Israel referral and ICC
Deputy Doherty condemned the Government’s vote against referring Israel to the International Criminal Court over Gaza. The Minister defended the ICC position and contrasted it with the Ukraine referral, but the exchange became a prolonged interruption-filled dispute over the facts until the next questioner was called.
Yesterday, the Minister and his Government shamefully voted against Sinn Féin's motion to refer Israel to the International Criminal Court for the war crimes and crimes against humanity and genocide that we are seeing in Gaza over the past month. This is as the bombs continue to rain down on the people of Gaza. This is as we continue to see infants, babies, dying in hospitals in Gaza as Israel targets schools, hospitals and places of worship.
The Minister may be aware that the President of South Africa, Mr. Cyril Ramaphosa, has announced that his country will refer Israel to the International Criminal Court, ICC, for war crimes in Gaza. We must use every single tool at our disposal to hold Israel to account for its crimes. Last year, the Government rightly joined with those of other countries in referring Russia to the ICC for war crimes. Palestinian lives are just as worthy of our attention as Ukrainian lives. In the pursuit of justice and accountability for the Palestinian people, will the Government change direction now and join with South Africa in referring Israel to the ICC for the war crimes that the Minister has said are difficult to watch on the news and that we see before our eyes every single day?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for raising this issue. The Government's position on this has been consistent and clear. The prosecutor of the ICC, Mr. Karim Khan, has reaffirmed that the investigation that is currently under way covers the current and ongoing conflict, including all events on and from 7 October this year. He is on record as saying that, so that is the position.
In relation to Ukraine, there is a distinction because the situation was fundamentally different. Ireland did refer Russia to the ICC prosecutor because Ukraine was not a party to the ICC statute and the prosecutor could not, therefore, begin an immediate investigation-----
Comment on this
-----without a states party referral.
Comment on this
The inquiry was announced before that.
Comment on this
This is double standards. Absolute double standards.
Comment on this
The position is clear. In the case of Palestine and Israel, the investigation is already under way.
Comment on this
On a point of order, what the Minister has said is not true.
Comment on this
It is not true. A Palestinian life is just as worthy of our attention as a Ukrainian life.
Comment on this
The Minister is misleading the Dáil. With respect-----
Comment on this
-----what he said is not true. The inquiry in Ukraine began before the referral of this State.
Comment on this
It is shameful that the Government will not stand up-----
Comment on this
Deputy Doherty may not like them but they are the facts.
Comment on this
The war crimes are happening before the Minister's eyes. He says he cannot even watch the news. It is war crimes that are happening and the Government will not stand up-----
Comment on this
The Deputy did not even raise the matter on Leaders' Questions. He had the option of raising it during Leaders' Questions but he chose not to.
Comment on this
You chose not to raise it on Leaders' Questions.
Comment on this
The Minister is misleading the House.