Saudi Arabia UN status vote
Deputy Ó Caoláin challenged the Government over whether Ireland supported Saudi Arabia's election to the UN Commission on the Status of Women. The Taoiseach defended Ireland's women's rights record, said secret ballots are not divulged, and argued the UN voting system and its precedents shaped the outcome.
Can I have just one word from the Taoiseach? That is all it would require.
Comment on this
The programme for Government refers, I believe, on 15 occasions, to commitments to women that claim to empower them and to tackle the inequalities experienced by them in our society and internationally. Last week, the Government refused to reveal how it voted in the election of Saudi Arabia to the UN Commission on the Status of Women-----
Comment on this
-----and I am asking the Taoiseach did he vote - Yes or No - to allow Saudi Arabia take a seat on the Commission on the Status of Women.
Comment on this
It is merely a "Yes" or "No".
Comment on this
This committee at the United Nations will be chaired by the incoming ambassador, Ms Geraldine Byrne Nason, on behalf of Ireland next year and the Deputy can rest assured that the question of women's rights will be one that will be foremost in her mind at that committee.
It has already been made clear by the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade that not since 1947 have any of the secret ballots been divulged. There are very good reasons for that. Clearly, the issue that arose here was that a panel of five countries-----
Comment on this
Did the Taoiseach tell Deputy Ross?
Comment on this
-----were put forward: Turkmenistan, Korea, Japan, Iraq and Saudi Arabia. There were five nominations for five places. Obviously, there was a place for every country involved.
Comment on this
The important issue here is the functioning of the United Nations, the mechanics of how it actually works. In my view, it needs fairly serious reform. Be that as it may, these votes occur on a regular basis-----
Comment on this
This is the first time that Saudi Arabia has been on this committee. This will be a committee focused on women's rights. Obviously, Saudi Arabia will have to hear some home truths and will have to play its part.
Comment on this
It will be a great comfort to the women of Ireland, and internationally, that Saudi Arabia is there.
Comment on this
I support the Minister, Deputy Flanagan, here in this matter. For those who wish that there would be a big row about this inside Cabinet, let me say that the members of the Independent Alliance were quite happy to say we need to have the opportunity to ask relevant questions and be better informed-----
Comment on this
Dúirt bean liom go ndúirt bean léi.
Comment on this
-----about votes that are coming up at the United Nations by the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade, and that is the case. Clearly, since it was formed in 1947-----
Comment on this
-----we have never had cases of divulgence of secret votes. Deputy Ó Caoláin knows how important they are.
Comment on this
It is time to break the precedent.