Leaders' exchange on farming and local cases
The Taoiseach strongly rejected Deputy Carthy's claims about the Agriculture Minister and defended the EU farming position, while Carthy kept insisting on a debate. Deputy Collins then argued with the Taoiseach over whether he had contacted him about the fishing incident; the Taoiseach said a debate could happen next week and later also addressed the maternity hospital issue.
I reject the assertions by Deputy Carthy that the Minister, Deputy McConalogue, is endeavouring to disadvantage Irish farmers-----
Comment on this
The Minister should come before the House and explain himself.
Comment on this
I did not interrupt the Deputy. The Minister is committed to agriculture and Irish farmers, and genuinely so. That should not be taken by-----
Comment on this
He is fighting against every redistributive measure at EU level.
Comment on this
He should come before the House and-----
Comment on this
The Deputy's mask slips every so often in regard to his basically anti-European Union position, in terms of net contributions and all the rest. He has fought against the European Union all his life-----
Comment on this
The Deputy will present everything and create a negative narrative on the European Union.
Comment on this
I remind everyone that we are not meant to be having lengthy debates about these matters. Is the Taoiseach prepared to change the Order of Business or take on board any of the proposals?
Comment on this
I want to be co-operative but if assertions are made that have nothing to do with the Order of Business-----
Comment on this
In that case, I think we will have to deal with that in the Business Committee because it is a recurring feature that this is an extended part of Leaders' Questions. That is what is going on here.
Comment on this
Excuse me. We are dealing with it and alternative arrangements will be brought forward for our next sitting.
Comment on this
The issues have not come to a conclusion, so we will have time for a debate next week.
To respond to Deputy Michael Collins, he did not ring me, and if the situation was that serious, he should have done so.
Comment on this
I rang the Taoiseach's office in Dublin that morning, and they put me through to the Cork section and I have got no reply since.
Comment on this
I left a message. The Taoiseach has to correct the record of the Dáil.
Comment on this
I have never in my life rang you, because I have never got any satisfaction from you.
Comment on this
You rang me looking for a vote but I knew you would turn your back on the people of west Cork, and I would not vote for you. Never once did I ring you.
Comment on this
Leaving that to one side, there is no issue with us having a debate next week or the week after that.
This is an ongoing issue. We will respond to the specifics of the case.
In terms of Holles Street hospital, Government proposals have not come before Cabinet. There will be time for a debate on that and for me and the Minister for Health to bring clarity to the House, but it has not come before Government.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the proposal for dealing with today's business be agreed to."
Do you agree with this result?