Child protection abuse case review
Deputy Ó Laoghaire raised a shocking abuse case, praised the women who spoke out, and questioned the adequacy of the State review mechanism. The Tánaiste said the national review panel was examining the case and a possible alternative review was under consideration.
Tuesday's "Prime Time" programme focused on a particularly shocking case of abuse and a failure on the part of State agencies. I take this opportunity to commend Rachel Barry and the women who asked to be identified as Amy and Sarah on their bravery. I have raised the issue of resources in the area of child protection before. However, no shortage of resources could ever excuse this level of failure or these children being left in danger when there was full knowledge of the risk that existed. The victims have said that they do not have any confidence in the review mechanism to which the Taoiseach referred yesterday. They do not believe that it will lead to a satisfactory outcome. They have called for a fully independent investigation. The Taoiseach has a responsibility to see that this happens. These women have written to the Minister for Children and Youth Affairs, Deputy Zappone, requesting the establishment of a commission of investigation similar to that relating to the Grace case. I urge the Taoiseach to respond positively to this request and to engage with the victims in order to ensure that such a commission is established.
Comment on this
As the Deputy indicated, the national review panel is reviewing this case. The Minister has received correspondence from the solicitor involved in the tragic case to which the Deputy referred. The Minister is considering whether she should make a recommendation to Government as to whether we would look at a different form of review. That decision has not yet been made but it is certainly under consideration.