Hip dysplasia surgery letters
Deputy McDonald challenged the Taoiseach over hip dysplasia surgery recall letters, saying the Dáil had been misled about whether the letters mentioned recalls and how many had been sent. The Taoiseach insisted he had seen only a generic letter, while exchanges grew heated with repeated calls for clarity and accusations of misleading the House.
I want to return to the issue of the hip dysplasia surgery raised by my colleague, Deputy Cian O'Callaghan. The Taoiseach has misled the Dáil. To set the record straight, the letters were sent to parents on foot of an early recommendation of the audit, and it says so in the letter. This was recommendation No. 4.2.1, to be precise. The recommendation refers specifically to the recall of children. We know with regard to cases between 2021 and 2023 that 561 recalls are in question. The very same letter, word for word, not a general letter or a different context but the same context, the same audit and the same letter, has been sent to families of children who had surgery as far back as 2010. This letter also refers to an early recommendation from the audit. It is the same letter and the same situation.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach needs to be clear on how many of these letters have been sent and how many recalls are envisaged.
Comment on this
I suspect the Taoiseach actually knows that number and is choosing not to share it.
Comment on this
CHI has commissioned the audit. I will say it one more time. I am not endeavouring in any way to cast aspersions on anyone raising questions here. However, aspersions are being laid at the door of the Government.
Comment on this
Attempts have been made and the words "ducking", "dodging" and "diving" were used yesterday by the Deputy.
Comment on this
That is a false assertion by the Deputy. The Government wants the facts and I want the facts. Deputy McDonald has no-----
Comment on this
When the audit is complete. I know what Deputy McDonald is at. Unfortunately, it is quite-----
Comment on this
Jesus Christ, they are implementing the audit recommendations. Do you not know what has been happening for the past eight weeks?
Comment on this
They are implementing the audit recommendations.
Comment on this
Do you not know what is happening? It is disgraceful that you would not do this.