Order of Business
The Leas-Cheann Comhairle manages carry-over names and time limits while Dara Calleary presses the Government on guillotining promised legislation. The Taoiseach defends limiting debate in cases of filibuster, and the Chair reminds the House that guillotine decisions are made on the Order of Business.
The Ceann Comhairle has left three names to be carried over from yesterday: Deputies Durkan, McConalogue and Eugene Murphy. I will take the leaders first, however. I think we will get them all in, providing they abide by the time limits.
Comment on this
I note news of the new coalition between Fine Gael and Deputy McDonald's party in Seanad Éireann. They are introducing a guillotine on the Judicial Appointments Commission Bill. I wish the new coalition well. May it have happiness and prosperity.
Comment on this
In the context of promised legislation, is it the Government's intention to reintroduce the guillotine, or will it get permission from Deputy McDonald to do so, in this House for future legislation?
Comment on this
I have never been a fan of guillotines. In my six years as a Minister in three Government Departments I never used the guillotine once. There does come a point, however, at which a filibuster is under way and a minority in either this House or the Seanad are preventing a democratic decision from being made. I do not know how many hours of debate that Bill had. I think it was 70 or 80 hours.
Comment on this
-----would probably have difficulty getting elected to this House anyway, whatever about the other one. There comes a time when the use of a guillotine or limiting debate is merited, and that is when debate has gone on for four, five or six days and people are just repeating themselves or deliberately using filibustering tactics to prevent the majority from having its view. However, as the Government does not have a majority in either the Dáil or the Seanad, we cannot decide to use a guillotine. We will be able to curtail debate only if the majority of the House wants that to be done.