Whistleblowers procedures in Defence
Deputy Micheál Martin pressed for confirmation of Department of Defence procedures for protected disclosures and for a copy of them. The Taoiseach said he would provide the procedures and repeatedly maintained he had answered yes, while the exchange was prolonged by procedural interventions and the Chair eventually called the next Member.
The whistleblowers legislation - the Protected Disclosures Act 2014 - lays out clear procedures for Departments to take in respect of protected disclosures. There are three whistleblowers and one in particular made protected disclosures to the Department of Defence and the then Minister, Deputy Coveney, regarding public health concerns at Baldonnel Airport and the workshops at the facility in which people were exposed to toxic chemicals. These were most serious and grave health issues and revelations. The whistleblower concerned was very anxious to ascertain whether the Minister could confirm that he had received his protected disclosure in 2015 and could not get confirmation of that. Indeed he went through the Chief Whip, Deputy Regina Doherty, to get access to the Minister to get him to confirm that he had received the protected disclosure. The texts of his messages to the Chief Whip have been revealed in the Irish Examiner. I pay tribute to Joe Leogue who has written a series of articles on this matter. This is very good investigative journalism.
Comment on this
It reveals a horror story of what has been going on and demands, at the very least, a proper transparent response from Government.
Comment on this
Under the Act, proper procedures are meant to be in place in the Department of Defence to react to protected disclosures.
Comment on this
Could the Taoiseach publish the procedures of the Department of Defence or could he give me a copy of them? Will he confirm that such procedures are involved?
Comment on this
The Health and Safety Authority conducted three inspections of the Air Corps premises at-----
Comment on this
That is not what I asked. I want to know in terms of the procedures within the Department.
Comment on this
I will supply that to the Deputy. The Health and Safety Authority conducted three inspections of the Air Corps premises at Casement Aerodrome in Baldonnel. It focused in particular on the control of occupational hygiene hazards in the workplace, including health surveillance issues. The Health and Safety Authority issued its report of inspection to the Air Corps on 21 October 2016. It listed a number of matters that required attention, including risk assessment, health surveillance, the monitoring of employees' actual exposure to particular hazardous substances and the provision and use of personal protective equipment. I am advised that the military authorities responded in writing to the Health and Safety Authority report on 20 December 2016. They indicated that the Air Corps is fully committed to implementing improved safety measures that will protect workers from potential exposure to chemicals and will ensure risks are as low as reasonably practicable. The Air Corps has implemented an improvement plan that will be conducted over eight phases. The first phase commenced in September 2016 and has a completion date of December 2017. I know that a number of articles were published in the Irish Examiner on 23 and 24 January last.
Comment on this
That is not what I am talking about.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I asked a specific question about legislation under the Order of Business.
Comment on this
I asked about the procedures that are meant to be put in place by any Government.
Comment on this
I know all of what the Taoiseach read out.
Comment on this
I simply asked the Taoiseach-----
Comment on this
-----why the Government Chief Whip and the former Minister for Defence-----
Comment on this
-----are silent on the issue of the lack of response to a whistleblower-----
Comment on this
-----to confirm to him that his protected disclosure has been received by the Minister. That is my point. That is the only question I asked.
Comment on this
He has not answered it, a Cheann Comhairle, and-----
Comment on this
-----I think you might have the authority to ask him to answer this specific question.
Comment on this
Will the Taoiseach give a commitment to publish the procedures?
Comment on this
This is supposed to be about promised legislation.
Comment on this
I did not say you had the authority to instruct him.
Comment on this
Okay. Second, the Taoiseach answered your question. He said "Yes". "Yes" was the answer.
Comment on this
No. This is a very important point.
Comment on this
Deputy Martin has been put back in his box.
Comment on this
I am being very serious. This is a serious matter.
Comment on this
I just asked a simple question, a Cheann Comhairle. Are the procedures in place and will they be published?
Comment on this
Deputy Martin asked me for a copy of the procedures followed by the Air Corps here. I said "Yes" in response to his question.
Comment on this
No, I did not ask for the procedures.
Comment on this
We have spent 15 minutes on this. Will we have injury time?
Comment on this
I asked whether the Department of Defence has added procedures in respect of protected disclosures.
Comment on this
This is supposed to be about promised legislation.
Comment on this
If so, will those procedures be published and will the Taoiseach forward a copy of them to me?