Criticism of the budget
Bacik argued the budget offered too little for households, workers and renters, and criticized the lack of public-sector pay engagement and energy-bill measures; she proposed targeted free solar units. The Taoiseach defended the tax-band change and the Government’s retrofit and solar grant schemes.
Yesterday, as it lashed rain, the Ministers for Finance and public expenditure dropped their budget for next year. We might call it a pathetic fallacy that it was pouring rain as the Government's plans were revealed. Indeed, the word "pathetic" is appropriate in many ways because the money the Government says will go back into people's pockets could barely buy a chocolate bar a week in reality. It is a KitKat budget from a TikTok Tánaiste.
Comment on this
Did the Deputy work that one up herself?
Comment on this
Did Deputy Nash write that for Deputy Bacik?
Comment on this
In seeking to please everybody, the Government has ended up pleasing nobody, especially not the Minister for missing culture cards, Patrick O'Donovan.
In seriousness, this underwhelming budget has failed many: the PAYE workers the Government forgot last year; the public sector workers still left without any pay deal; the commuters facing a 15% increase in public transport fares; and renters facing eviction into homelessness. What the Government produced will come as cold comfort to workers like Martina, who contacted me today to ask how the Government could think that €4 a week was helping her, a worker who earned €33,500 per annum and who got up to work. She says that everything has gone up hugely and asks what the likes of her are to do this winter. For people like Martina, the Government has not made it any cheaper to heat her home or to commute to work or school. It has put a pittance on the budget for Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland, SEAI, retrofits and taken only €43 off the €1,500 cost of a home heating oil refill. The freezing of funding for active travel means that in real terms the Government has slashed budgets for walking and cycling measures.
With this week's budget, the Government had a choice. We know that geopolitical circumstances are challenging, particularly thanks to Trump's war on Iran, but Ireland is a country with unique opportunities. We have booming corporation taxes, an abundance of wind off our coasts and a talented, educated population. This means that the Government could have invested to lower bills, decarbonise the economy and improve living standards for all. It could have imposed a windfall tax on the companies and data centres that were profiteering during this energy crisis. It could have invested heavily in renewables and a retrofitting revolution to bring down household bills and curb carbon emissions. It could have provided a targeted energy credit to the half a million households already in arrears on their energy bills. The Labour Party had proposed all of these measures. Instead, struggling households will pay through the nose to heat their homes this winter and they will pay again when the Government's failure to decarbonise leaves them footing the bill for fines levied on us when we miss our climate targets.
Yesterday's budget was pathetic and the Taoiseach owes people an explanation. Why is the Government spending more than €200 million on capital gains tax cuts for the wealthiest when hundreds of thousands are in arrears on energy bills? Why did the Government choose not to impose a windfall tax on the energy corporations and data centres enriching themselves with the misery of people who cannot heat their homes? Why did the Government not introduce targeted energy credits for struggling households, as the Labour Party had asked?
Comment on this
I disagree fundamentally with Deputy Bacik's analysis of the budget. She is hardly blaming us for the rain, is she? It is melodramatic to say that, as it lashed down last evening, we dropped the budget.
The budget is quite substantial. Deputy Bacik knows that one of the significant features of the Irish taxation system, which has been acknowledged by the OECD and others, is that workers tend to go on the highest rate of tax at a relatively low income level. We addressed this in yesterday's budget through moving the band to €46,500. I take it that Deputy Bacik is in favour of that. Will she please articulate whether she is or is not?
In addition to that, we also introduced a tax credit of approximately €250, in terms of two tax credits of €125 each. In terms of public service pay, which Deputy Bacik referenced, we have provided €1.2 billion for 2027. By any objective metric, both of these measures combined form a basis for entering into negotiations on a new public service pay deal. In my view, there is no basis for industrial action or for disrupting people in education, health or anything else when that platform is there as a basis for negotiation on a new pay agreement. We will negotiate in good faith, like we did for the last number of pay agreements. We have also expanded the public service quite significantly over the last five to six years.
One cannot look at the budget in isolation. Over the last five years, we have increased the number of social houses by 59,560. That is a massive change since 2020. In 2025, 9,000 social houses were built. This year, the figure will be over 10,000 and we are budgeting for 11,000. If we look at the ten years to 2020, there has been a sea change in terms of the Government getting back into building social housing, which is taking pressure off private housing. We are also building affordable housing for people. The number of drawdowns by first-time buyers has been significantly higher over the last five years because of our housing interventions. It is unprecedented. That is still a big focus of the Government. This year, €20 billion will be spent on infrastructure through capital allocation because we took a decision last year to focus on infrastructure and to focus on housing and other parts of the economy.
We will deliver five budgets, not just one. People cannot look at any one in isolation. That is the context here. Workers do benefit significantly. If we had not taken the measures that we did, workers would have certainly been much worse off. No one can argue this in terms of disability, with the cost-of-disability payment and other measures. In terms of childcare, we now have a clear pathway to get down to the €200 a month cost of childcare over the next number of budgets.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach keeps saying that this is one of a series of budgets and he keeps asking people to wait, but that is just not good enough for households that are struggling now. The Taoiseach asked about Labour policy. Labour has consistently called for the indexation of tax bands, as the Taoiseach knows, and as we did in our alternative budget this year.
The Taoiseach says that the Government is ready to engage on public sector pay. Why does the Minister, Deputy Chambers, not simply give Kevin Callinan or any union leader a call? Why does the Government not engage to avert industrial action?
The Taoiseach spoke about the Government's interventions on housing, but in this budget, its signature housing intervention will simply add €5,000 to the cost of a house. It is an inflationary measure.
Comment on this
Instead, the Government could have taken radical action and adopted sustainable solutions. For example, in our budget, Labour proposed that the State should bulk buy targeted, free, plug-in solar units to lower bills for those most in need, a practical and tangible measure that had been taken in Germany. That is the sort of intervention that could have helped to lower household bills and meet our climate targets. Instead in this budget, we have seen no ambition, no urgency and no effective action-----
Comment on this
-----either to reduce bills or to curb climate change.
Comment on this
The Deputy is wrong there. The Minister, Darragh O'Brien, has, since last February, made very significant efforts on simplifying the operation of the grant schemes for retrofitting solar and so forth. In fact, because of our efforts over the last four to five years - the previous Minister, Eamon Ryan, did good work here - over 290,000 homes have now been retrofitted. Since the Minister, Darragh O'Brien, simplified and enhanced the grants, there have been 100,000 applications. I agree with Deputy Bacik that the most effective way to permanently reduce the cost of energy is to assist people to retrofit, to insulate and to install solar. With this budget, the Minister will have up to €800 million to spend next year on these measures for households, farmers and businesses. We must keep our focus on that. It is a far better way of getting an outturn in terms of some of the proposals that have been put forward.