Speaking time for Brexit debate
Deputy Micheál Martin argued that larger parties were being given too little time in the Brexit debate and called for proportional speaking rights. The Ceann Comhairle and the Chief Whip said the matter should go to the Business Committee, while Deputy Doherty sought confirmation that the debate timing would also be reconsidered.
May I come in on Thursday's business?
Comment on this
It relates to the Brexit debate. I said this before Christmas. We have a difficulty, as a party with up to 45 Deputies, with a pattern that has developed. My understanding was that a conclusion had arisen out of the Dáil reform committee that proportionate time would be allocated to the larger parties that would allow those parties to come back in a second time on substantive debates. Deputy Ryan is correct to stand up for the rights of Members of Parliament. I am standing up for the rights of the members of my parliamentary party. I signalled this before Christmas. A pattern has developed whereby there is a set 15 minutes for a party with 45 Deputies and a set 15 minutes for a party or grouping with two or three Deputies.
Comment on this
The Deputy is trying to squeeze out the Independents.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael are the one party now.
Comment on this
What emerged from the reform committee was that-----
Comment on this
Put them in together - full stop.
Comment on this
-----there would be a second opportunity for Members of the larger parties to contribute to a debate, but the debates have been shortened. The Government's initial proposal of a five-minute speech from each of the main representatives of each party on Brexit was insulting to the Dáil. It was just pathetic. This is the defining issue of our time, and the Government was offering five minutes to each party. Obviously, I do not mind any party having a say and an opportunity, but we have 45 Deputies. There must be some degree of proportionality. D'Hondt does not apply to debating time; it applies to everything else. I say this only in the interests of fairness and objectivity. A Brexit spokesman can get into a debate but a spokesman on foreign affairs, finance, social protection or agriculture cannot.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach agrees but he never does anything about it. The idea of 15-----
Comment on this
Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil are all the one now.
Comment on this
You scratch my back, I scratch yours.
Comment on this
With the greatest of respect, Deputy Healy-Rae's back has been well scratched by the reforms. Dáil reform has been beneficial to all and sundry, and this Dáil has been the fairest to all parties, irrespective of size-----
Comment on this
But not fair enough to the Deputy's party.
Comment on this
-----and no one can contradict that. What has happened here because of Dáil reform since the 2016 general election is unprecedented. That at least should be acknowledged and put on the record. However, there is a need for balance. We all agree with the use of D'Hondt in the allocation of Members to committees.
Comment on this
The time on Leaders' Questions-----
Comment on this
The same should apply to the backbenchers of large parties who are equally entitled to have some say on debates that are defining for this country and Europe.
Comment on this
The Deputy's point is well made. Proportionality was at the core of what was decided in respect of reform and speaking times. Let us bring forward the Business Committee meeting that was proposed for tomorrow. Let us have it this afternoon and consider the points made by Deputy Micheál Martin and others and supported, I think, by the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
Not by the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade.
Comment on this
I have no issue with this. To my knowledge, it has not been raised at the Business Committee during my time on it over the past few months.
Comment on this
The Chief Whip is right about that.
Comment on this
It is right and proper that we do it but this protocol preceded me and was agreed by the Business Committee before Christmas on similar issues and was put forward for the incorporeal meeting.
Comment on this
With respect, the Ceann Comhairle asked for the Business Committee to discuss the issue Deputy Micheál Martin raised. The substantive issue is that we address this issue with seriousness-----
Comment on this
-----and urgency. I am asking for clarification that the proposal we made before the Business Committee, and that I make again, that the debate on the preparedness for a no-deal Brexit take place on Wednesday, will also be discussed.