Questions on Proposed Legislation
- EPSEN Act implementation 9 speeches
After procedural discussion of the one-minute limit, Deputy Martin asks which EPSEN Act sections have been commenced; the Taoiseach promises to provide the information.
Seán Ó Fearghaíl, Micheál Martin, Brendan Howlin, Enda Kenny
- Rising motor insurance premiums 2 speeches
Deputy Adams seeks a Government task force on sharply rising motor insurance premiums; the Taoiseach will raise the issue at Cabinet subcommittee and examine the causes.
Gerry Adams, Enda Kenny
- National Maternity Hospital delay 2 speeches
Deputy Howlin asks about the delayed National Maternity Hospital project and the mediator’s report; the Taoiseach says the dispute is unacceptable and promises an update.
Brendan Howlin, Enda Kenny
- ECB scrutiny of Opposition legislation 2 speeches
Deputy Murphy objects to reported ECB attempts to review Opposition legislation; the Taoiseach says Ireland’s sovereign Government is entitled to draft legislation independently.
Paul Murphy, Enda Kenny
- Legal Services Regulatory Authority 2 speeches
Deputy McGrath asks when the overdue authority under the Legal Services Regulation Act will be established; the Taoiseach will provide an implementation date.
Mattie McGrath, Enda Kenny
- TAMS payments to farmers 9 speeches
Deputies raise delayed TAMS payments affecting thousands of farmers who have completed approved works and incurred loans, reportedly because the payment system is unavailable. The Taoiseach will ask the Agriculture Minister to investigate and clarify the position.
Declan Breathnach, Enda Kenny, Seán Ó Fearghaíl, Heather Humphreys, Aindrias Moynihan
- Town and village renewal scheme 3 speeches
Deputy Healy-Rae asks when the improved town and village renewal scheme and additional funding will be announced; the Taoiseach says preparatory work is under way.
Michael Healy-Rae, Seán Ó Fearghaíl, Enda Kenny
- Oireachtas committee appointments 2 speeches
Deputy Ó Caoláin criticises the delay in establishing committee work programmes; the Taoiseach undertakes to inquire about the appointments.
Caoimhghín Ó Caoláin, Enda Kenny
- Post offices as State-service hubs 4 speeches
Deputy O’Dea asks for a working group on providing services through post offices before the recess; the Taoiseach cites ongoing discussions and work on driving licences and other services.
Willie O'Dea, Enda Kenny
- Fast-track housing planning 12 speeches
Deputy Burton challenges proposals to send large housing developments directly to An Bord Pleanála, warning they would undermine local planning and favour developers. The Taoiseach rejects her political allegation and says the proposals will feature in the forthcoming housing action plan.
Joan Burton, Seán Ó Fearghaíl, Enda Kenny
- Cancelled cancer operation in Cork 4 speeches
Deputy Moynihan raises the cancellation of a constituent’s life-threatening cancer operation because of bed pressures at Cork University Hospital. The Taoiseach asks him to provide the case details to the Health Minister for a factual explanation.
Michael Moynihan, Enda Kenny, Seán Ó Fearghaíl
- St Vincent’s Care Centre transfer 3 speeches
Deputy Troy asks whether the forced removal of residents from St Vincent’s Care Centre is temporary or a closure by stealth. The Taoiseach confirms a phased temporary transfer caused by electrical and fire-safety risks, with residents to return afterward.
Robert Troy, Enda Kenny, Seán Ó Fearghaíl
Before moving on to questions on promised legislation, I point out to Members that we have recently amended Standing Order 28 to provide that there is one minute per Member on one question on promised legislation. Deputy Micheál Martin has one minute for one question.
Comment on this
It is in Standing Orders. One minute for one question.
Comment on this
The disenfranchisement of large parties continues. I will say no more.
Comment on this
Excuse me, Deputy. Your party agreed to the amendment of Standing Orders which apply to every Member. The quicker we start, the more Members will be able to speak.
Comment on this
In the programme for Government there is a reference to the Education for Persons with Special Educational Needs, EPSEN, Act, which is the legislation dealing with special education. It refers to sections that were introduced on a non-statutory basis, which does not make sense to me. The Taoiseach may not have the relevant information available to him, but I ask him to communicate the various sections of the Act which have been properly and statutorily commenced and those which have not been. I thought it was a very strange phrase.
Will it be possible to get an update before the recess on the progress made in delivering the housing plan?
Comment on this
I will revert to the Deputy regarding the EPSEN Act and the sections that have not been implemented by statute and on a voluntary basis. The Deputy's second question referred to housing.
Comment on this
I did not hear a second question because there is only provision for one. I am very sorry.
Comment on this
On Saturday, protesters took part in a rally on Merrion Square to protest at the rise in car insurance premiums, which have increased by 67% over the past three years. Those involved who have to carry this burden want the Government to establish a task force, similar to the Motor Insurance Advisory Board, MIAB, which was established in the 1990s and whose recommendations led to a 40% drop in premiums. The Minister for Finance has established a task force in his Department to review policy in the insurance sector, but it has not yet begun to deal with the reasons behind the major spikes in premium costs. Will the Taoiseach indicate when he expects the review to be completed? Will he consider establishing a task force similar to the MIAB?
Comment on this
We will discuss this at the next Cabinet sub-committee meeting and advise Deputy Adams of the progress made and whether the outcome is that a task force should be established.
When we called the insurance companies together previously about flooding, many of them commented that fraudulent claims were driving up motor insurance. I have seen that refuted in other areas. The rise in insurance costs is a matter of concern and we will examine the matter carefully.
Comment on this
I wish to ask the Taoiseach about the commitment in the programme for Government on the National Maternity Hospital. As he is aware, the previous Government committed €150 million for the project and planning permission was to have been lodged in the final quarter of last year. The project is now seven months behind schedule. A mediator was appointed months ago to sort out the problem and was to report back to the Minister for Health, Deputy Harris. Has the mediator reported back, and when will we see progress on a new National Maternity Hospital?
Comment on this
Deputy Howlin was in government himself when the money was allocated for the project. I find it disgraceful that the situation has not been resolved. As the Deputy is aware, it is not a political problem. The money is in place, a mediator was appointed and people should be able to agree. I have heard so many instances of the inadequacy of the building that has been the National Maternity Hospital for more than 100 years. The details should all be arranged and the project should move on. I will advise Deputy Howlin when I speak to the Minister for Health about the progress being made by the mediator. This is something that is in the interests of everybody.
Comment on this
I refer to the reports that the European Central Bank is seeking to have sight of, and presumably influence over, Opposition legislation in advance of it being discussed and voted on in this House. The European Central Bank is a body with no democratic legitimacy. It is unelected and unaccountable and has played a disgusting role in the course of European crises in various coups in Italy and in Greece. It is reported that the ECB has suggested there would be "potentially very serious consequences" for a failure to comply with its wish to see the legislation. We have no intention of complying with or facilitating the ECB's interference in the democratic process. Is there any proposal for legislation to facilitate the ECB to have access to Opposition legislation in advance of it being discussed and voted on in this House?
Comment on this
This is a sovereign country with a sovereign Government and we are entitled to draft legislation. The changes made here recently allow for that to an even greater extent in terms of proposed legislation from Members of the Opposition as Private Members' Bills. There is no such proposal.
Comment on this
The Legal Services Regulation Act 2015 has been enacted for a full 12 months, yet there is still no sign of the regulatory authority being set up. People are being charged enormous fees and significant issues arise in that regard. When will the regulatory authority which underpins the Act be set up?
Comment on this
As Deputy McGrath said, the legislation was enacted in 2015. I will advise the Deputy when the Act will be implemented.
Comment on this
Page 110 of the programme for Government refers to farm gate investment. The Taoiseach and the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine are well aware that in excess of 70 questions have been asked in this House on the targeted agricultural modernisation scheme, TAMS, programme, and the failure to pay farmers who have been approved. The excuse is that the computer system is not working. When will a commitment be made on a payment date for the farmers involved, many of whom have been offered loans from the banks, which completely defeats the purpose of the scheme?
Comment on this
I do not know anything about the failure of a computer system in that regard but over the years the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine, and the Minister, have been very diligent in attempting to have farmers paid promptly. In some cases farmers are paid a portion of the money to which they are entitled in advance. I will follow up on the point Deputy Breathnach raised but he can take it that the Minister is anxious that farmers are paid on time.
Comment on this
Does the matter relate to promised legislation?
Comment on this
Some farmers who have expended cash and done the work as recently as last January, who appeared to have approvals, have not been able to collect them. The Minister said the payments would be made in June and July. Up to 4,000 farmers are affected. When farmers try to access the website, they find it is not active and the option of drawing down the payment is not available to them.
Comment on this
In the meantime they are borrowing money to carry out work and making repayments on it.
Comment on this
A parliamentary question or Topical Issue would appear to be the best option in terms of getting a response.
Comment on this
I will ask the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine to note the points made by the Deputies. I am sure there is a reason the payments have not been issued. I will have the point the Deputy raised cleared up.
Comment on this
The programme for Government states that the renewal of towns and villages will be a top priority for the new Minister with responsibility for regional and rural affairs as a way to revitalise rural Ireland. To deliver on this goal, the new Minister will develop a new and improved town and village renewal scheme, with input from the Oireachtas, in time for the budget in 2017. As part of the scheme, the Government proposes to commit additional funding to support the development of rural towns and villages. When will the House learn about this scheme and how much funding will the Government allocate to it?
Finally, I thank the Minister again publicly in this House for allowing "Star Wars" to come to Kerry, because it would not have been there only for that. I give credit where credit is due.
Comment on this
They are following on "Ryan's Daughter," which was years ago.
The work preparing for the various schemes is well under way. The Minister and the Minister of State at the Department of Arts, Heritage, Regional, Rural and Gaeltacht Affairs will be very diligent to see that this happens as quickly as possible.
Comment on this
The Select Committee on Justice and Equality had its first meeting this morning, dealing with the Paternity Leave and Benefit Bill. However, as I speak, we have no certainty as to when the joint committee will sit. I understand the difficulty is that the appointments to the various Oireachtas committees from the Seanad have not yet concluded. It is absolutely disgraceful, after this long period of time, that we are faced, a couple of weeks before the recess, without even the opportunity of addressing a work programme. This applies to all of the committees. I ask the Taoiseach to establish why there is such an inordinate delay by the Seanad in appointing members to the joint Oireachtas committees, and to ensure that is done as expeditiously as possible so we can progress our programme of work.
Comment on this
Well done on "Star Wars," Taoiseach, but back here on planet Earth there is a commitment in the programme for Government that a working group will be set up to establish whether post offices could be used as a hub for the provision of State services such as motor taxation. I ask the Taoiseach whether that working group could be established before the recess, as this situation has now become very serious.
Comment on this
There have been a number of meetings with Mr. Kerr, who wrote the report, on the issues that arise there. The Government already made the decision some time ago that the basic bank account would be made available to the post offices.
Comment on this
I know that, but what about the work?
Comment on this
Work is going on regarding driving licences, as the Deputy mentioned. As I said, a number of meetings have taken place, but I will advise the Deputy of the progress made. It is a matter that has been discussed a few times.
Comment on this
I ask the Taoiseach about the proposal by the Minister with responsibility for housing, Deputy Simon Coveney, to the effect that planning permission for housing estates of more than 150 units will go straight to An Bord Pleanála and bypass the local authority entirely. The follow-up proposal by Deputy Barry Cowen, the Fianna Fáil spokesperson, is to bring that down to 30 units. In built-up areas, that would end planning as we know it. In fact, it would be back to the oldest alliance between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael relating to fast-track planning in the interest of developers.
Comment on this
Can the Taoiseach tell me whether this will result in legislation and when?
Comment on this
I think the Deputy's comment is completely unworthy of somebody who has served in government and who is a former Tánaiste. I reject that assertion completely.
Comment on this
I reject Deputy Burton's assertion about going back to the old days between political parties.
Comment on this
I served on the old Dublin County Council. I have a lot of personal experience of this.
Comment on this
I have a lot of experience of it. Do not lecture me about it.
Comment on this
These are matters that will be part of the housing action plan to be delivered in outline very shortly by the Minister for housing, planning and local government. Obviously, incentives are built in there for county councils to move on and for local authorities to get on with the job of providing affordable houses and social houses for the many people who need them throughout the country.
As regards Deputy Ó Caoláin's question, the Seanad Committee on Procedure and Privileges is meeting this week to appoint committees through the Committee of Selection.
Comment on this
As regards the programme for Government and the commitment on health care, a serious issue has developed with a constituent of mine over the past 24 hours. The person was waiting nearly four months for a serious cancer operation only to be informed yesterday that the operation scheduled for today was now being stopped because of the beds crisis in Cork University Hospital. It is disgusting that this operation for a life-threatening condition has been cancelled. I have the facts of the case, but I do not want to name the family involved.
Under the programme for Government and following what our party leader, Deputy Micheál Martin, said on Leaders' Questions, the crisis in all hospitals is shocking. It is particularly so concerning this issue because what could be a life-saving operation was cancelled at 24 hours' notice. The information given to the family was that it was because of the beds crisis within Cork University Hospital.
Comment on this
It is an issue. If Deputy Moynihan wants a detailed response as to why a life-saving operation was cancelled this morning, obviously it may well be because of bed management problems or due to something else within the medical team. I do not know.
Comment on this
I suggest that if the Deputy gives the details to the Minister for Health, he will supply a factual answer. It does not answer the question, though, concerning the patient who needs this operation. I hope that when it happens, it will be a success for the person in question.
Comment on this
Patients in St. Vincent's Care Centre in Athlone were informed last night that they would have to leave that hospital this morning to allow electrical works necessary under health and safety requirements to be carried out. This morning we have a situation whereby families are blocking ambulances taking patients from the hospital. The manner in which the HSE has dealt with patients, their families and staff is nothing short of disgraceful.
Will the Taoiseach confirm that this is a temporary measure and is not an attempt to close St. Vincent's Care Centre by stealth? When will the health information and patient safety Bill come before the Houses in order that all Members of the Oireachtas will have an opportunity to make an input into it? That would ensure a situation such as that pertaining in Athlone this morning will never happen again.
Comment on this
The Bill will go for pre-legislative scrutiny shortly. As regards the Deputy's first question, I can confirm that it is a temporary move. The decision was taken to transfer residents from St. Vincent's Care Centre in Athlone to alternative accommodation because of an electrical report that highlighted a number of risks, including fire and power outages that led to service failures in the facility. They affected lighting, heating and electrical equipment. The transfer will take place on a phased basis over the next two to three days. It is temporary. The patients will be transferred back again when things have improved.