families who are caring for loved ones to get a home care package or to get home help in this country today. I could go on. I regret that I see nothing in this budget that will make a real difference to those people and many others who need our help at this time. A meaningful recovery simply must address those issues.
Instead of claiming the recovery as its own creation, the Government should give credit to ordinary people throughout the length and breadth of this country who refused to yield in the face of the worst economic crisis in decades. It should give the credit to the owners of small businesses-----
Comment on this
-----who defied the odds and not only survived but are now driving the recovery. The Government is delusional if it believes that decisions made on Merrion Street during its tenure have brought about this recovery. Having broken promise after promise over the past four and a half years, this budget is an attempt by the Government to take a short cut to popularity, but the people will not be fooled. This budget will be seen alongside the coalition's previous four budgets. It is depressing that, as with last year, the Government's priority is not to undo as much as possible of the social harm caused by tough years of austerity, but again to design tax cuts that disproportionately put far more money in the pockets of higher income earners. The stand-out feature of this Government's approach to budgeting for five consecutive years has been to favour the better off. It is Fine Gael ideology all the way.
Comment on this
With every budget this Government has passed, it has made Ireland a more unequal place. Fine Gael and the Labour Party seem intent on creating deeper and deeper divisions in society. The way the Government targeted lone parents, women and the elderly will live long in the memory. This Government does not like independent analysis very much, but the analysis of the Government's approach to its last four budgets has been very clear. The first three austerity budgets were found to be regressive, placing the greatest burden on those least able to carry it. Last year's budget was the first in seven years where there was scope to give something back and, incredibly, it resulted in the bottom 10% of households in income terms losing the most and the top 10% gaining the most. I have no doubt that when an objective analysis is done, this budget will be deemed to have had the same effect. Against all of that, one would have to wonder what is the point of having the Labour Party in government at all.
Comment on this
It is little wonder the Government wants another few months in office before facing the people, but it will make no difference. Back in 2011 the Government was swept to power with a record mandate and the overwhelming goodwill of the Irish people to be bold and reforming, but it has utterly failed to deliver in so many areas.
Political reform, which was demanded by voters in 2011 has been abandoned completely. Instead, the Government put a new polish on the old ways. Many of the big questions facing the country have been ignored completely and the programme for Government commitment on pensions is a case in point. The Government promised to reform the pension system to achieve progressively universal coverage but instead, decided to raid €2.4 billion from private pension savings; zero reform.
Comment on this
Universal health insurance was to be the landmark reform of the Government. It was to provide equal access to the health service for all citizens, irrespective of their means. It too has been abandoned; it must lie on a waiting list somewhere. The proceeds from a local property tax were to be used to improve local communities. Instead-----
Comment on this
-----the Government cut funding to councils and used the local property tax proceeds to set up a bloated super-quango in Irish Water and that is the truth.
In opposition, Fine Gael and the Labour Party cynically opposed every measure introduced by Brian Lenihan to put the economy back on track-----
Comment on this
-----and then went on to implement his national recovery plan and better still, to claim credit for it. They told us they would burn the bondholders but all the Government did was to burn their election promises. The Government told Members it had secured a game-changer of a deal on bank debt but it turned out to be little more than hype. The deal on bank debt never materialised. Fine Gael and the Labour Party told families struggling with mortgage debt that their homes would be safe from the back. Instead, they diluted the rights of mortgage holders and made repossessions quicker and easier.
Comment on this
The Government stated it would breathe new life into rural Ireland but instead, it attacked every pillar on which it is built.
Comment on this
The centrepiece of this budget is the package put forward by the Minister, Deputy Noonan, on the universal social charge, USC. I acknowledge the USC is a very heavy burden on Irish taxpayers introduced at the worst of times.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil agrees the burden of USC should be lessened.
Comment on this
However, when one considers the impact of this tax package today on different families, one simply must put it alongside the Government's introduction of a series of taxes and charges that take no account of ability to pay. From the local property tax to water charges, from increased public transport fares to the fivefold increase in prescription charges, the Government consistently has had no regard to the principle of the ability to pay. In last year's tax package, higher earners gained more than four times more than someone on modest wages. The full-year cost of the Minister's package today is approximately €550 million and because the USC is taxed on the income of an individual, the biggest winners will be two-income couples, especially high-earning two income couples.
Comment on this
Yet again, where one parent stays at home to mind children, the gain will be far less. The Minister has thrown a sop to them with an increase in the home carers tax credit, which incidentally is only claimed by 83,000 people. Many people are not even aware of the existence of this credit and that is a job the Minister must do. A two-income couple earning €70,000 per year or more will stand to gain by €1,800 in the Minister's tax package, whereas a single-income couple on €35,000 per year will gain by €377 on foot of the USC changes. As the Minister is providing them with €190 through the home carers tax credit, if they apply and claim it, their gain will be €567, compared with €800. In the case of working people on an income of €22,000, of whom there are many, their gain in this budget through the Minister's tax package is €182. The Minister is giving high-income couples ten times the level of gain people on low incomes will get.
Comment on this
The Minister will make the point, as he often has, that people who pay more tax will benefit more from tax cuts and while such people do pay more tax, if the Minister really seeks to make work pay, then people who earn €20,000, €30,000 or €40,000 really need his help. He must use all the tools at the disposal of the Government collectively to deal with that issue because the reason there are welfare traps and the reason it is not viable for many people to work is because of secondary benefits, namely, rent supplement and the medical card, which they lose as soon as they start working. This is an issue the Minister could have dealt with in this budget but he has not.
Members were promised the budgetary process would be opened up and would be much more transparent and accountable but this simply has not happened. At midnight last Friday night, the White Paper on Estimates of Receipts and Expenditure was published and lo and behold, there was an additional €1.5 billion in Supplementary Estimates. Members have been given no information today on that €1.5 billion and are only seeing half the picture.
Comment on this
This is €1.5 billion of Supplementary Estimates between now and the end of the year.
Comment on this
It is in the Book of Estimates that was circulated.
Comment on this
Members do not know how much of that money already has been spent, how much of that €1.5 billion has yet to be spent between now and Christmas or precisely how it will be spent. In the interests of transparency and accountability, all these facts should be in the public domain and should have been put up front and centre in the budget today.
Comment on this
On the spending side, one of the Minister's main points today was the increase of €3 in the old age pension and the partial restoration of the Christmas bonus. I do not believe the Minister is naive enough to think pensioners will be fooled by what he has announced here today because they remember well what the Government has done to them in recent years.
Comment on this
The Government cut the fuel allowance by six weeks.
Comment on this
-----and abolished the Christmas bonus.
Comment on this
It cut the actual fuel allowance amount by €3.90, it cut their gas and electricity units allowance by 25%, it abolished the telephone allowance and imposed the local property tax and water charges on elderly people with no account taken of ability to pay. The Government promised to abolish their prescription charges but multiplied them by five. It increased the cost of a bag of coal by €2.50, on which many elderly people rely, with the carbon tax. It slashed the tax relief on their medical insurance premiums, which for many people meant an increase of hundreds of euro. It increased DIRT tax from 27% to 41%, again directly affecting many people. The cost of a place in a nursing home under the fair deal scheme increased dramatically under the present Government, including the share of the person's home that will be taken as a result.
Comment on this
In addition, the Government has cut thousands of hours of home help.
Comment on this
On top of all that, the Minister's announcement of an increase of €3 will ring hollow for many people because in 2012, the Tánaiste and Minister for Social Protection, Deputy Burton, introduced sneaky changes to the eligibility criteria for the State pension-----
Comment on this
-----by changing the yearly average contribution bands. A lady from my constituency wrote to me last week.
Comment on this
This was announced seven years earlier.
Comment on this
Her yearly average band came in at more than 20 weeks per annum-----
Comment on this
-----and under the old regime, at €225, her pension would have been €5 short of the full pension. Instead, €34 has been cut from the pension she otherwise would have received.
Comment on this
But it is all right because of the €3 increase.
Comment on this
That is the reality and many people are only now beginning to realise, as they reach the age of 66-----
Comment on this
-----that the eligibility criteria for the State pension has changed fundamentally.
The Minister's comments on housing and accommodation were nothing short of pathetic. He would have been better off saying nothing than what he actually said. There has been no increase in rent supplement. It was flagged and leaked repeatedly that rent certainty would be introduced but there is no rent certainty today. There was to be tax relief for landlords who took on tenants in receipt of rent supplement-----
Comment on this
How many houses did Fianna Fáil build when it was in government?
Comment on this
-----but there has been no such tax relief.
Comment on this
It was 14,000 social houses Deputy Buttimer.
Comment on this
There were to be grants for builders who sold houses at below the market value. Apparently, Members are told, the Minister, Deputy Noonan and the Minister, Deputy Kelly, could not reach agreement on the package of measures to help people trying to put a roof over their heads. Is it not amazing the Ministers did manage to reach agreement on giving themselves a €900 tax cut? However, the Government could not reach agreement on helping people who do not have a roof over their heads tonight.
Comment on this
Is the Government not aware of what the Simon Community found in its recent report? In the areas it studied, which included all the major population centres, 93% of properties available for rent were outside of the rent supplement cap. In the five major cities, the Simon Community could not find a single property available for rent that was within the rent cap for a single person.
Comment on this
Not a single property and not a word about it in the budget today, which is an absolute disgrace-----
Comment on this
-----because apparently, the Government cannot reach agreement on all of that. It is an absolute disgrace.