Questions on Promised Legislation
- Order of Business 1 speech
The Chair outlines the short time available and asks Members to keep questions focused on promised legislation or the programme for Government.
Pat the Cope Gallagher
- Mental health nurse contracts 2 speeches
Deputy Kelleher raises the failure to recruit mental health nurse graduates on permanent contracts despite programme commitments. The Tánaiste says CAMHS recruitment is progressing and will raise the matter with the Minister for Health.
Billy Kelleher, Frances Fitzgerald
- Domestic violence legislation 2 speeches
Deputy McDonald seeks a date for pre-legislative scrutiny of consolidated domestic violence legislation and the Istanbul Convention Bill. The Tánaiste says the legislation is in the Seanad, signing the convention is intended by year-end, and the legislation should be available soon.
Mary Lou McDonald, Frances Fitzgerald
- Technological Universities Bill 2 speeches
Deputy Howlin asks when amendments to the stalled Technological Universities Bill 2015 will be published and when it will return to committee. The Minister of State says the amendments are being drafted and hopes to complete the legislation before year end.
Brendan Howlin, Mary Mitchell O'Connor
- Garda Síochána Bill and Jobstown case 8 speeches
Deputy Coppinger asks when the Garda Síochána Bill will be ready, linking it to the dropped Jobstown charges and calling for independent investigation and overturning of a conviction. After procedural interventions, the Tánaiste says work is under way on the Bill and decisions of the DPP are independent.
Ruth Coppinger, Pat the Cope Gallagher, Seán Sherlock, Frances Fitzgerald
- Health amendment Bill and hunger strike 7 speeches
Deputy McGrath raises the hunger strike of Timothy Jackson and asks that a video about the eighth amendment be considered in deliberations. The Chair steers him back to legislation, and the Tánaiste says the committee controls its own work and that work is under way on the health (amendment) Bill.
Mattie McGrath, Pat the Cope Gallagher, Ruth Coppinger, Frances Fitzgerald
- Commercial rates Bill 2 speeches
Deputy Cassells seeks a timetable for the commercial rates Bill and criticises the burden on towns such as Navan. The Tánaiste says it is an important modernising Bill and should go to committee for pre-legislative scrutiny soon.
Shane Cassells, Frances Fitzgerald
- Local improvement scheme funding 9 speeches
Deputy Scanlon says rural local authorities have received many applications but no funding certainty for the local improvement scheme, amid a dispute between Ministers. After interjections about who is paying, the Tánaiste confirms there is funding for Donegal, and the Chair notes the amount for Sligo.
Eamon Scanlon, Mattie McGrath, Tony McLoughlin, Frances Fitzgerald, Billy Kelleher
- Market and Financial Instruments Bill 3 speeches
Deputy Rock asks about the impact of EU supervisory reform proposals on the Market and Financial Instruments Bill and MiFID II transposition. The Tánaiste says pre-legislative scrutiny will happen shortly and the Bill will be fully published during the term.
Pat the Cope Gallagher, Noel Rock, Simon Coveney
- Homelessness in Bray 14 speeches
Deputy Brady describes a homeless man’s death in Bray and the wider local homelessness crisis, pressing for action for tents and emergency accommodation. After repeated reminders that the session is for promised legislation, the Tánaiste expresses sympathy and points to homelessness initiatives and increased emergency beds.
Pat the Cope Gallagher, John Brady, Simon Coveney
- Disabilities convention ratification 2 speeches
Deputy Murphy O’Mahony asks for a firm date for ratifying the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. The Tánaiste says final amendments are being prepared, with signing and legislation intended by year end.
Margaret Murphy O'Mahony, Frances Fitzgerald
- Mental Health (Amendment) Bill 3 speeches
Deputy Buckley asks when the Mental Health (Amendment) Bill will be taken in the Seanad. The Tánaiste says the Dáil stages are complete and the timetable now rests with the Seanad.
Pat Buckley, Pat the Cope Gallagher, Frances Fitzgerald
- Border region job creation 5 speeches
Deputy McLoughlin raises weak job growth in the Border region and asks what the Government is doing to rebalance it, especially with Brexit pressures. The Tánaiste says the issue is being addressed through economic development and the Action Plan for Jobs, including regional plans.
Tony McLoughlin, Pat the Cope Gallagher, Frances Fitzgerald
- Regulation of housing bodies 2 speeches
Deputy O’Sullivan asks when legislation to regulate voluntary housing bodies will be published so they can borrow for social housing construction. The Tánaiste says it is a priority for the term and will be before the House this term.
Jan O'Sullivan, Frances Fitzgerald
- Health transport support Bill 2 speeches
Deputy Carey asks for the status of the health (transport support) Bill. The Tánaiste says it will come before the House this session.
Joe Carey, Frances Fitzgerald
- Roscommon mental health services 9 speeches
Deputy Murphy raises a review criticising Roscommon mental health services, speaking of past underspends, patient distress and deaths, and asking whether funds should be returned locally. The Tánaiste says the legislation is being worked on and that recruitment difficulties often explain service failures, which the HSE must address.
Eugene Murphy, Pat the Cope Gallagher, Frances Fitzgerald
- Sports capital and village renewal 5 speeches
Deputy Breathnach asks when the sports capital grants and village renewal programme will be issued under the programme for Government. The Tánaiste says the capital initiative is being prioritised and announcements will be made before year end.
Declan Breathnach, Frances Fitzgerald, Pat the Cope Gallagher
- Personal Injuries Assessment Board Bill 2 speeches
Deputy Durkan asks when the promised PIAB amendment Bill will come before the House after pre-legislative scrutiny. The Tánaiste says it is listed for this session.
Bernard Durkan, Frances Fitzgerald
- Mobility and transport grants 2 speeches
Deputy Ó Caoláin presses for the long-awaited replacement scheme for mobility and motorised transport grants and asks when the heads of Bill will be published. The Tánaiste says the Bill is intended for publication this term.
Caoimhghín Ó Caoláin, Frances Fitzgerald
- Micro-plastics in maritime Bill 2 speeches
Deputy Sherlock asks when the Government will legislate to ban micro-plastics, possibly through the Maritime Area and Foreshore Bill, and mentions his own Bill. The Tánaiste says Parliamentary Counsel advice is awaited and the Minister will liaise on including it.
Seán Sherlock, Frances Fitzgerald
- Garda Commissioner replacement 2 speeches
Deputy Ó Laoghaire seeks cross-party consultation on appointing a new Garda Commissioner in the interests of political buy-in. The Tánaiste says the process is the responsibility of the Policing Authority and the Public Appointments Service.
Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire, Frances Fitzgerald
- Assisted human reproduction legislation 3 speeches
Deputy O’Reilly asks when the general scheme for assisted human reproduction legislation will be available. The Tánaiste says consultation and legal advice are ongoing and a Bill will be published as soon as possible.
Louise O'Reilly, Frances Fitzgerald, Pat the Cope Gallagher
We have only 15 minutes for Questions on Promised Legislation and I will not be able to accommodate all Members who wish to speak. Perhaps the Business Committee could examine timing at a later stage. I ask Members to confine themselves to short, focused questions on promised legislation or the programme for Government.
Comment on this
The programme for Government, the supply and confidence agreement and A Vision for Change all refer to improving 24 hour service support and liaison teams for mental health in primary and emergency care. Last year the HR director of the HSE wrote to all nursing graduates to say that permanent contracts would be put in place. However, mental health nurse graduates are not being recruited on permanent contracts. I ask that the Tánaiste consider this in the context of the commitment in the programme for Government to ensuring there is adequate support and services for mental health nurses in primary care teams and emergency care teams.
Comment on this
There is a focus on mental health and ensuring that there are teams all over the country. There are now 64 teams in place under the CAMHS service which indicates that recruitment is successfully taking place. I will raise the point made by Deputy Kelleher with the Minister for Health, Deputy Harris.
Comment on this
I wish to mention the consolidated domestic violence legislation which I have raised consistently in the House.
This Government and the previous one made repeated commitments to bring forward such legislation.
Can the Tánaiste give us a specific date for when the heads of Bill for the criminal justice (Istanbul Convention) Bill will be ready for pre-legislative scrutiny?
Comment on this
The domestic violence consolidated legislation the Deputy mentioned is in the Seanad and I would like to see it go through that House as quickly as possible. I was very pleased to introduce that important Bill.
The Government is working closely with the Departments of Justice and Equality and of Health to deal with one issue that has arisen in respect of signing the convention. It is intended to sign the convention by the end of this year. The legislation should be available soon.
Comment on this
For almost 18 months, the Technological Universities Bill 2015 has been stalled and the merger of the institutions towards technological university status has also been impeded considerably. Announcements have been made about amendments. When will the amendments be published and when will the Bill be back in committee?
Comment on this
The amendments for the Technological Universities Bill 2015 are being drafted and I am hoping to have them soon and to deal with that legislation before the end of the year.
Comment on this
When will the Garda Síochána Bill be ready relating to complaints and investigations by the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission? I raise this in light of the news last night that all charges have been dropped against future Jobstown defendants.
Comment on this
I named the legislation already.
Comment on this
Does this not now warrant independent investigation into why this fiasco began and went as far as it did, in respect of money and the resources of the Garda, and given that the evidence of the gardaí is not now considered fit for a jury? Is the Tánaiste concerned that the only person now convicted in respect of that event is a minor? He now has a criminal conviction hanging over him for the rest of his life. That conviction must now be overturned.
Comment on this
All the people have been vindicated and that young man should not have this hanging over him.
Comment on this
Work is under way on that Bill. Decisions taken by the Director of Public Prosecutions, DPP, are a matter for the DPP. It is an independent office and that is absolutely in keeping with our system of justice, the separation of powers and the due process approach to criminal justice.
Comment on this
I am sure the Tánaiste is aware that a young man from Donegal, Timothy Jackson, is on his fourth day of hunger strike outside the House.
Comment on this
It is the health (amendment) Bill. He has written to the Taoiseach and the Minister for Health asking them to view a short video of a situation regarding the eighth amendment. He wants the Taoiseach to ask the Joint Committee on the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution to view this video as part of its deliberations on any repeal or otherwise. It can be viewed at whiteflag.ie.
Comment on this
I think they should watch it.
Comment on this
Any decision about the work of the committee is a matter for the committee of which the Deputy is a member.
Comment on this
Of course. I have written to the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
The commercial rates Bill appears to be very low in the list of priorities on the legislative programme with no pre-legislative scrutiny date determined. When does the Government expect to see this advanced? Many towns outside Dublin are trying to share in the recovery experienced in the capital. I see this particularly in my home town, Navan, where the archaic system is thwarting any entrepreneurs trying to grow their businesses. When will it be considered and advanced? Does the Tánaiste think it right that in the past year business contributions to the running of local councils have increased to €1.5 billion, 36% of the income up from 29% in 2010 because councils are forced to increase rates due to rising costs.
Comment on this
This is an important Bill to modernise and consolidate the approach to commercial rates and it is expected that the Bill will go before the committee for pre-legislative scrutiny soon.
Comment on this
The programme for Government contains a commitment to support people living in rural areas. On 28 August every local authority in the State was advised to accept applications to participate in a local improvement scheme, a scheme under which people make a contribution where there are more than two people living on a road. The closing date was 14 September and I understand works have to be completed by 24 November. To date, the local authority in Sligo has received 250 applications, the local authority in County Leitrim has received 210, while the local authority in County Donegal has also received 250.
Comment on this
The problem arises from an apparent dispute between two Ministers, Deputies Shane Ross and Michael Ring, over who will fund the scheme. The work must be completed within the next three to four weeks, but the local authorities have not been informed of funding.
Comment on this
Who is paying for it? Where is the money?
Comment on this
Is the figure €282,000 for the local authority in Sligo? I am glad to hear it.
Comment on this
Who is taking the credit? Is it the Minister, Deputy Shane Ross, or the Minister, Deputy Michael Ring?
Comment on this
Deputy Eamon Scanlon has got his funding, on which I congratulate him.
The Market and Financial Instruments Bill is important legislation. Has the relevant Minister considered the potential implications of the European Commission's proposals announced yesterday relating to reforming the European supervisory authority and specifically the proposal to amend the MiFID II directive? What is the anticipated impact on the transposition in Ireland of the MiFID II directive? Will the Tánaiste consult the relevant Minister on the Market and Financial Instruments Bill which is priority legislation?
Comment on this
I do not think the relevant Minister is in the House. Prelegislative scrutiny of the Bill will take place shortly and there will be full publication in the course of this term.
Comment on this
On housing and particularly homelessness, in Bray in my constituency of Wicklow a homeless man aged 41 years was found dead in a tent on Saturday morning. It was a tragedy. I listened to the Tánaiste's empty rhetoric. Joseph, the man who passed away, was not the only homeless person in Bray. While we sit here, there are homeless persons sleeping in tents on the top of Bray Head. There are people sleeping in tents under footbridges along the N11. The Tánaiste's empty rhetoric does nothing for them.
Comment on this
While there has been much talk about providing 200 emergency beds for homeless persons in coming months, none of it caters for my constituency. There are homeless families, women and families, being put up in women's refuges-----
Comment on this
The Deputy is depriving his colleagues of their time. He cannot circumvent the rules.
Comment on this
What is the Government doing to address the homeless crisis in my constituency?
Comment on this
It is included in the programme for Government.
Comment on this
I am asking what will be included in it to address what is a serious problem.
Comment on this
The Deputy is depriving his colleagues of their time. We cannot circumvent the rules. Does the Tánaiste wish to answer?
Comment on this
Like everyone in the House, I express my deepest sympathy to the family of the man in question. Everyone in the House shares the concern about the situation in which he found himself. I have outlined the initiatives being taken to deal with the very serious issue of homelessness, including the increased number of emergency beds, to ensure people will have access to better facilities than those outlined by the Deputy.
Comment on this
Will the Tánaiste give a specific date for the ratification of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons With Disabilities?
The Tánaiste must excuse my cynicism, because exactly this time last year I asked for a date and we were told it would be before the end of the year. The Taoiseach has stated the Government is using a different approach to other European countries, and this is certainly true because I find its approach very hands-off and I would like a more specific date, please.
Comment on this
The Department of Health and the Department Justice and Equality are working together on finalising the amendments for the Bill, particularly on the issue of deprivation of liberty, which is a very complex issue. We intend to sign the convention by the end of this year and bring the relevant legislation to the House before then. The point the Taoiseach was making is that some countries signed before they did all of the work or developed the services for those with a disability. We have taken the approach that we want to make sure everything is in place before we sign it. That is actually more constructive approach. It means better services for people with disabilities.
Comment on this
Is it possible to get a date for when the Mental Health (Amendment) Bill, which passed through the House on the final day before the summer recess, will be taken in the Seanad?
Comment on this
We completed all Stages in the Dáil and it has gone to the Seanad. It is a matter for the Seanad to decide on the exact timetable for it. I am sure if the Deputy makes inquiries there he will be told.
Comment on this
In the programme for Government, special consideration is given to the creation of new jobs in many rural areas throughout the country. The Tánaiste is aware the Border region, of which counties Sligo, Leitrim and south Donegal are part, has, unfortunately, witnessed the lowest level of job growth than any other region.
Comment on this
On this basis, will the Tánaiste please advise the House on the efforts the Government is making to rebalance this job creation growth, particularly given Brexit and weakening sterling, which have already resulted in job losses in the region?
Comment on this
This will primarily be affected by continued economic development and the Action Plan for Jobs, and I assure the Deputy the Regional Action Plan for Jobs will make absolutely sure every area in the country benefits from the job creation we see, as it has already in terms of the percentage of jobs last year. There was growth in Dublin but there was also growth in all regions. The area about which the Deputy is speaking is an area that does need focus and attention.
Comment on this
In the context of the urgent need for more social housing, some of the larger voluntary housing associations have been making a very strong case that if they could show they were regulated they could borrow money to build substantial numbers of social houses. It is a year and a half since there was pre-legislative scrutiny on the Bill to regulate the voluntary housing sector and the approved housing bodies. It is on the list. When will the legislation be published?
Comment on this
It is a priority for this term and the Minister will ensure it will be before the House this term.
Comment on this
I wish to ask the Tánaiste about the status of the health (transport support) Bill. When will it come before the House?
Comment on this
In the programme for Government six key issues were laid out on improving mental health services, and we all subscribe to this. The Tánaiste is aware that recently a review of mental health services in County Roscommon was published. This review had been ongoing since 2015. It referred to a culture of blame, secrecy and negativity in Roscommon mental health services.
Comment on this
It is with regard to the programme for Government. I will not delay on this and I will not fire Scuds left, right and centre, but this is very revealing. In 2012, €4.57 million was returned to the HSE from County Roscommon. In 2013, a sum of €6.9 million was returned to the HSE and in 2014 a sum of €6.19 million was returned. This amounts to more than €17 million. The report revealed that people died in the county. There are heartbroken families. Recently, a woman sat in my clinic and cried.
Comment on this
Yes, it is in the programme for Government. On three occasions this woman spoke to psychiatrists and each time it was a different psychiatrist. She has had to tell her story over and over again.
The Taoiseach was Minister for Health for part of the time in question. Will the €17.2 million be returned to the mental health services in County Roscommon, which are in deep crisis? None of us wants more tragedy.
Comment on this
With regard to the point the Deputy makes, very often the explanation is the difficulty in recruiting staff, but that is obviously an issue on which the HSE needs to focus to ensure that where the money is available, the services will be developed and delivered in the types of circumstances described by the Deputy.
Comment on this
In the programme for Government, there is a commitment to both urban and rural regeneration and rejuvenation. Could the Tánaiste tell us specifically when the sports capital grant for this year will be issued? When will the village renewal programme be announced? It is normally announced at this time of year. I am led to believe it has been postponed until October. Perhaps Deputy McLoughlin knows the answer.
Comment on this
It is in the programme for Government.
Comment on this
Under the programme for Government, this has been a very important capital initiative to help local communities to develop sports services. That is being prioritised again this year. The Minister, Deputy Shane Ross, and the Minister of State, Deputy Griffin, will be making announcements before the of the year in regard to it.
Comment on this
The Personal Injuries Assessment Board (amendment) Bill has been promised for some time. Pre-legislative scrutiny took place on 27 June last. When is it likely to come before the House given its importance?
Comment on this
I raise again the long-awaited scheme to replace the mobility and motorised transport grants. I heard the Tánaiste's earlier response but I have been told on numerous occasions that the heads of the Bill would be presented shortly. We do not even have the heads of the Bill, yet the Tánaiste is saying she expects the legislation will be enacted before the end of the year. Is that really realistic? What is the delay? When can we expect the heads of the Bill so we can have a Parliament, with all its elements, really addressing the long-awaited replacement scheme?
Comment on this
I have a technical question. The Maritime Area and Foreshore (Amendment) Bill is on the long list. The Government had given some indication that it would legislate for the prohibition of micro-plastics in that Bill. I would like the Government to clarify when it will legislate for that. I have a Bill that is due before committee. The ten-week window has long since passed. I had said to the Government that I was willing to wait for the publication of its legislation and that I will be happy to withdraw mine if it passes muster. That still has not happened. What is the status of the Government's proposed Bill?
Comment on this
The advice of the Parliamentary Counsel has been sought on that Bill. We have to await that advice. I will ask the Minister to liaise directly on the detail as to how that might be included.
Comment on this
In the programme for Government, there is a commitment to improving oversight and accountability in policing. In the context of that and the resignation of the Garda Commissioner, will the Government, including the Minister for Justice and Equality, consider meeting all Opposition parties regarding the process for the replacement of the Garda Commissioner to ensure full political buy-in concerning that appointment?
Comment on this
Responsibility for that recruitment lies with the Policing Authority and the Public Appointments Service.
Comment on this
I have asked about the status of the assisted human reproduction legislation. I was assured by the Minister for Health in the last term that it was a priority. It has not managed to make it onto the priority list. Can the Tánaiste give us an idea when the general scheme will be available? I ask simply because many people want to know when they will get that assistance.
Comment on this
It is important legislation. The Minister, Deputy Harris, spoke about it recently and recognised it as such. Consultation is underway with stakeholders and some legal advice is being sought. He is anxious to publish a Bill as soon as possible. It is not down as a priority for this term because of the ongoing background work. I am sure the Deputy will receive further information in the House in the period ahead.