Sea-Fisheries statutory instrument
Deputy Micheál Martin challenges the Government’s handling of penalty points for illegal fishing and says primary legislation should be used rather than a statutory instrument. The Minister of State says he will check with the Minister, and the Chair ends Martin’s second round.
I have a question about the Sea-Fisheries (Amendment) Bill. As the Taoiseach knows, the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Deputy Creed, laid a statutory instrument before the House on Easter Monday to allow penalty points to be applied to fishing vessel owners who engaged in illegal, unreported and unregulated fishing. While we all agree with having a proper and fair regime in that regard, given the fate of previous statutory instruments that were proved to be unconstitutional, the Minister indicated that he would not do this by statutory instrument but rather by primary legislation and that he would consult other parties on it. He has not consulted other parties. My party has a particular difficulty with the statutory instrument. My question is why is the Government introducing a statutory instrument. The statutory instrument and the appeals process are unfair. Will the Government revert to its original position that it would introduce primary legislation to govern this issue, as it would allow for proper transparency and fairness for all concerned?
Comment on this
I acknowledge that I am not fully familiar with the proposal about the statutory instrument.
Comment on this
I cannot hear the Minister of State.
Comment on this
I am not fully familiar with the proposal about the statutory instrument, but if the Minister has said he intends to consult and revert to primary legislation, I presume that is what he will do. I can check.
Comment on this
The Minister of State might check with Deputy Pat The Cope Gallagher who is an acknowledged expert.
Comment on this
The statutory instrument has been laid before the House. I ask the Minister of State to consult Deputy Pat The Cope Gallagher.
Comment on this
I will check with my colleague, the Minister, Deputy Michael Creed, first.
Comment on this
Deputy Charlie McConalogue has proved to be an expert advocate on behalf of farmers who need fodder.