Questions on Promised Legislation
- Farm safety 2 speeches
Deputy Cowen raised the high fatality risk in farming and urged Government action under the agriculture and food commitments. The Tánaiste acknowledged farm safety as a major priority and said the HSA and Agriculture Department share responsibility.
Barry Cowen, Frances Fitzgerald
- Homeless families at Garda stations 2 speeches
Deputy Ó Broin questioned the lack of clarity for Gardaí when families with children present at stations seeking help. The Tánaiste said Gardaí know their duties, work with agencies, and child safety is covered by law.
Eoin Ó Broin, Frances Fitzgerald
- Vacant homes strategy 2 speeches
Deputy Jan O'Sullivan pressed for a publication date for the vacant homes strategy after raising emergency accommodation failures. The Tánaiste said the Minister would communicate directly with her on the timeframe.
Jan O'Sullivan, Frances Fitzgerald
- Homeless families and Garda stations 6 speeches
Deputy Coppinger demanded support for emergency housing legislation and asked why homeless families were being sent to Garda stations, with follow-up questions from both sides. The Tánaiste denied any protocol exists, said Garda stations are not appropriate, and stated the Dublin Region Homeless Executive is coordinating the matter.
Ruth Coppinger, Frances Fitzgerald
- Kerry University Hospital funding 2 speeches
Deputy Healy-Rae warned that cuts and funding shifts could turn Kerry University Hospital into a downgraded service. The Tánaiste said health funding had increased by over €1 billion and would ask the Minister for Health to contact him.
Michael Healy-Rae, Frances Fitzgerald
- Emergency accommodation for families 13 speeches
Several Deputies condemned the overnight homelessness of families and children and accused the Government of failing to provide accommodation. The Tánaiste repeatedly said the situation was unacceptable, insisted extra emergency capacity had been doubled, and said the case would be closely monitored.
Joan Collins, Frances Fitzgerald, Thomas P. Broughan, Richard Boyd Barrett, Seán Ó Fearghaíl
- Setanta Insurance claims 9 speeches
Deputies McGrath and Doherty pressed for relief for motorists affected by the Setanta collapse and asked whether the 65% compensation cap would be lifted. The Tánaiste said the Supreme Court ruling clarified that claims would be paid from the ICF and that future legislation would provide for 100% cover.
Michael McGrath, Pearse Doherty, Seán Ó Fearghaíl, Frances Fitzgerald
- Holy Family school Cootehill 7 speeches
Deputy Smyth raised the condition of Holy Family school and asked when works would begin. The Chair ruled the matter out of scope for promised legislation and the Minister said the Deputy had already tabled a private notice question.
Niamh Smyth, Seán Ó Fearghaíl, Richard Bruton
- Post office network future 6 speeches
Deputy Brassil sought clarity on the Kerr report, its implementation, and which Minister was responsible for securing the post office network. The Tánaiste referred the matter to Minister Naughten, who confirmed responsibility and said Cabinet would shortly consider the formal transfer and restructuring plans.
John Brassil, Mattie McGrath, Frances Fitzgerald, Denis Naughten, Seán Ó Fearghaíl
There is a commitment in the programme for Government to support the development of the agriculture and food sector. Every Deputy supports that aspiration, no more than we support the aspiration to look after everyone who gets up early in the morning, let alone those who cannot find a place to put their heads at night. The latest reports citing farming as the occupation with the highest risks for families is something that cannot be ignored by Government. The findings published by the ESRI earlier this week of the analysis of the 2013 Health and Safety Authority's survey on risk-taking and accidents on Irish farms outline how the fatality rate for farming is nearly ten times that of other occupations in the 2009 to 2015 period. It is a startling figure and one that proves a lot more action is needed. There were 11 fatalities last year alone and 138 people died in farm accidents during the past seven years. Will the Tánaiste confirm to the House that the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine and the Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation have agreed to meet to discuss this issue?
Will the Tánaiste confirm to the House that extra funds will be made available to both Departments to ensure every effort is made to address this issue?
Comment on this
The issue the Deputy raises is a very significant one. The issue of farm safety is a very significant priority for the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine and his colleague, Minister of State, Deputy Pat Breen, who has responsibility for the Health and Safety Authority. Farming is the occupation with the highest risk of fatalities in Ireland with a rate nearly ten times the average across occupations. It is a very serious and disturbing situation. The Health and Safety Authority has primary responsibility for health and safety on farms and the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine is working closely with it. There are a number of ongoing initiatives in the Department.
Comment on this
The programme for Government recognises it is not acceptable for families to live in unsuitable emergency accommodation. If a child presents unaccompanied to a Garda station out of hours, there is a clear statutory responsibility on the Garda to contact the Tusla-funded social worker. When a family with a child presents at the same Garda station, there is no statutory clarity in terms of what the Garda should do. Focus Ireland wrote to the Taoiseach two years ago asking for regulations to be introduced to clarify what the Garda must do in such circumstances. The Taoiseach said it was not necessary. Given the events of this week, will the Tánaiste look again at the issue and come forward with regulations to clarify the legal situation in such circumstances?
Comment on this
Gardaí are very clear about their responsibilities in such a situation. For example, a family turned up in Finglas the other night. Every effort is made to ensure they are made aware of all the services. Contact is made with the appropriate services. In this situation we are talking about housing. The Garda works very closely with all the agencies and will do everything possible to ensure anyone with whom its members come into contact is linked to the appropriate service. If there is any question about the safety of the children of those families, there is very clear law governing it. There are child protection guidelines, emergency out-of-hours services and provision for contacting Tusla. Gardaí are very aware of the law and they work to it so there is no need for extra arrangements.
Comment on this
The programme for Government says, "We will end the use of unsuitable long-term emergency accommodation, such as hotels and B&Bs, for homeless families". What we heard about here this morning goes much further than people ending up in hotels and bed and breakfast accommodation, with 12 families and 30 children being sent to Garda stations. I want to follow up on the vacant homes strategy. Will the Tánaiste or the Minister, Deputy Coveney, give us a date when the strategy will be published? The question was not answered when my party leader raised it today. The Peter McVerry Trust has looked at the situation in Britain where every local authority has a vacant homes officer. The Tánaiste said we do not know why they are vacant but that person's job is to go out and look at vacant homes, find out why they are vacant and bring them back into use. It has been really successful so there are models we can use to get a quick win. There are almost 200,000 empty homes in our country while people are sleeping in parks.
Comment on this
I will ask the Minister to communicate directly with Deputy Jan O'Sullivan on the exact timeframe.
Comment on this
In light of the fact that 12 families, 30 children and a pregnant woman turned up at Garda stations last night, will the Government support the Residential Tenancies (Housing Emergency Measures in the Public Interest) (Amendment) Bill 2016 in about ten minutes' time? If not, what legislation will it bring in? Who in the councils is telling people to go to Garda stations and why? What are gardaí supposed to do? They have enough on their hands. Will the Government issue a direction to stop the practice? The fear of having one's children taken away is probably the biggest fear any parent has. I am addressing the Tánaiste, the Government and the Labour Party. This crisis has been going on for three years. We know it takes time. The Government invokes the housing assistance payment, HAP, yet one of the women who was evicted was in a rental accommodation scheme, RAS, property. The Tánaiste knows RAS. It is the thing the Labour Party and Fine Gael told us was the solution to the housing crisis. Unless there are measures brought in to keep people in their homes and to stop them being evicted as a result of the sale of a property or its occupation by a family member of the owner, this will continue. Will the Government support the Bill in about ten minute's time?
Comment on this
We debated the Bill the other night.
Comment on this
Let me absolutely clear, there is no question of a protocol being in place to refer homeless families to Garda stations. That is not the job of An Garda Síochána.
Comment on this
Why are councils doing it then?
Comment on this
Gardaí obviously deal with homeless people and do everything they can to make sure accommodation is sourced for people who come directly to their attention. Clearly, Garda stations are not the place for any family and the Garda does not have any responsibility for providing accommodation. The issue is being co-ordinated by the Dublin Region Homeless Executive.
Comment on this
Regarding the commitments on health care in the programme for Government, I told the Taoiseach a number of weeks ago that I did not want Kerry University Hospital to be turned into a glorified community hospital. Funding is being cut from the hospital and allocated to the South/South West hospital group where it is swallowed up by hospitals in Cork. Where does this leave us given that recent reports indicate cuts of €5.6 million are being imposed on management at Kerry University Hospital who will have to make significant cuts to staff, services and equipment? This could lead to the closure of beds or entire wards? Patients in the hospital are at severe risk. This is a disgrace. Will the Tánaiste give an assurance that Kerry University Hospital will not be downgraded as a result of a lack of funding?
Comment on this
More than €1 billion in extra funding has been made available to the health service to support hospitals throughout the country and the work that takes place day in and day out. I will ask the Minister for Health to liaise with the Deputy directly on the point he raised regarding Kerry hospital.
Comment on this
What happened on Tuesday night when 30 children did not have anywhere to go or a roof over their heads is a blight on a society. These families ended up in Fairview Park and Mountjoy Square. Imagine having children aged under ten years outside at night looking for a safe place. This is an absolute failure on the part of the Government. Mr. Mike Allen of Focus Ireland stated in a radio interview this morning that 200 of the 1,000 families in emergency accommodation must ring around and self-accommodate every day. They do not know from one day to the next where they will be the following night. What will the Government do about this scandal?
Comment on this
I made absolutely clear that what happened to these families on Tuesday night is completely unacceptable.
Comment on this
No, our policy will ensure families will have accommodation and our economic policy will allow the budget to be made available.
Comment on this
Why did the Government oppose our Bill?
Comment on this
No one is saying this is acceptable. We never want to see a family in this situation.
Comment on this
The Government should resign and have a general election now.
Comment on this
The amount of contingency emergency accommodation has been doubled overnight in order that further accommodation will be available for families who find themselves in an emergency late at night.
Comment on this
This is the result of the Government's policies.
Comment on this
As I stated, there was capacity last night that was not used. The matter will be monitored very carefully, but of course this case was completely unacceptable.
Comment on this
That is not the point. Some 200 families have to self-accommodate every day.
Comment on this
The Supreme Court this morning upheld an appeal by the Motor Insurers Bureau of Ireland in respect of who would foot the bill for the collapse of Setanta Insurance. It now looks like the insurance compensation fund, ICF, will have to pay the outstanding claims, of which there are more than 1,600 amounting to more than €90 million. Last June, the Government published a report on the motor insurance compensation framework which recommended that the current 65% cap on ICF payouts be increased to 100%. Will the Tánaiste give a commitment that the policyholders caught up in the Setanta collapse will receive 100% compensation in respect of their claims and that the 65% cap will be lifted immediately by way of legislation?
Comment on this
I have raised this issue continually as the drama of Setanta Insurance has unfolded. While people will be relieved that the Supreme Court has made this judgment, it will come as a crushing blow to many motorists who are waiting for payouts in light of the 65% cap to which Deputy Michael McGrath has referred and the upper limit of €825,000 imposed on payouts.
Some families have been left in a situation in which they are no longer mobile and the cost of their claims are far in excess of that. The cap would be cruel. Will the cap of 65% up to a limit of €825,000 be lifted and will the Minister direct the liquidator to begin immediately payouts to and communication with those who have been waiting for many years?
Comment on this
The decision that has been delivered by the Supreme Court today in respect of the cases outlined by the Deputies removes the uncertainty that has existed since 2014. That is to be welcomed. The decision clarifies that the payments will be made from the ICF, which is overseen by a High Court judge and the Central Bank, as the Deputies will be aware. The payment of 65% of the amount due from each outstanding third party claim or €825,000, whichever is the lesser, will be arranged as soon as possible. The Department of Finance has been assured that this will be dealt with as a priority matter, given the urgent need to compensate people who have been waiting a long time.
It is likely that a significant proportion of the balance of third party claimants' claims will be met from the proceeds of the distribution of assets on completion of the liquidation process. I assure Deputy Michael McGrath that draft heads of a Bill amending the relevant legislation will be brought to the Government shortly.
Comment on this
The legislation will reflect today's Supreme Court judgment and the recently published Department of Finance report on the reform of the ICF, which will ensure that 100% of claims will be covered in future.
Comment on this
Will the Setanta claims be covered under the legislation?
Comment on this
According to a commitment on page 86 of the programme for Government, education "is the key to giving every child an equal opportunity in life." The Holy Family school in Cootehill is a special national school for pupils of four to 18 years of age from the entire Cavan-Monaghan catchment area. It caters for pupils with severe to profound learning difficulties, moderate to multiple learning disabilities or autism. More than 160 children attend the Holy Family school and it is the only facility of its kind in the constituency.
It is more than five weeks since Oireachtas colleagues from all parties and I visited the school to meet parents, staff and the board of management to discuss-----
Comment on this
It is on the programme for Government.
Comment on this
The Deputy is stretching it. This is for a parliamentary question or a Topical Issue.
Comment on this
Please, let me finish. The other Deputies and I were appalled to see the conditions at the school. My question is simple and we have discussed it with the Minister - when will work on the school begin?
Comment on this
On page 48 of the programme for Government, the Government committed to securing the future of our post office network. At a meeting that I held in Kerry last week, as well as at meetings that have been held all over the country by my colleagues, it transpired that, despite all of the talk and promises, nothing had been done. Where is the Kerr report? Where is its implementation plan?
Comment on this
Where is the Minister of State, Deputy Ring?
Comment on this
I call on the Tánaiste to tell me that the Government has finally established which Department and Minister have responsibility for securing the future of our post office network.
Comment on this
I am the Minister responsible and my Department is the Department responsible. The formal transfer of that decision will come before the Cabinet in the next couple of weeks. I have been engaged with the company. As the Deputy knows, two reports have been completed by Mr. Bobby Kerr and have fed into the restructuring of the company that is under consideration by the board. Significant restructuring is required to ensure the continued viability of the company. It is building on some of the existing strengths, including the nationwide network that post offices and sub-post offices provide. They will be a key part of the reform of the network.