Government deal and chamber disorder
Deputy Collins accused the Government of railroading the change through and demanded to know the deal with Deputy Lowry and its cost to taxpayers. The Taoiseach again insisted the proposal was limited and constitutional, while the sitting descended into repeated shouting, with the Ceann Comhairle standing and warning Members to resume their seats.
I thank the Ceann Comhairle. It looks like, no matter what we say here, the Government is going to railroad these changes through. It is very clear to the good, honest and hard-working people of this country that this is what the Taoiseach was going to do anyway. He has to be straight and honest. What is the deal he has done with Deputy Michael Lowry that has him spellbound? We know the deal has cost more than €5 million already with extra super junior Ministers, extra junior Ministers and extra payments for them alone over five years. Is it going to cost the honest and hard-working taxpayer €50 million? Is it going to cost €100 million, €200 million or above?
Comment on this
We need to know. The taxpayer needs to know. The ordinary man and woman who cannot afford to pay weekly bills need to know here and now. They know it is a sleazy deal that taxpayers must pay heavily for. On top of that, the Taoiseach wants them to ask planted questions in this House to make a mockery of the Irish people in Dáil Éireann.
I ask the Taoiseach to come clean on the deal that might yet crumble around him and to pull back from the mockery of the Irish people who are not with him on this one. Will he admit he cut 45 minutes of Taoiseach's Questions? Will he admit he cut the Order of Business time? Will he admit he cut Private Members' business time for our party by 20% on Wednesdays and Thursdays? This Lowry deal has cost us enough financially.
Comment on this
Do not let it cost us our democracy also.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot be serious. He talks about it costing our democracy. Eight minutes on a Tuesday and our democracy is gone.
Comment on this
Is the Taoiseach familiar with democracy?
Comment on this
There is a fundamental issue here-----
Comment on this
The fundamental issue here is the lack of respect for the Chair. The salient ruling-----
Comment on this
The Deputies are making an absolute holy show of themselves. I am loath to say it again but will the Deputy resume his seat?
Comment on this
Sorry, Ceann Comhairle-----
Comment on this
-----I will not resume my seat.
Comment on this
What is at stake here is a fundamental subversion of our rights to hold the Government to account. It is a fundamental question.
Comment on this
They need to convey why they are breaking their word to the Opposition. They told us on the day, on the floor here. You made the commitment it would be an agreement.
Comment on this
Tell us now why you are breaking your word. What did that guy do to you in between?
Comment on this
You said there would be agreement so stand up and say it. You can laugh all you want, Michéal, but it is not funny. It is not funny what you are doing.
Comment on this
You might laugh, Taoiseach, but you are not in the White House now. Get up.
Comment on this
It is shocking what you are doing. It has never, ever happened, the stunt that you are trying to pull here.
Comment on this
This is a disgrace from the Government who are not listening to the Opposition and not listening to their own backbenchers. This is wrong. It is a disgrace.
Comment on this
Answer the question honestly. Give us an honest answer.
Comment on this
You have not answered the question. Not honest, but misleading.
Comment on this
It is an absolute disgrace. You are making a holy show of yourselves for the world to see.
Comment on this
On one hand, you wish the Government to have respect for the Ceann Comhairle's ruling while you yourselves are seemingly incapable-----