Written answer
Commemorative Medals
The Minister said the decision not to award medals to some Laois volunteers could not be reviewed: the statutory process has ended, and there is no mechanism to investigate or verify claims to the required standard. Their pension files are publicly available, and the Minister acknowledged their contribution to Irish independence.
185. Deputy Brian Stanley asked the Minister for Defence to review the decision of the Board of Assessors regarding the rewarding of 1916 service medals to Laois volunteers who were on active service during Easter week 1916, under the direction of Padraic Pearse and who were not awarded a service medal. [76940/26]
Comment on this
The 1916 Medal was awarded to persons who were awarded 1916 service under the Military Service Pensions Acts or to those who did not apply for a pension but who satisfied the Minister that they would have been awarded 1916 service if they had applied under the Acts.
The Military Service Certificate under the 1924 Act, which formed the basis for the award of a pension, is also the basis for the award of a 1916 medal. Section 3(6) of the Military Service Pensions Act 1924 provided that the Board of Assessors could at any time re-open their findings at the request of the Minister on the ground that evidence not previously available had subsequently become available.
The power given to the Board of Assessors to reopen findings was removed by the Military Services Pensions Act 1949. Therefore, there is now no statutory provision available to re-open the findings of the Board. The process by which applications and petitions or appeals under the Military Service Pensions Acts were made, investigated and verified was wound up in 1958 and there is no statutory or other mechanism available now by which service can be investigated or verified.
The Deputy refers to a group of Laois volunteers who participated in the relevant Easter Rising events, of whom six received 1916 medals on foot of awards under the relevant Military Service Pensions Acts, while others did not.
While such an outcome may seem inconsistent, it was the result of various statutory processes (including appeals) carried out over the course of more than thirty years from the 1924 Act to the winding up of the various military service pensions related mechanisms in the late 1950s.
The award of 1916 medals was based on assessment of long-established criteria, which my Department must continue to follow, in order to preserve the integrity of the overall 1916 medal process. You will appreciate that, with the passage of time, it is no longer possible to investigate or substantiate claims for posthumous 1916 medals to the required standard now.
Unfortunately, therefore, I am not in a position to review the decision of the Board of Assessors regarding the award of 1916 service medals to those members of the Laois group of volunteers who did not receive them.
The pension files relating to these individuals, including material relating to their claimed activities in Easter Week 1916, are now publicly available on the Military Archives website www.militaryarchives.ie. Therefore, their activities in Easter Week 1916, whilst not reaching the threshold for the award of a 1916 medal, are a matter of public record.
On that basis, I would like to take this opportunity to acknowledge, on behalf of the Government of Ireland, the part played by these individuals in the struggle for Irish independence.