Section 47 family law assessments
Deputy Cronin raised concerns about women and children affected by section 47 family law assessments and asked who oversees assessors. The Taoiseach replied that broader child-protection issues can be discussed in the House but that the matter falls within separation of powers and other jurisdictions.
Since I raised in the House recently the impact on women and children of assessments under section 47 of the Family Law Act 1995, I have had a flood of contacts from yet more mothers and accredited practitioners in the psychological services outlining disturbing experiences of women and their children assessed under this process. One eminent practitioner is very anxious about mothers engaging in the process at all, such is the concern about how it operates. I have put down a series of questions to the Minister for Justice on the appointment, qualifications, accreditation and professional development of court assessors and their practices. In response, I received a letter from the Ceann Comhairle to say the Minister has no function in this matter.
I was not interfering in any case. I did not mention any case or any names. We are legislators and we make the laws in this House. We cannot ignore a situation where court assessors are making assessments of families within the justice system but are accountable to no one. They have all that power but no accountability. The mothers are silenced by the in camera rule and the Deputies who represent them are now stonewalled by the Oireachtas. How do we, as legislators, address this perverse situation whereby the Ceann Comhairle tells me the Minister for Justice has no function when children's lives are left hanging in the balance?
Comment on this
I was not interfering in the separation of powers.
Comment on this
First, more general issues in terms of protecting children and mothers can, of course, be discussed in this House at any time. However, the separation of powers means there are different jurisdictions where issues get dealt with.
Comment on this
To whom are these assessors accountable?
Comment on this
I do not think it is fair to say that this House is somehow suppressing the issue. I do not think that is the intention at all.