Questions on Promised Legislation
- Order of Business 4 speeches
The Chair outlines time limits for questions on promised legislation. Deputy Donnelly asks about overdue Brexit sectoral reports, and the Minister says there is no publication schedule but work is under way in skills planning.
Pat the Cope Gallagher, Stephen Donnelly, Richard Bruton
- Garda station pilot scheme 5 speeches
Deputy O'Reilly asks when six Garda stations promised in the programme for Government will be reopened and seeks assurance of fairness. The Minister says Stepaside is progressing and the remaining stations depend on a Commissioner’s report due shortly.
Pat the Cope Gallagher, Louise O'Reilly, Richard Bruton
- Social welfare and pensions Bill 4 speeches
Deputy Howlin questions the publication and timing of the social welfare and pensions Bill, criticising the bilateral Government arrangement. The Minister says it will be published shortly and taken next Thursday, with publication this week.
Brendan Howlin, Richard Bruton
- Passenger name record Bill 29 speeches
Deputy Coppinger asks when the passenger name record Bill will be introduced, but uses the exchange to raise concerns about an alleged airport cautioning of an academic over criticism of a Minister. The Chair repeatedly tries to confine her to the legislation, and the Minister says preparatory work is under way in Justice.
Pat the Cope Gallagher, Ruth Coppinger, Catherine Byrne, Mick Barry, Michael Ring
- Farmers' compensation package 44 speeches
Several Deputies raise the plight of farmers protesting at Agriculture House over promised compensation after crop losses and bad weather. The Minister says the Agriculture Minister is willing to meet the IFA, is developing a crop-loss scheme with the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform, and has already introduced other supports such as agri-cash loans.
Pat the Cope Gallagher, Mattie McGrath, A Deputy, Jackie Cahill, Michael Healy-Rae
- Family Court Bill 5 speeches
Deputy Joe Carey asks for an update on the Family Court Bill. The Minister says work is ongoing in the Department and he will get a report for the Deputy.
Pat the Cope Gallagher, Danny Healy-Rae, Joe Carey, Richard Bruton
- Post-mastectomy supports 6 speeches
Deputy Niall Collins raises concern that HSE changes to post-mastectomy supports may reduce help for breast cancer survivors. The Minister points to a new ten-year cancer strategy and says he will ask the Health Minister to respond specifically.
Pat the Cope Gallagher, Niall Collins, Richard Bruton, Michael Moynihan
- Sligo job creation infrastructure 3 speeches
Deputy Scanlon urges action on IDA land access and funding for an inner relief road in Sligo to support job creation. The Minister says IDA Ireland has committed to an advanced facility and the Government remains strongly committed to regional enterprise support.
Pat the Cope Gallagher, Eamon Scanlon, Richard Bruton
- Teacher thresholds in small schools 6 speeches
Deputy Martin Kenny warns that Kiltyclogher school could lose a teacher because threshold reviews promised in the programme for Government have not happened. The Minister says the Government is committed to protecting small schools but cannot pre-empt budgetary decisions.
Martin Kenny, Pat the Cope Gallagher, Richard Bruton
- Housing regulator for approved bodies 7 speeches
Deputy Fitzpatrick asks when a housing Bill will establish a regulator for approved housing bodies. The Minister says it is hoped the Bill will be published in the next session and it is on the Government priority list.
Peter Fitzpatrick, Pat the Cope Gallagher, Richard Bruton
- Order of Business 1 speech
The Chair closes by listing further Members who have indicated and notes the possibility of a longer Thursday session in future.
Pat the Cope Gallagher
I remind Members that there are only 15 minutes allocated for questions on promised legislation. I ask all Deputies, including leaders or their representatives, to confine their questions to promised legislation or the programme for Government.
Comment on this
There is a firm commitment from the Government to publish detailed sectoral reports in response to Brexit. When we raised this issue with the Taoiseach two weeks ago, he informed us that no deadline for the publication of any of these reports had yet been released. Brexit started a year ago. The Irish food and drinks industry estimates that trade has fallen by about €570 million in the past year and that it could fall by twice that amount this year, yet not only do we not have detailed sectoral reports from any Minister, we have not even had a release date or an indication as to when they might be expected. At this point, are there dates for publication of the detailed sectoral plans in response to Brexit?
Comment on this
I do not have access to any schedule of publication but in my own area of skills, which is a very important one, we had a meeting this week with the Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation and our own delivery agencies to identify the areas of pressure. We will be pursuing those within the National Skills Council to make sure our provision and planning for next year incorporates concerns that have arisen specifically out of the Brexit report. We will not be publishing a particular element of that, but we will be focusing on the priorities. I will bring to the attention of the appropriate Ministers the matter of whether a date has been agreed for these sectoral reports to be issued because they can help people frame their own response and planning. To be fair, Enterprise Ireland is providing a very good framework across sectors to which companies can respond.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Reilly might preface her remarks by indicating whether she is asking about promised legislation or the programme for Government.
Comment on this
The programme for Government contains a commitment to reopen six Garda stations on a pilot scheme basis. Recently, it was mooted that Rush Garda station would be one of those. The Minister's colleagues in Fine Gael and his very best friends in Fianna Fáil were tweeting about it, but we are, in truth, no wiser as to what Garda stations will be reopened other than the station in Stepaside. We all know that Stepaside Garda station will be reopened. When will people throughout the country know what other Garda stations will be reopened? Can the Minister give us an assurance that equity and equality will be applied to that in terms of a rural-urban split and a geographic spread?
Comment on this
The idea of opening six Garda stations on a pilot basis was part of the programme for Government. It is for the Commissioner to select those that are most appropriate. I understand Stepaside Garda station was indicated as being appropriate and is in the course of being opened; the planning for that is being done.
Comment on this
The others will depend on a report to Government from the Commissioner, which I believe is due shortly. I know Rush Garda station was one that was signalled as being a potential one. The Government expects that report shortly.
Comment on this
I want to ask about the social welfare and pensions Bill. We were informed today that there is yet another bilateral agreement between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil on the passing of that Bill. Our party spokesperson, Deputy Willie Penrose, sought to engage with the Minister on it. For the information of the other Members of the House who are not part of this arrangement - any pretence now that there is not a formal coalition between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil is becoming strained - when will the social welfare Bill be published? Why, as announced today by Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael bilaterally, is a threshold of €5,000 for disclosures being applied to social welfare fraud when the threshold for Revenue fraud is €30,000 before disclosures happen?
Comment on this
I understand that Bill will be published shortly and the Business Committee has agreed that it will be taken initially next Thursday.
Comment on this
How can it be taken before we will have seen it?
Comment on this
It is being published this week and will be taken next week.
Comment on this
I call Deputy Ruth Coppinger. Is the Deputy's question on promised legislation or the programme for Government?
Comment on this
It is on promised legislation. When will the passenger name record Bill be introduced? Will it take up the issue of a sinister and chilling experience of a US based academic, Catherine Kelly, in an Irish airport last week? She was stopped in the airport by two plain-clothes gardaí, asked her name, if she uses social media and if she had written an article about the Minister, Deputy Regina Doherty, and her business dealings. A complaint had been made and she was cautioned not to tweet the Minister or any material relevant to her again.
Comment on this
This question relates to legislation. She was told to sign a statement that she-----
Comment on this
Obviously, her name was given by an airline to the gardaí. She was told to sign a statement or she would not be allowed proceed to the gate.
Comment on this
In the blog she merely raised issues-----
Comment on this
-----about the Minister's dealings in a bankrupt company in 2009.
Comment on this
If it is a matter of promised legislation, the Minister will answer, but this is not a Second Stage debate.
Comment on this
This is about promised legislation.
Comment on this
More censorship.
Comment on this
A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, can I finish my point?
Comment on this
I am referring to Deputies on the Fine Gael benches.
Comment on this
Will the Leas-Cheann Comhairle let me speak?
Comment on this
I am complying with the regulations that I have to implement to which the Deputy's group is a party.
Comment on this
I was referring to the comments of the Fine Gael Deputies.
Comment on this
I will just finish.
Comment on this
We have heard a lot about social media this week. Is it now Government policy to attack, in this very sinister way, anybody who criticises anyone in the Government on social media-----
Comment on this
-----in a very legitimate article, which was not abusive, that raised questions about-----
Comment on this
There are Members who have waited here patiently all day and the Deputy got to speak by virtue of the fact that she is representing her group. There are other Members behind her who want to speak.
Comment on this
It is a legitimate question.
Comment on this
I understand preparatory work is being done on the Bill that was mentioned in the Department of Justice and Equality.
Comment on this
I understand that. I obey that rule. I am here all the time.
Comment on this
The programme for Government specifically commits to supporting the agriculture industry. Farmers have been in Agriculture House since yesterday evening because they have not been paid the compensation they were meant to be paid following a debate in this House and a commitment made to pay them from a distressed fund. They should be at home now-----
Comment on this
-----preparing for their own missed harvest, as it were. The Minister would not meet them. There will be a sit-in for the whole weekend. I ask the Minister if he, the Taoiseach or the Tánaiste will direct the Minister, Deputy Creed, to meet these farmers.
Comment on this
No, I have the list. There are no priorities with me when I am in the Chair. I call Deputy Jackie Cahill. I want Deputies to keep their questions short and concise because the Minister will reply to them all with one answer.
Comment on this
Last January Fianna Fáil moved a Private Members' Bill that would allow a fund to be set up to deal with farmers who were severely affected as a result of the 2016 grain harvest. It would allow €15,000 be paid to each farmer, which would be some step towards restoring some of their losses.
Comment on this
Earlier this week there was a leaked report in the media-----
Comment on this
------that stated that there would be only-----
Comment on this
-----a maximum of €5,000 paid to each farmer and €1.5 million allocated to the fund. I would like the Minister to comment on whether this is the exact situation? If it is, it is a totally inadequate response to the financial crisis that these farmers have faced. It would not be in the spirit of the motion that was passed here in January.
Comment on this
I most certainly will be. It is a disgrace that last night these farmers had to stay overnight in Agriculture House. They were promised a compensation package of €15,000. They are looking for an envelope of money to be shared out. It does not involve all that many farmers. They had the worst harvest ever last year. They stayed up all night last night in Agriculture House-----
Comment on this
-----when they should have been at home running their businesses. I call on the Minister, for God sake, to stand up and-----
Comment on this
I call Deputy Anne Rabbitte. I have the same question for the Deputy. We will not get beyond this issue.
Comment on this
I ask that the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine to meet the president of the Irish Farmers' Association, IFA, today to discuss what Deputy Jackie Cahill is just after discussing.
Comment on this
I would like to add my voice to those of the other Deputies who have raised this issue. I thought the day was long gone when the farmers of this country would have to protest and-----
Comment on this
It is on promised legislation. It concerns the payment of this money.
Comment on this
The allocation of €5,000 funding as a maximum is a insult to any man who lost his livelihood last year owing to bad weather. The Minister needs to meet this group, discuss the matter with them and give them a fair package.
Comment on this
In all fairness, I think Deputy Danny Healy-Rae's two colleagues have represented him very well.
Comment on this
There will be no time for anybody else.
Comment on this
There will be no time for anybody else to raise a matter.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Minister to meet-----
Comment on this
-----these people and let these honest people go home.
Comment on this
Do any other Deputies have a question on agriculture? I call Deputy Kevin O'Keeffe. Is the Deputy's question on promised legislation?
Comment on this
Yes. I want the amount of the compensation increased from €1.5 million to €4 million. I presume that would require legislation.
Comment on this
I understand that the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine received a request from the IFA for him to meet it yesterday. He is happy to meet it but it seems-----
Comment on this
This request came in yesterday. I am sure the Minister will schedule this. He is quite happy to meet the IFA in the normal course and he meets it frequently. He has been seeking to develop the outline of a crop loss compensation scheme, as the Deputies are aware. He is in discussions with the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform to develop the terms of that. He will meet with the IFA ahead of any such final decisions. As the Deputies will be aware, he has already announced plans for agri-cash loan scheme and I understand 90 tillage farmers have availed of that. There is the targeted agricultural modernisation scheme, TAMS, and there has been a very significant take up of that. The Minister is responding-----
Comment on this
-----and is happy to meet the IFA regarding this specific proposal.
Comment on this
Let them go home for the weekend.
Comment on this
Deputies have had their time, there are others behind them, please. Show respect for all.
Comment on this
On promised legislation, will the Minister update the House on the status of the Family Court Bill?
Comment on this
I do not have a detailed update. Work on it is ongoing within the Department but I will get a report on this for Deputy Carey.
Comment on this
The programme for Government, particularly under health, has a commitment to treat all our people equally and uniformly across the country. Late last week and earlier this week, it came as a huge surprise to survivors of breast cancer to learn the HSE had changed its policy on providing supports to post-mastectomy products to women who had been through a breast cancer procedure. There was a great outpouring of concern that future supports available to women who have survived breast cancer will be significantly reduced. The HSE and the Minister have said this will be suspended until August but we need clarity on this. Will everyone receive the same level of support post-breast cancer procedure and will it be at the existing amount, not the reduced amount which had been flagged by the HSE?
Comment on this
This week, the Minister for Health published a ten year strategy for cancer which seeks to build on the very significant progress which has been made in much longer survival and better recovery, which the strategy seeks to consolidate and progress. I will ask the Minister to respond specifically to the concern which Deputy Niall Collins raises. I do not have that answer to hand.
Comment on this
There is a huge crisis in respite care for adults, particularly with intellectual or physical disabilities. This has been mentioned for the summer in the case of children. Is the emergency funding put in place this year for respite only to pay off the emergency funding for last year? Is there any funding there for respite during the summer months for the families that desperately need it?
Comment on this
Again, I do not have a detailed response for the provision of respite care but I will seek to make the information on this available to the House.
Comment on this
The next three questions are from Deputies Scanlon, Martin Kenny and Fitzpatrick. I will review any more that arise after that.
Comment on this
The programme for Government gives a commitment to provide funding to IDA Ireland and local authorities for job creation. Currently in Sligo, IDA Ireland has not a square inch of land on which to build a plant or factory. This is because Finisklin industrial estate is full. The IDA has other lands but they need to access them. The local authority has applied for funding for an inner relief road in Sligo which will cost around €14 million. I appeal to the Minister and to the Minister of State, Deputy Phelan, who is seated behind, him to expedite this.
Comment on this
I understand IDA Ireland has committed to an advanced facility in Sligo. Land acquisition is an element in that. I will draw IDA Ireland's attention to the Deputy's concern over progress but this was one of the significant elements in the new regional enterprise strategy, that the regions would be supported through the IDA as well as Enterprise Ireland. It is something to which the Government is very strongly committed.
Comment on this
On page 89 of the programme for Government, in a section about education, it says that in three months the Government will commence a review of the teacher appointment thresholds in schools where there are four teachers or fewer. Kiltyclogher school in north Leitrim is a two teacher school. Next September, the numbers have fallen-----
Comment on this
This relates to the programme for Government, page 89.
Comment on this
Next September, the pupil enrolments in this school will fall one pupil below the threshold for a two-teacher school. The numbers are expected to recover the following year so that the school will have sufficient numbers to retain a second teacher. Allowing a situation to develop where Kilyclogher school would become a one-teacher school for that year could jeopardise enrolment numbers in future years and endanger the sustainability of the school in the long term. I understand that this review of teacher appointment thresholds in smaller schools has not happened. Will the Minister use his good offices to keep the two teachers in place in Kiltyclogher school next September in keeping with the spirit of the commitment in the programme for Government that no small school will close?
Comment on this
The Government is committed to no small school closing. Ahead of last year's budget, we conducted an initial review of initiatives. Some initiatives were included in last year's budget to try to protect smaller, isolated, and island schools. Each year, in the context of the budget, we take a fresh look at initiatives that we might take in this area but ahead of the budgetary deliberations, I cannot give any indication of initiatives in this area.
Comment on this
Regulation is a key rule of approved housing bodies, of which there are 520, with over 26,000 units. They are private, non-profit and relieve housing needs. Regulation provides assurances for tenants, and both Governments and potential investors-----
Comment on this
It also demonstrates that the Government is delivering on its key priorities and policies.
Comment on this
When can we expect a housing Bill to provide a regulatory framework for approved housing bodies by establishing a housing regulator for approved housing bodies which include every housing association-----
Comment on this
It is hoped that will be published in the next session. It is on the Government priority list.
Comment on this
If I might continue. I have so many more questions put down, for the record the names on the list are those of Deputies Curran, Murphy, O'Loughlin, Nolan, Durkan, McLouglin, MacSharry, Madigan, Heydon and Neville. They have all requested and I will ask that next week we might consider a longer period on a Thursday. That is not a matter for me, but for the reform committee.