Legacy Bill opposition
Deputy Smith condemned the Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Bill as granting amnesty to perpetrators and shutting down justice avenues. The Taoiseach said the Government believes the Bill is not fit for purpose and has raised concerns repeatedly with the British Prime Minister.
The British Government's Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Bill is an absolutely deplorable piece of legislation. Yesterday, most regrettably, this Bill was passed in the House of Lords and returned to the Commons with amendments. The only suitable amendment to this reprehensible legislation would be to withdraw it in its entirety. This Bill, as proposed, would give murderers and the perpetrators of other heinous crimes the right to give themselves an amnesty for such misdemeanours. That would suit criminals belonging to British state forces and paramilitary organisations. In any democratic society, this should not be acceptable. Our total opposition to this Bill must be outlined repeatedly to the British Prime Minister and his Government. Dealing properly with the legacy of the past is very important. Families who have campaigned with such grace and dignity over decades cannot be abandoned through the implementation of such legislation. I repeat again that the closing-off of access to the inquests, police ombudsman investigations, civil cases and police investigations simply must not happen.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for raising the issue of Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Bill again and for very much keeping it on the agenda of the Government and this House. The Government has consistently said that this Bill is not fit for purpose in its entirety. We remain deeply concerned about the shutting down of all other avenues to truth and justice, including inquests, police investigations, ombudsman investigations, as well as civil cases, as the Deputy outlined. I have raised the issue with Prime Minister Sunak at every available opportunity, as has the Tánaiste with his counterparts. The Government's firm view is that any way forward on legacy must be based on human rights, in particular the European Convention on Human Rights with victims at its centre, and ideally should have the agreement of the five main parties in Northern Ireland.