Questions on Promised Legislation
- Commercial rates and Valuation Act 4 speeches
Deputy Micheál Martin pressed for implementation of the Valuation Act to modernise commercial rates and help businesses and councils. The Taoiseach said a rates Bill was being worked on but was not on the immediate priority list.
Micheál Martin, Enda Kenny
- Transport support Bill 2 speeches
Deputy Gerry Adams asked about legislation for transport payments for people with severe disabilities and criticised the scrapping of previous supports. The Taoiseach said the heads would be published this session and sent for pre-legislative scrutiny.
Gerry Adams, Enda Kenny
- Garda misconduct inquiries 2 speeches
Deputy Brendan Howlin asked when terms of reference would issue for five recommended Garda misconduct inquiries. The Taoiseach said he would speak to the Minister for Justice and update the House.
Brendan Howlin, Enda Kenny
- Moneypoint replacement plan 4 speeches
Deputy Michael Healy-Rae asked what plan existed for replacing Moneypoint and whether a report would issue soon. The Taoiseach said no detailed proposals had yet been brought forward and only climate-related discussions were underway.
Michael Healy-Rae, Enda Kenny, Micheál Martin
- Horse Racing Ireland funding row 10 speeches
Deputy Martin Kenny raised controversy around the greyhound and horse racing sector, saying Ministers had been misled about a business case and an HRI CEO reappointment. The Chair ruled parts out of order, and the Taoiseach replied only that the agriculture Minister had already dealt with the issue before committee.
Martin Kenny, Seán Ó Fearghaíl, Enda Kenny
- Tobacco and mortgage arrears measures 6 speeches
Deputy Willie O'Dea asked when the public health tobacco Bill would be published and when a special court for mortgage arrears would be established. The Taoiseach said the tobacco Bill heads were being drafted and that he would follow up on the mortgage question.
Willie O'Dea, Seán Ó Fearghaíl, Enda Kenny
- Diesel tax proposal 7 speeches
Deputy Danny Healy-Rae urged the Government not to raise excise duty or VAT on diesel in the budget. The Chair ruled it out of order for the Order of Business, and the Deputy’s warnings were simply noted.
Danny Healy-Rae, Seán Ó Fearghaíl, Michael Healy-Rae
- Legislative programme priorities 5 speeches
Deputy John Curran asked for the Government’s priority list of Bills within the session’s limited debating time. The Taoiseach said Government priorities would be published as part of the agenda, with the Business Committee handling the rest.
John Curran, Enda Kenny
- Medical cards for released prisoners 2 speeches
Deputy Michael Moynihan questioned why released prisoners seemed to get automatic medical card entitlement while terminal cancer patients did not. The Taoiseach said medical-card eligibility would still depend on income and that legislation was being pursued for other categories.
Michael Moynihan, Enda Kenny
- Insecure work protections 2 speeches
Deputy Mick Barry asked that promised protections for workers on insecure, low-hour contracts be brought forward urgently because of Bus Éireann’s plans. The Taoiseach said the legislation was being worked on and he would advise on its state of preparation.
Mick Barry, Enda Kenny
- Project Eagle and insurance register 2 speeches
Deputy Pearse Doherty asked about the debate on the Project Eagle inquiry and the delayed personal injuries register amid soaring insurance costs. The Taoiseach said he had received party submissions on the investigation and that a Minister of State was preparing insurance proposals.
Pearse Doherty, Enda Kenny
- INTERREG and PEACE funding 3 speeches
Deputy Declan Breathnach asked about promised cross-Border projects with EU support and noted Northern Ireland approval of INTERREG funding. The Taoiseach said the matter would be considered at the North-South Ministerial Council and mentioned support for the A5 and Narrow Water bridge.
Seán Ó Fearghaíl, Declan Breathnach, Enda Kenny
- Birth family tracing legislation 2 speeches
Deputy Joan Burton asked when legislation allowing adopted people to trace birth families would be brought forward. The Taoiseach said it was well advanced, on the priority list, and would be processed as quickly as possible.
Joan Burton, Enda Kenny
- Universities amendment Bill 4 speeches
Deputy Thomas Byrne raised staffing pressures in universities and said the universities (amendment) Bill and funding must address worsening staff-to-student ratios. The Taoiseach said short-term funding was for discussion between the Education and Public Expenditure Ministers, with medium- and longer-term issues to follow.
Thomas Byrne, Enda Kenny
- Domestic violence and victims of crime Bills 2 speeches
Deputy Carol Nolan asked when the domestic violence Bill and the criminal justice (victims of crime) Bill would be published. The Taoiseach said the domestic violence Bill would be published at the end of the session and the victims of crime Bill earlier, with both treated as priorities.
Carol Nolan, Enda Kenny
As the Taoiseach will be aware, many businesses remain under significant pressure, particularly in the cities and towns across the country. Commercial rates are a significant burden on businesses. They are also an outdated model in terms of garnering revenue for county and city councils. In the era of the Internet, it is particularly noteworthy that it is people with fixed buildings that are paying for all of the services in a given area, vis-à-vis the online developments that have taken place. To a large extent, there is a significant discriminatory element attached to commercial rates in that a smaller pool of people are now expected to pay them.
The programme for Government contains a commitment to implement the Valuation Act so we can get a sustainable commercial rates base for employers and new start-ups in particular. That is what the programme for Government specifies. Will the Taoiseach confirm implementation of the Valuation Act has commenced? When will it be completed? Does the Government have further plans for change?
Comment on this
It was about the Valuation Act and the programme for Government commitment to implement it so efficient local authorities can adopt a commercial rates policy that helps sustain existing businesses and encourages new start-ups. I know it is a weighty document and there is a lot in it.
Comment on this
We have a rates Bill, which will modernise commercial rates in local authorities. I will advise Deputy Michéal Martin of the progress being made on it. It is not on the immediate priority list published yesterday.
Comment on this
My question is on the health (transport support) Bill. The Taoiseach will recall the legislation is intended to provide for a scheme to make individual payments towards transport costs for citizens with severe disabilities. Almost three years ago, the Taoiseach scrapped the motorised transport grant and mobility allowance. Interestingly enough, this came on the back of it being found to be discriminatory and in breach of various equality protocols because certain people were not allowed onto it. Rather than opening it up for those people, the Government scrapped it entirely. While temporary arrangements were made for approximately 5,000 citizens, no disabled citizens have had access to any transport scheme since then. I have raised this many times. The Taoiseach promises a new scheme all the time. The Tánaiste told us the heads of the Bill would be published in July but they were not. Will the Taoiseach tell us when the heads of the Bill will be published and when he expects the health (transport support) Bill to be introduced in the Dáil?
Comment on this
I can confirm to Deputy Adams that the heads will be published in this session and it will go for pre-legislative scrutiny to the appropriate committee in this session.
Comment on this
The previous Government established an independent review mechanism to deal with various allegations of Garda misconduct. The overview report was published last July and in five of the 320 cases, the expert panel considered that an inquiry was required and the Minister accepted this. When will we see the terms of reference for these five recommended inquiries, including the allegations made by the former CEO of ISME, Mr. Frank Mulcahy?
Comment on this
I cannot answer the detail of the question for Deputy Howlin but I will advise him. I will speak to the Minister for Justice and Equality. The report was accepted by the Minister and there was a recommendation for five further actions to be taken. I will advise Deputy Howlin and the House on this.
Comment on this
The programme for Government states, in anticipation of Moneypoint coming to the end of its operating life in its current configuration, that national dialogue on climate change will identify as soon as possible the most suitable replacement low carbon generation technology. What plan or strategy, if any, has been thought up for Moneypoint and will a report or statement be issued in the near future?
Comment on this
Not in the near future. The Minister for Communications, Climate Change and Environment is going to either Brussels or Paris this week to discuss climate change.
Comment on this
There is also an extraordinary meeting on Friday to give consent for Europe to sign the Paris agreement in Marrakesh in November. There have not been any detailed propositions brought forward or considered by the Government in respect of Moneypoint. I will advise Deputy Healy-Rae.
Comment on this
As the Government is aware, page 114 of the programme for Government states the Government will prioritise strategic investment to support modernisation of the greyhound and horse racing sector. In recent days we have had a lot of turmoil, and yesterday evening the Minister appeared before the Joint Oireachtas Committee on Agriculture, Food and the Marine to discuss this. Two issues are coming to the fore on this. The board of Horse Racing Ireland, supposedly because of a mix-up, inadvertently misled the Minister. There is also the issue that a business case was put forward-----
Comment on this
It goes to the very heart of the issue of new government and new politics.
Comment on this
Yes, we are dealing with promised legislation and the programme for Government. I have raised the issue on the back of this.
Comment on this
A business case was supposed to be brought forward. It was revealed to us yesterday evening that there was no business case and that the business case was simply a letter from the chairperson of HRI to-----
Comment on this
There is no business case. Does the Taoiseach concur that his two Ministers were misled and that they have agreed to the appointment of the CEO of HRI for a third term which, apart from the huge salary the man in question will receive, is in breach of Government guidelines?
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine dealt with this issue at some length before the Oireachtas joint committee yesterday.
Comment on this
On promised legislation, the first item on page 24 of the legislative programme is the public health (sale of tobacco) Bill. It states the heads of the Bill are being drafted. What is the timescale for publication?
Second-----
Comment on this
It is a continuum. There is a commitment in the programme for Government to set up a special court to deal with cases of mortgage arrears. When will it be established? The link is tenuous.
Comment on this
The heads of the public health (sale of tobacco) Bill are being drafted. I will advise the Deputy of the position on the question of mortgages.
Comment on this
The heads of the Bill are being worked on and I will advise the Deputy of the position.
Comment on this
With regard to the programme for Government and the upcoming budget, I ask the Taoiseach and the Government not to raise the excise duty and VAT on diesel-----
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot raise that matter on the Order of Business. It is not related to promised legislation.
Comment on this
Working people and transport services cannot take any more and if the Government parties do it, it will hurt every man and woman in the country. I ask them not to do so.
Comment on this
The point has been made and the Taoiseach has heard the Deputy, but he cannot answer the question.
Comment on this
We would like it if he could.
Comment on this
Yesterday, the Chief Whip published the legislative programme for the autumn session. A total of 25 Bills are due to be published. A total of 21 Bills are before the Dáil and the Seanad. Approximately five and a half hours is available on the schedule this week to debate legislation. This session will be 12 weeks long and rather than go through each Bill, I refer to the fact that 46 bills have either been or are due to be published. While I accept that the Taoiseach may not be able to reply to the question now, will he identify the priority list of Bills that he intends to have passed this session?
Comment on this
Clearly, that is a valid question. There is a request before the Chief Whip from the Business Committee for an additional two hours to be granted on Thursdays. That request is being considered. However, this is part of the new politics and the agenda is, in part, determined by the Business Committee which is chaired by the Ceann Comhairle. It is not for me to determine the agenda for the Government and I cannot speak about the contributions Deputies and parties may wish to make as part of the legislative programme and about how long or frequent they might be. I expect all of the Bills we have set out to be published this session. On the ones before the Dáil, committees and so on, it is a matter for Members to decide how they wish to contribute. We have had discussions in the past about not enough time being granted and the debates on Bills being guillotined towards the end of a session. That will not happen now. This is part of the new deliberations under the arrangements brought forward by the House, which I support.
Comment on this
Will the Taoiseach publish a priority list of Bills that he intends to have passed within the time constraints?
Comment on this
As far as the Chief Whip and the Government are concerned, we will publish and present what we think should be priorities as our part of the agenda. Obviously, the Business Committee will deal with the rest.
Comment on this
I asked a question prior to the summer recess about automatic entitlement to a medical card for cancer patients who were terminally ill. The Taoiseach said there was no such automatic entitlement. It now transpires that the HSE has agreed to automatic entitlement for prisoners on release.
How is that organised? Before the summer, the Taoiseach told me there was no automatic entitlement so has there been a change to the legislation? If there are proposed changes to the legislation there should be automatic entitlement for people who suffer from terminal illness.
Comment on this
The Minister is pursuing legislation for the granting of medical cards to those children who are in receipt of domiciliary care allowances. A person released from prison will not, I presume, be in gainful employment any more than a person who loses a job and becomes unemployed. I also presume that income levels relating to eligibility for medical cards would apply.
Comment on this
I understand legislation is promised by the end of the year to provide protections for workers on insecure, low-hour contracts but, given that a publicly-subsidised State-owned public transport company, namely, Bus Éireann, is looking at introducing a low-hour and low-pay regime for those workers in its expressway service, scandalously lowering the terms and conditions of hundreds of workers, can the Taoiseach inform the Dáil as to whether this legislation could be brought forward urgently, and as a priority, in the coming weeks?
Comment on this
The Government has set out the list of legislation for publication this session and it is being worked on. I will advise the Deputy on the state of preparation in respect of the legislation he mentions.
Comment on this
Can the Taoiseach inform the House as to when he expects we will debate the terms of reference of the statutory commission of investigation into NAMA surrounding the Project Eagle sale and other activities?
The country is currently dealing with the increasing costs of car insurance, with a 40% increase this year on top of a 30% increase last year. Everybody agrees there needs to be more transparency in terms of claims for personal injuries, so can the Taoiseach explain how the requirement by the Courts Service to set up a personal injuries register in 2004 has still not happened? The Minister said that it was because it does not have the IT facilities at this point in time. Twelve years later, this has still not been done yet this is one of the things people believe could reduce the cost of insurance. Can the Taoiseach give a commitment that it will happen without delay?
Comment on this
I have received submissions from the different parties following the meeting I had with the leaders of the different groups in respect of Project Eagle on the decision to hold an appropriate investigation in this House. I expect to meet with the leaders again next week and to put forward the best option we have from all the submissions we received. We will try to get consensus on the most appropriate and effective commission and one which will actually work. The Minister of State, Deputy Eoghan Murphy, is working on the area of insurance and he expects to bring propositions back for a Government decision and consideration before Christmas. I will see to it that Deputy Doherty is advised directly on the current status of the register that was supposed to be introduced in 2004.
Comment on this
As part of the programme for partnership Government dealing with Northern Ireland, North-South co-operation and EU supports, on page 142, paragraph 4e, the Government promised to work with the Northern Ireland Executive to agree and implement cross-Border projects with the benefit of EU funding through INTERREG and the PEACE programme. At the meeting of the Joint Committee on the Implementation of the Good Friday Agreement yesterday evening, the Northern Ireland Minister for Finance, Máirtín Ó Muilleoir, informed us that the £120 million of INTERREG VA funding has been approved through the steering committee. He further informed us that Northern Ireland had matched this funding but stated that the projects would not receive a letter of offer until the authorities in the Republic also matched it. Bearing in mind that the steering committee last met on 27 July, can the Taoiseach inform this House when this funding will be made available from our side as it is pending for various projects around the country?
Comment on this
This is another reason we need an all-island conversation about the relationship between ourselves and Northern Ireland and this will be a matter for consideration at the North-South Ministerial Council to be held on 18 November. The Government has made available moneys for the A5 and we support the development of the Narrow Water bridge project.
Comment on this
When does the Government propose to bring forward the legislation relating to the right of people who have been adopted in Ireland to trace their birth families, which was published during the term of the previous Government? The Minister for Children and Youth Affairs indicated at the start of this Government's term that she would soon do so. What progress, if any, has been made on it?
Comment on this
Deputy Burton is correct. The Minister can confirm that this is well advanced. It is on the Government's priority list of legislation and it will be processed as quickly as possible. I will advise Deputy Burton of the progress on it.
Comment on this
I refer to the universities (amendment) Bill, which deals with staffing issues in universities. The staff to student ratio has reached record levels in this country and is affecting the reputation of our universities abroad. In addition, a professor told me this week that he has to teach 470 first year students in a lecture hall that is built to accommodate 450 people. It is unacceptable if that situation continues. I hope that the legislation, and the funding that is required, will deal with that. It is not sustainable.
Comment on this
Deputy Martin raised the question of third level funding in both the short and medium term arising from the Cassells report. I am aware of students who attend lecture halls with more than the figure mentioned by the Deputy. There are over 500 in some of the lecture halls, depending on the faculty and the subject being studied, as Deputy Thomas Byrne is well aware.
Comment on this
That does not make it right. It is unacceptable.
Comment on this
The question of the short term is a matter for discussion between the Minister for Education and Skills, Deputy Bruton, and the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, Deputy Donohoe. The Minister has set out his view on the Cassells report, and discussions will have to be held on the medium and longer term.
Comment on this
Ba mhaith liom ceist a chur ar an Taoiseach faoin Bhille um fhoréigean baile. The enactment of the domestic violence Bill is an important step in the Government's long overdue ratification of the Istanbul Convention and the Council of Europe Convention on preventing and combatting violence against women and domestic violence. In July, after a long delay, the Minister for Justice and Equality published the heads and general scheme of the new domestic violence Bill. Can the Taoiseach say when he expects that Bill to be published and when the criminal justice (victims of crime) Bill, which aims to strengthen the rights of victims of crime and is linked to this issue, will be published?
Comment on this
Deirtear liom go mbeidh an chéad Bhille a d'ardaigh an Teachta liom - an Bhille um fhoréigean baile - foilsithe ag deireadh an tseisiúin seo. The second Bill mentioned by the Deputy, the criminal justice (victims of crime) Bill, should be published earlier in the session. Both are deemed to be a priority.