Mandatory sentencing for violent crime
Deputy Breathnach called for zero tolerance, no bail and mandatory sentencing for knife and gun offences under criminal justice legislation. The Minister said there was no Government proposal for mandatory sentencing and warned it would require very careful consideration.
Under promised criminal justice legislation, it is widely known that there is an increase of over 14% in violent crime in this country. In my own town of Dundalk, we witnessed the stabbing and killing of Yosuke Sasaki, which made the headlines around the world. In this last month, five people have died as a result of stabbings. I am asking that in the criminal justice legislation we provide for zero tolerance, no bail and mandatory sentencing for anybody convicted of a crime relating to use of weapons such as knives and guns. I am asking that those provisions be brought to this House. What is happening is intolerable.
Allied to that is the fact that a migrant can move freely with no papers, as is the case-----
Comment on this
It is in respect of criminal justice legislation being brought before the House.
Comment on this
I do not know of any proposal from Government to introduce mandatory sentencing. This has been a very controversial issue whereby the Oireachtas seeks to remove discretion from judges to evaluate the individual merits of each case. It would have to be done with very careful consideration. The Deputy would have to consider with his own party and with others whether such an approach would command support across the House. I know the Minister of Justice and Equality would have very serious misgivings around mandatory sentencing as a principle. It has not proven particularly effective where it has been introduced. The House would have to give it very serious consideration. That is in no way to understate the genuine concern the Deputy has expressed about the increase in violent crime and the need to have effective policing and justice in those cases.