We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Written answer

Mental Health Services

1878. Deputy Michael Healy-Rae asked the Minister for Health if the State Claims Agency is relying on previous settlement amounts as benchmarks when valuing individual South Kerry CAMHS claims; and the way in which it ensures that this does not unfairly disadvantage claimants with more serious or different injuries. [76349/26]

Comment on this

1879. Deputy Michael Healy-Rae asked the Minister for Health if the Government is satisfied that the scheme is fulfilling its intended purpose of providing fair and compassionate redress to those affected by the south Kerry CAMHS failures. [76355/26]

Comment on this

1880. Deputy Michael Healy-Rae asked the Minister for Health the safeguards that exist to ensure claimants for the south Kerry CAMHS compensation are not placed under pressure to accept inadequate settlements simply because they have waited years for resolution. [76354/26]

Comment on this

1881. Deputy Michael Healy-Rae asked the Minister for Health if the south Kerry CAMHS compensation scheme could provide a meaningful process for individual acknowledgement, explanations and genuine apologies, rather than concentrating almost exclusively on financial settlement. [76353/26]

Comment on this

1882. Deputy Michael Healy-Rae asked the Minister for Health if vocational losses, lost educational opportunities, future psychological treatment and long-term care requirements are being fully and individually assessed where supported by evidence when it comes to the south Kerry CAMHS claims. [76352/26]

Comment on this

1883. Deputy Michael Healy-Rae asked the Minister for Health if there is sufficient independent oversight of the fairness of settlement offers for south Kerry CAMHS, particularly where claimants are psychologically vulnerable or have experienced substantial educational and developmental harm. [76351/26]

Comment on this
Mary Butler Minister of State at the Department of Health Fianna Fáil

I propose to take Questions Nos. 1878, 1879, 1880, 1881, 1882 and 1883 together.

As the Deputy will be aware, the Maskey Report, published in 2022, examined the files of everyone who received care from South Kerry Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS) between 1 July 2016 and 19 April 2021. The review identified that 240 young people did not receive the standard of care they should have from CAMHS.

The HSE issued an apology to the affected young people and their families as determined through the Maskey Report. Importantly, HSE officials and clinicians offered meetings to each of the 240 young people who did not receive the care they should have. During these individual Open Disclosure meetings, the HSE outlined the review findings and sincerely apologised to the young person in question and their family.

Following publication of the Maskey Report, the Government introduced a non-adversarial route for children and their families to seek compensation for the shortfall in care received. This resulted in the development and delivery of the South Kerry CAMHS Compensation Scheme, which is managed by the State Claims Agency on behalf of the HSE.

The scheme operates in a fair, transparent and compassionate manner for those affected and provides for full compensation, in accordance with established principles of compensatory damages, and agreed clinical supports to persons who suffered injury or harm as identified through the Maskey Report and whom have been notified by CAMHS.

There are safeguards and oversight mechanisms built into the scheme to ensure appropriate administration of same. For example, if agreement is not reached between parties at mediation on the level of compensation to be awarded to an applicant, it will be independently assessed by a mediator (Senior Counsel). The mediator’s assessment will be subject to an ultimate right of review in any individual case, by a retired Superior Court Judge. If an applicant is dissatisfied with the decision of the mediator, they are entitled to have that decision reviewed by the Judge and the parties will be bound by their decision.

In addition, if an applicant requires an independent psychiatrist’s report for mediation, they can obtain an independent expert report from any one of a panel of independent expert psychiatrists provided by the scheme. The report of the independent psychiatrist from the panel will be accepted and not be disputed by the State Claims Agency for the purposes of mediation. If an applicant does not wish to avail of a member from the panel of independent experts to provide a report, they may commission a psychiatric report elsewhere.

The scheme has a very high level of uptake. The latest information available to my Department as of July 2026 indicates that there have been 233 applications to the South Kerry CAMHS Compensation Scheme, with initial payments made to 229 of these 233 applicants, following an applications’ verification process. Mediations have also been ongoing, with 150 such instances as of July; 139 concluding in settlement, 6 adjourned and 5 awaiting determination.

The very high level of uptake indicates that those affected consider the scheme to be an appropriate and effective response to the deficits in care identified. As a result, parties have experienced resolution in a less stressful and adversarial manner than the alternative, adversarial court process. The State Claims Agency continues to engage with families in relation to the processes involved in the Compensation Scheme.

I will continue to work closely with the HSE National Child and Youth Mental Health Office to drive reform of CAMHS nationally thus ensuring that this key specialist service which benefits many young people and their families is safe, accessible, child-centered, and delivered to the highest standard.

Comment on this