Foreign Affairs report and funeral comparison
The Taoiseach defended the internal report on the Department of Foreign Affairs event and rejected calls for a further independent investigation or for the Minister to come to the House. The exchange became highly charged over his comparison with Sinn Féin's conduct at a funeral, while other Members pressed for clarity on leaving certificate debates and the fishermen's role in the Russian incident.
First, Deputy Doherty has called on me, I think, to instigate an independent investigation into what happened in the Department of Foreign Affairs when we won our seat on the UN Security Council.
I am satisfied with the investigation that has taken place and I will not be doing that. While I was not in government at the time, I have been very clear since this event was brought to my attention that it was wrong and should not have happened. Those involved have apologised. I am genuinely taken aback by Deputy Doherty's tone and attitude on this matter. He is the deputy leader of a party that invited almost 2,000 members and supporters onto the streets of Belfast and then to a political rally, in essence, in Milltown Cemetery at a time when the ordinary men and women he spoke about-----
Comment on this
The Taoiseach is comparing a funeral to a champagne party. Scandalous.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach will stand over any Fine Gael-----
Comment on this
Sinn Féin had people lining the streets in uniform, while the ordinary men and women Deputy Doherty talked about were distraught because they could not attend the funeral of their loved ones.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach will stand over any crony appointment, or any pay raise or whatever it takes-----
Comment on this
-----but he will not actually do the decent thing.
Comment on this
That comment should be withdrawn.
Comment on this
The point is that everybody with eyes in their head could see what happened. That funeral took place only weeks after the event Deputy Doherty is raising such a huge issue about. To the best of my knowledge-----
Comment on this
Is the Minister coming to the House?
Comment on this
-----the Deputy and his organisation have never admitted that they were wrong in what they did, but they lecture everybody else. There is one law for Sinn Féin and a different law for everybody else when it comes to this.
Comment on this
How long is the Ceann Comhairle going to give him to respond? He has not responded. He is talking about the funeral of somebody who passed away two years ago.
Comment on this
No. The Taoiseach actually took plenty of joy in that.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach does not care that there is a grieving family in the middle of this.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach's attempt to compare a champagne party with the funeral of a friend is disgraceful.
Comment on this
Can we all hold on a minute? I said last week that if this constant interruption continues, I will suspend the House. If Deputies want me to do so, they should continue to interrupt, but I think we will do the courteous thing and hear the Taoiseach out. He has three minutes in which to respond.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach made a very provocative statement, in fairness. It was an outrageous statement. What does the Ceann Comhairle expect us to do?
Comment on this
It seems the only people who can call foul, criticise or say others have created a scandal are those in the Sinn Féin Party. I am telling home truths.
Comment on this
If the Taoiseach wants to go into the muck-----
Comment on this
-----he should expect to be rebuffed.
Comment on this
What went on in respect of the Department of Foreign Affairs event was the wrong thing to do. Those involved are public servants involved have given long service to this State. They have admitted they were wrong and have apologised for one minute's breach of the social guidance. It pales into insignificance by comparison with what Sinn Féin organised. That is the bottom line. That is what I am saying and that is all I have to say about it. I am not revisiting the issue any more. I ask Deputy Doherty not to be so hypocritical in his response.
Comment on this
Can we get an answer to the question?
Comment on this
-----will the Minister come to the House to answer questions? This is the House that keeps the Minister accountable.
Comment on this
We need a specific discussion on this.
Comment on this
-----to answer questions on the leaving certificate. We will talk to the Whip to see if, at some later date this week, a debate can be organised on the leaving certificate. I take Deputy Denis Naughten's point that a debate, where people can bring their different perspectives to the table fully, would be useful and important. I have no issue with that. The Minister will be in the House this evening to answer questions and, I presume, there will be a number of questions on the leaving certificate.
Comment on this
Deputy Michael Collins raised the issue of the work of our fisherman in respect of their diplomacy with the Russian ambassador. I understand that one of the key fishermen involved thanked the Minister, Deputy Coveney, for his intervention. Apparently, they were at one regarding the successful outcome of the representations made by the Minister and our fishermen.