We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Order of Business

Planning contact and influence

Summary

Deputy Mary Lou McDonald criticised the Taoiseach's claimed intervention in a planning matter involving Donald Trump and asked that such contacts be legally prohibited in future planning law. The Minister said the Deputy was referring to different legislation, but confirmed that amendments could be tabled when the relevant Bill comes before the House.

I was at the event in Washington last week when the Taoiseach told his tale on how he intervened on behalf of Donald Trump with regard to a planning application close to Trump's Doonbeg resort in County Clare. The relaying of this tale raised a real concern for many people because of the past experiences in the State of political and ministerial interference in the planning process and all that flowed from that. It is a bad situation when a Minister takes a call from a wealthy businessman and makes such an informal intervention on his behalf. There is no way on earth that an ordinary person would have such privileged access or such an intervention. There is scope for inappropriate contact, or at least the perception of inappropriate contract, where Ministers take such calls from wealthy business people on planning matters and then raise the matters in this manner.

Comment on this

We are supposed to be discussing promised legislation here Deputy.

Comment on this

My question relates to the planning and development Bill, which I understand is due for publication this year. Can we have the law amended to ensure that such contact is legally prohibited?

Comment on this
Eoghan Murphy Minister for Housing, Planning and Local Government Fine Gael

The Planning and Development (Strategic Infrastructure )(Amendment ) Bill 2017, which is currently passing through the Houses, is due in the Seanad where amendments will be taken on strategic infrastructural investment, such as data centres for example. Is this the legislation to which the Deputy refers?

Comment on this

No. It is the next Bill.

Comment on this

Is that the Bill coming after that planning Bill? The amendment will be in relation to what? I am sorry Deputy.

Comment on this

As I explained, the scenario set out by An Taoiseach in Washington was one of contact that was made to him, while he was overseas, by a very wealthy and influential businessman-----

Comment on this

The Minister, Deputy Murphy, knows-----

Comment on this

The Taoiseach told the story of how he intervened in that. I am asking-----

Comment on this

If the Deputy wishes-----

Comment on this

I ask that such contact be-----

Comment on this

There was no inappropriate contact-----

Comment on this

I was asked by the Minister to clarify.

Comment on this

-----in that point in question because there was a role for the tourism board that was involved, but if Sinn Féin wants to submit an amendment when the Bill comes before the House then it is perfectly entitled to do so.

Comment on this