Medicinal cannabis committee dispute
Deputy Boyd Barrett challenged the handling of the medicinal cannabis Bill, arguing that the committee had no right to block it and that the process was a sabotage of a democratically passed Bill. The Chair and Tánaiste defended the committee’s role and said a substantive motion would come back in September; the prolonged procedural row ended with assurances that the matter would return then.
On a point of order, I asked to come in on a similar issue to Deputy Gino Kenny. The Ceann Comhairle did not allow it but he then let several other people do exactly that on other issues.
Comment on this
On the same issue.
Comment on this
-----when the issue had already been raised and addressed by the Tánaiste. If a Deputy indicates in advance when a matter is raised, I have no difficulty. The Deputy cannot come in after the event. He has made his point of order so I ask him to resume his seat.
Comment on this
I have not, actually.
Comment on this
I have not. I am making a point of order. This is the last day of the Dáil.
Comment on this
This is the last chance we will have to question what is on the Dáil schedule.
Comment on this
A report has been produced about Deputy Gino Kenny's medicinal cannabis Bill-----
Comment on this
-----where it has been stated that this Bill is going to be stopped even though it was passed democratically last December.
Comment on this
That is a subversion of the authority of the Dáil.
Comment on this
It is.
Comment on this
The health committee has no right to decide that a Bill that was passed by this House is not going any further.
Comment on this
Just a second, Deputy. I want to clarify the position in respect of a Bill that has been the subject of some debate.
Comment on this
The Cannabis for Medicinal Use Regulation Bill 2016.
Comment on this
Yes, the Cannabis for Medicinal Use Regulation Bill 2016. An all-party Oireachtas committee, which is chaired by a respected Independent Deputy, has produced a report on the matter.
Comment on this
We are not on that committee.
Comment on this
That report will form the basis of a motion that will have to come before the House in September. When that motion comes before the House, I expect that the Business Committee will provide for an opportunity for the matter to be debated. That is the procedure. That is the democratic process in action and in operation. I appeal to Deputy Boyd Barrett to respect that process. It has worked in the past. I do not see why it would not work in relation to the particular issues about which he is concerned.
Comment on this
I would like to respond briefly. For the record, it is not an all-party committee. The party and group that put forward this Bill is not represented on the committee. I think there has been an absolutely outrageous sabotage of this Bill for the most spurious of reasons. Medical evidence from doctors, the Irish Medical Organisation, Professor Mike Barnes, Professor David Finn and many other people who are experts in this area has been distorted and denied. Instead, the committee has relied on expert evidence from the pharmaceutical industry.
Comment on this
I will finish on this point. The procedural clarification given by the Ceann Comhairle was necessary because the message that went out from the Chairman of the committee and other members of the committee was to the effect that they had a right to stop this Bill from proceeding to Committee Stage. They do not have that right. Only the Dáil has that right. In fact, Standing Order 141 suggests that once a Bill goes past Second Stage, notwithstanding the right of the committee to scrutinise it or to refer it back to the Dáil, it will go to Committee Stage. Many other Bills, including Deputy McLoughlin's Bill, have been substantially changed on the basis of legal advice, but have still gone to Committee Stage. In this case, the Bill is being sabotaged by all the representatives on the health committee. The Deputies who put the Bill forward-----
Comment on this
Was it unanimous?
Comment on this
Was it unanimous?
Comment on this
Was it unanimous?
Comment on this
It was sabotage.
Comment on this
The point is made, a Cheann Comhairle.