Leaving Certificate standardisation fairness
Deputy Ó Laoghaire warned that using historical school results in accredited grade standardisation would disadvantage students in disadvantaged schools. The Minister of State said fairness in DEIS and disadvantaged areas is being examined by the State examinations advisory group.
The issue of the leaving certificate has been raised. It is important we get an early decision. Reports in the media suggest that school historical results may be used in the standardisation of accredited grades. Two years ago, the Minister, Deputy Foley, correctly accepted that this would mean students in disadvantaged schools would lose out across the board. It is an elitist approach. There are viable alternatives in standardisation, including use of assessment tools as applied in the North, the use of rank order within a class to apply a percentage based average, and so on. We need a hybrid model. The use of historical data would be a mistake. It is elitist.
A solution based on those data might relieve stress on some people but it might also intensify the anxiety of students in schools in disadvantaged areas that previously had lower results.
Comment on this
It is extremely important when we are talking about the leaving certificate that there is fairness for children from delivering equality of opportunity in schools, DEIS, areas, disadvantaged areas and across the board. This is something the advisory group on State examinations is looking at in considerable detail. I am sure the Minister, Deputy Foley, is aware of it also.