We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Ceisteanna ar Sonraíodh Uain Dóibh - Priority Questions ›

Defence Forces

Summary

Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire argued that removing the UN-mandate requirement would weaken the triple lock and called for a referendum, saying people want a say on neutrality. Helen McEntee said the bill would allow Ireland to join a broader range of missions while retaining the option of UN deployments, and maintained that constitutional protections rule out joining a common EU defence.

94. Deputy Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire asked the Minister for Defence her views on the Government's proposal to end the requirement for a UN mandate for the deployment of Irish personnel as part of an international force. [77955/26]

Comment on this

Is léir leis an bplé atá ar siúl i measc an phobail go bhfuil fonn ar dhaoine a gcuid a rá faoin gceist seo. Among the Irish people, in my engagement with them, there is a huge appetite for a referendum on this question. People want their say on this. They had it in the past and they want it again. Regarding the Minister's proposals to get rid of the triple lock, and it is to get rid of it, it is my view that the Government should put it to the people.

Comment on this
Helen McEntee Minister for Defence Fine Gael

I thank the Deputy for the question. We have had an opportunity to set out in detail over the last number of weeks in the Dáil and, indeed, the Seanad the purpose of the Defence (Amendment) Bill. This is to broaden the range of international missions to which Ireland may contribute, where appropriate, in support of international peace and security. Importantly, it is to make sure that we, as a country and as a Government, have the right to make those decisions ourselves. The Government's proposals do not seek to end Ireland's participation in UN-mandated missions, which is something that has been conflated with this matter, nor will they prevent Ireland from continuing to deploy personnel to missions authorised by the United Nations. In fact, they broaden the basis on which to deploy our peacekeepers to UN and other missions.

I want to clarify to the Deputy that the legislation specifically proposes to amend the current reference in legislation from an "International United Nations Force" to the broader term "international force". This reflects the reality that peacekeeping and crisis management operations are conducted in a variety of international frameworks. This includes the United Nations, the European Union and other international organisations. In fact, some of the missions are led by NATO but are still UN-mandated missions. It is, therefore, not accurate to characterise, as many have, these proposals solely as ending a UN-mandate requirement. The objective is to provide Ireland with the flexibility and sole responsibility in making decisions to participate in a wider range of international missions, which importantly will continue to include the UN, where there is a clear legal basis and where such participation is consistent with Ireland's foreign and security policies and in line with our values and international obligations.

We have heard for decades, time and time again, in particular from those who are opposed to the EU, that we are going to EU defence armies, that we are going to send our men and our boys to war, and that we are going to become warmongers. None of this has come true. In fact, we have been always clear. We have participated in UN-mandated missions and we have removed ourselves from UN-mandated missions where they have not aligned with our views, values and propositions, but we want to make sure that that decision is ours and ours alone.

In terms of the overall suggestion around a referendum, that is something I want to come back to because there is something in our Constitution that the Opposition continues to overlook.

Comment on this

There is absolutely nothing whatsoever preventing the Government from putting this to the people.

I was out in Cork over the course of the weekend talking to people. People have lots of different views on this. The vast majority want to protect our neutrality and keep the triple lock but the thing that unites almost everyone is that people want to have their say. That is based on the fact that commitments were given to them in past referendums. Even the Taoiseach, in discussing the Lisbon treaty and how it was that they managed to persuade people the second time around, put it down to concessions that people got in relation to confirmation of neutrality. The triple lock was a central part of those debates. People want to have their say. It should be put to the people.

The Minister says that it is wrong to state that this is getting rid of the requirement for a UN mandate. It plainly is getting rid of the requirement for a UN mandate. That is literally what the legislation does. That is the bit that the Government is taking out of the Defence Acts. I again emphasise that these are Defence Acts and are decided here. If the Minister were so concerned about sovereignty, it is-----

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

Go raibh maith agat, a Theachta. You will have a further opportunity.

Comment on this

What I said clearly was that this did not prevent us from participating in UN-mandated missions-----

Comment on this

No one said it would.

Comment on this

-----which is what the suggestion is.

Comment on this

Not a one said-----

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

There is one speaker, namely, the Minister.

Comment on this

Article 29.4.9, introduced in 2002, sets out that the "State shall not adopt a decision taken by the European Council to establish a common defence pursuant to Article 42 of the Treaty on European Union where that common defence would include the State”, that being, Ireland. That was put into our Constitution in 2002 following the Nice treaty and was upheld again in the Lisbon treaty. What would we be putting into the Constitution? What is it that the Deputy wants to put to people? We have legislation that was enacted after we were very clear that we were a neutral country. Our neutrality is based on our non-military alliance. We have set out already in our Constitution, under Article 29.4.9, that we will not adopt any decision taken by the EU where it aligns with a common defence that would include our State. How can we be any clearer in that regard?

What we are proposing here is that we would put forward a mechanism that would allow us to make our own decisions. Nobody would make any decision as to where we sent our troops and, also importantly, where we kept our troops. It is important to point out that since we had our debate two weeks ago, another UN-mandated mission has lost its mandate. There are now ten, not 11. That is three in the last couple of months.

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

Go raibh maith agat, a Aire. You will have another opportunity. A Theachta.

Comment on this

There are many more situations that could potentially compromise our neutrality than simply that common defence point. In fact, I would say that our neutrality is frequently compromised by our failure to check warplanes that fly through Shannon and over Irish airspace. That is certainly something that the Government should return to. Certainly, it is something that we will return to.

This is another paper tiger. There are so many of these arguments that the Minister throws out that nobody is actually making. I have not heard a single person, left, right, middle, media or Deputy, suggest that we would have to pull out of UN missions because of this. I do not know where that came from. Add that on top of the fact that there is this constant implication that we are prevented from doing things that we are not, such as the rescue of Irish citizens, humanitarian evacuations and investing in our Defence Forces should we deem fit. We should take our security seriously. That is appropriate but that is not prevented by the triple lock. The Government should put it to the people.

Comment on this

The Deputy has not answered, in any response, what I have just set out in Article 29.4.9,-----

Comment on this

The Minister has not-----

Comment on this

-----which clearly sets out that we will not join any defence alignments. If we were to do that, we would have to have a referendum. Unless the Deputy wants to change that himself and actually take that out, that is what he is talking about.

Comment on this

That is not the only-----

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

The Minister has the floor.

Comment on this

The Deputy is saying that I am running away and we are not engaging with the people. I put it to the Deputy that his own colleagues are running away.

For two weeks, Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and Government colleagues have engaged with Deputy Conway-Walsh, who is the Chair of the defence committee, on tabling Committee Stage of the Defence (Amendment) Bill but she has ignored us and has not responded. Potentially we will have a meeting on Thursday of next week to talk about when we might take Committee Stage. There are many ways in which it can be brought through the House.

Comment on this

What deadline are is the Minister working to?

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

There is one speaker and the Minister has the floor.

Comment on this

If the Deputy's party is intent on frustrating this, it is not for a committee Chair to decide what they want to bring forward or not bring forward. There is an agenda and it is up to the committee Chair to respond to committee members. Sinn Féin is clearly trying to frustrate and delay the Bill so that when we try to bring it through the Houses, it will accuse us of rushing.

Comment on this

By discussing it at the next scheduled meeting agreed at the previous meeting.

Comment on this

It is a political tactic. That is all Sinn Féin is trying to do.

Comment on this