Ceisteanna Eile - Other Questions ›
Defence Forces
The Minister said Irish forces have long served in UN and UN-authorised missions with robust, sometimes peace-enforcement mandates, and that using force to protect civilians is distinct from taking sides in a war. She maintained the proposed changes would not alter military neutrality and would allow Ireland to continue such deployments on its own terms.
102. Deputy Catherine Callaghan asked the Minister for Defence whether peace enforcement missions are a new departure for Ireland or whether members of the Defence Forces have historically participated in UN and UN-authorised operations involving robust mandates and the potential use of force to protect civilians, uphold mission mandates or maintain international peace and security. [77449/26]
Comment on this
Can the Minister please confirm if peace enforcement is a new departure for the Irish Defence Forces or if there are some historical examples of missions in which they have been involved that entailed peace enforcement or other robust mandates?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for raising this matter. As the Minister of State, Deputy Thomas Byrne, and I have set out this evening, there is a lot of disinformation and attempts to suggest that what is being proposed in the Defence (Amendment) Bill is new and represents a departure from what we have already been involved in and for which our troops have been trained. That is quite simply not the case. There is a requirement to remove the UN mandate, but that is to ensure that we can continue to operate on these types of missions.
I again thank the Deputy for raising this matter. As I said, since 1990, the majority of overseas deployments by members of the Defence Forces have been peacekeeping - that is, Chapter VI missions - including service with the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon, UNIFIL, the United Nations Disengagement Observer Force, UNDOF, in the Golan Heights and the United Nations Truce Supervision Organization, UNTSO, in the Middle East.
However, Irish personnel have also served on quite a number of UN missions operating under more robust authorisations for the use of force, under what is known as Chapter VII. Examples include the United Nations Mission in Liberia, the United Nations Organization Stabilization Mission in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, the United Nations Multidimensional Integrated Stabilization Mission in Mali, and East Timor. Irish personnel have also served in UN-authorised and underpinned missions such as KFOR in Kosovo, the International Security Assistance Force, ISAF, in Afghanistan and EUFOR Tchad/RCA in Chad, all of which operated under robust international mandates.
I will outline and explain the distinctions between peacekeeping and peace enforcement to the House. In simple terms, peacekeeping involves helping to maintain a peace that already exists. Peacekeepers monitor ceasefires, support political agreements, protect civilians and help create the conditions for long-term stability. Such operations are generally associated with the principles set out under Chapter VI of the United Nations Charter. Peace enforcement involves the use, or threatened use, of force to restore peace and security where violence is ongoing or where parties have not agreed to stop.
I want to highlight that one of the significant developments in UN peace operations over the past two decades has been the increased use of more robust Chapter VII mandates. Of the 11 mandates - I mentioned this earlier - five of the UN mandates, which Deputies in this House are suggesting we should be looking towards-----
Comment on this
-----already have peace enforcement elements to them. It is part of what we do. It is not black and white; there are different elements to peace, security and support.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas leis an Aire. It is very clear that peace enforcement is not, therefore, a new departure for the Defence Forces. It is unfortunate that much of the Opposition's messaging around this debate has left some people genuinely believing that Irish soldiers are going to be sent abroad to fight another country's war. This is not what peace enforcement means and it is important that we have an honest debate about it here in this House.
Our Defence Forces have served with distinction in some of the world's most dangerous conflict zones, where civilians are often caught in the crossfire. It is in those situations that the protection of civilians may sometimes require the use of force against armed aggressors. That does not mean force will automatically be used. It means our personnel have the authority to act when innocent lives are under threat. Would the Minister agree that there is a world of difference between using force in the service of peace to protect innocent civilians and taking sides in somebody else's war?
Comment on this
They are very clearly two different things. We are setting out clearly, through the proposed changes to this legislation, that we are not suggesting - as some in this House are suggesting - that we are going to take sides in any conflict.
I am going to read from an article written by Senator Tom Clonan, who seems to have a lot to say on all of this at the moment. He wrote this and many other articles back in 2003, when he referred specifically to peace enforcement by Irish troops. He said:
Significantly, the Irish – despite being peacekeepers as opposed to peace enforcers – fought a conventional battle in the south Lebanese village of At Tiri in 1980, preventing its ethnic cleansing by an Israeli-backed Lebanese militia under the command of Major Saad Haddad. More recently, Irish men and women participated in robust peace enforcement operations in Somalia in the mid nineties, in East Timor in 1999 and currently in the Finnish-led Battle Group in Kosovo [which we are currently still a part of] and in the UN UNMIL peace enforcement mission in Liberia.
It has been the case, as has been set out by the Senator who now seems to think the complete opposite of this, that we have been part of these types of enforcement to protect civilians and innocent people.
Comment on this
I have no difficulty whatsoever with Members of the Opposition disagreeing with this legislation - that is democracy - but I do have a serious concern about the misinformation and unnecessary fear that has crept into this debate. Parents and grandparents are genuinely worried that their children and grandchildren could be sent to fight somebody else's war. People at home are worried about one simple thing: if the United Nations is not involved in approving a mission, does that mean that Ireland is stepping away from its traditional policy of being militarily neutral? Those concerns are real and people deserve straight answers based on facts, not fear. Can the Minister assure this House and the public that our soldiers will continue to serve under very clear and lawful mandates, regardless of which international organisation is leading any future mission? Could she please confirm to the House that Ireland's traditional policy of being militarily neutral will not change?
Comment on this
To the Deputy's last question, I can confirm and will continue to reaffirm that our position of military neutrality, which is our non-alignment with a military alliance, will continue. I will repeat that Article 29.4.9° sets out that:
The State shall not adopt a decision taken by the European Council to establish a common defence pursuant to Article 42 of the Treaty on European Union where that common defence would include the State.
That is in our Constitution. I am not sure what those who seek a referendum on this want to change because it is very clearly set out there.
Comment on this
An ordinary referendum on the legislation.
Comment on this
If we were to join a military alliance, we would have to change this and we would need a referendum. Unless that is what the Deputies are suggesting, that is not where we are going.
Comment on this
No. An ordinary referendum on the legislation.
Comment on this
The Minister is asking a question. I am telling her.
Comment on this
Second, I want to make this clear. Anybody who serves in our Defence Forces serves in a voluntary capacity in that they choose the path of the Defence Forces. They choose to serve our State and we are indebted to them for the security they provide at home but also the contribution they make overseas. Many of them choose to serve because they want to take part in peacekeeping missions. They want to support those who need our assistance. That is what we are trying to ensure by removing and changing that element of the triple lock, so we can continue to do that but on our own terms.