We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna ó Cheannairí - Leaders' Questions

Garvaghy Road march

Summary

McDonald urged the Taoiseach to press the British Secretary of State to stop the march and protect Garvaghy Road residents from sectarian harassment. The Taoiseach cited the pending court decision, criticized McDonald’s approach and rhetoric, and said he opposed marches and parades on the road; the exchange was marked by interruptions.

Mayo for Sam.

Before I proceed, I want to remember the ten people who lost their lives in the Creeslough tragedy four years ago today. I want to express solidarity with their families and friends and the entire community. Four years on, they are still waiting for answers and justice. They deserve just that.

Tar éis 11 lá, tá muintir Gharbhachaidh fós ina seasamh go daingean chun an tsíocháin a chosaint. Ní mór don Rialtas éileamh ar Stát-Rúnaí na Breataine stop a chur leis an máirseáil Oráisteach seo. There have been 11 days of fear, anxiety and sleepless nights on the Garvaghy Road. A dark cloud is hanging over families who fear that 28 years of peace could be torn apart. The British Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, Chris Bryant, has still not intervened. He has allowed this situation to fester. He should have acted on day one, and he must act now. He must use his powers, do his job and bring this crisis to an end. There cannot be an unwanted Orange march down the Garvaghy Road. This issue was resolved 28 years ago and we are not going back to the past.

The residents have made their position crystal-clear, and I stand in support of them. People across Ireland stand shoulder to shoulder with them, as does this Oireachtas. Many people within the Protestant community in the North have spoken out in solidarity. Political figures and others from the United States, Britain and across Europe have added their voice. There has been an outpouring of support that crosses borders, and religious and political traditions, united in defence of dignity and equality. The residents are not standing alone. They should not, however, have to stand vigil for another night to defend their right to live in peace. Their patience must not become an excuse for inaction. Their resilience must not become permission to leave them indefinitely in fear and constantly on guard.

The Taoiseach described the Parades Commission’s decision as "incomprehensible and wrong" and he is correct. I agree with him but condemnation must be followed by action. Last week, at Hillsborough, the British Secretary of State put forward a proposal and then he simply walked away, leaving everyone in limbo. The British Secretary of State now updates his X account more regularly than the residents, whom he has not spoken to since last Thursday. We must remember that it is the residents who live with the consequences. After 11 days of this, the case for direct intervention is now unanswerable. A small minority seeks to drag everyone backwards and undo 28 years of progress. They are damaging community relations, undermining trust and threatening hard-won peace. They cannot dictate the future. Peaceful arrangements on the Garvaghy Road and right across the North must remain secure. No one should be allowed to unravel them. The objective is unequivocal. There must be no Orange march down the Garvaghy Road and an end to the fear that hangs over this community.

When did the Taoiseach last speak to the British Prime Minister and the Secretary of State about this crisis? What concrete action will he take today to secure the British intervention needed to bring this intolerable situation to an end?

Comment on this

I dtús báire, first, I welcome all those from the two schools in Mayo. Congratulations on winning the All-Ireland and Sam Maguire. I wish them an enjoyable tour here this afternoon.

I too want to remember all those who lost their lives at Creeslough. Our thoughts are with the families who have been bereaved.

I also want to remember all those who lost their lives following the horrific attack by Hamas on innocent people on 7 October 2023. We have to acknowledge that it was a horrendous terroristic attack, which we should remember. Many innocent people from all over the world were brutally murdered and violated on that day. That led to horrific consequences subsequently, which we have also condemned.

I am on the record in relation to the Garvaghy Road situation and my views on the Parades Commission’s decision are well-known. My view is that we do have to resolve this through the wider lens of community relations. It is not as simplistic as the Deputy has put forward. I met with her on this issue last week. It is not a simple matter of making a declaration and it all goes away. There is a history of hurt around Drumcree. We know that. It requires a lot of sensitivity from all of us in leadership positions. We want to protect the gains of the peace process for people across the island. We all have to contribute positively to finding a way through what is a very, very difficult situation.

The Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade, Deputy McEntee, met the Northern Secretary of State on the evening before last and she has remained in direct contact with him. The Deputy knows a court case was taken and judgment is awaited in that regard. I remained in contact with the Prime Minister, Andrew Burnham, in the past 48 hours. There had been discussions during the course of past week, in which the Orange Order and the Garvaghy Road Residents’ Coalition participated. Those discussions ended without agreement. I acknowledge that. I still believe that we need a mediated resolution. That is the wider lens through which I am looking at this. There has not been a march down the Garvaghy Road. The current stalemate is not acceptable. I take the Deputy’s point on that.

There will always be challenges to the decisions of a public body. I believe in the Parades Commission, and I always have believed in it going back over the past number of decades. Many parades were resolved, and many happen all over the North and, indeed, the island. The Secretary of State had already announced an independent judge-led review into the decision-making process and organisational governance of the Parades Commission before this determination. I supported that process. The Right Honourable Sir John O’Hara KC will lead this review and we await his findings. That is not insignificant in and of itself. I have been in constant contact with the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade as well.

I do not understand why the Deputy is having a go at the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland in the way she has. If we want to persuade people, we have got to try to work to persuade them. I do not agree with the approach she has taken. We must be conscious that the talks that have happened could result in an outcome if we maintain dialogue and we will see-----

Comment on this

In the complexities of the Irish question and the North, there is one simple reality and we have to have a very clear-cut, unequivocal enunciation of it, which is that the rights of the Garvaghy Road community to live free from sectarian harassment are crystal-clear.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

There is no debating that. We are not mediating that away. We have a responsibility to assert that without equivocation. I am focusing my remarks - and I believe the Taoiseach should focus his attention likewise - on the British Secretary of State for the simple reason that he is the person who can intervene now to call an end to this march and to allow the space for the considerable repair work that will have to be done on the Garvaghy Road, across Portadown and farther afield.

We are now facing into a very dangerous limbo and stalemate. There is a responsibility on the Taoiseach to apply all necessary pressure on the British Prime Minister and the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland to intervene now and to put a stop to what is a dangerous and now lingering limbo situation.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that a further appeal by the residents was heard in the court of appeal and the court has reserved judgment. There is also a responsibility on the Deputy. Some of her actions over the past week were not ones that contributed or would-----

Comment on this

Where were you?

Comment on this

-----contribute to a satisfactory resolution of the issues, not just for now but into the future. I am looking around the corner and I am looking ahead but I am not so sure the Deputy is. She is looking at the here and now for her own electoral reasons. I hate to say that, but that is the conclusion I have come to.

Comment on this

Oh for God's sake, would the Taoiseach ever stop-----

Comment on this

-----and stand up for the nationalists.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt anybody. My commitment to Northern Ireland does not need any lectures from anyone here.

Comment on this

The Taosieach needs to listen to the nationalist people in the North

Comment on this

As Taoiseach, I have been responsible for the largest-scale investment by any Government in the Republic into Northern Ireland and that will continue.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Do the Deputies want to hear the answer?

Comment on this

I want to make a point, if I would be allowed and not have this constant interruption and heckling when Members do not like the message. When Deputy McDonald uses language like there will be a reckonings and so on with the stridency that she did, that has consequences too-----

Comment on this

The Taoiseach should make it clear to the British Government that a march should not be allowed to go down the Garvaghy Road.

Comment on this

Time up. He has nothing to say.

Comment on this

----which could impede a resolution of this, which would mean no marching and no parades down the Garvaghy Road, because nobody wants them.

Comment on this

Absolute rubbish.

Comment on this