We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Written answer

Vehicle Registration Tax

Summary

The Minister defended calculating VRT on Revenue’s assessment of a vehicle’s Irish open-market selling price, saying this treats similar vehicles consistently and complies with EU law; valuation appeals are available. The tax regime is monitored, with legislative changes made if needed.

533. Deputy Michael Collins asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Finance if he will review the vehicle registration tax regime, in light of concerns that it significantly inflates the cost of second-hand vehicles in Ireland compared with equivalent vehicles available in the UK and elsewhere in Europe, increases motoring costs for families, distorts the used car market, and unfairly taxes imported vehicles on a Revenue-assessed open market selling price rather than the actual purchase price paid. [77215/26]

Comment on this
Simon Harris Tánaiste and Minister for Finance Fine Gael

Under Irish law, vehicles in Ireland are required to be registered, and excise, in the form of Vehicle Registration Tax (VRT), is assessed and payable at the time of registration. The Finance Act 1992 (as amended), sets out the statutory framework for vehicle registration and for VRT.

For passenger cars, the VRT charge is based on the vehicle’s value in Ireland – expressed as it’s ‘open market selling price’ (OMSP) – and on its emissions. This approach to calculating the VRT charge applies to both new and used vehicles when brought into the State. The VRT charge is not affected by the place of origin of a vehicle nor, in the case of a used imported vehicle, on the place of origin where it was previously registered.

Section 133 of the Finance Act 1992 provides that the OMSP of an imported used vehicle is the price, inclusive of all taxes and duties, which, in the opinion of the Commissioners, the vehicle might reasonably be expected to fetch on a first arm’s length sale thereof in the State by retail. When a used car, which has been brought into the State, is presented for registration, Revenue determines its OMSP on a case-by-case basis, having regard to a range of factors, including real-time data from domestic dealer price guides, market advertisements, and the specific vehicle’s age, condition, and mileage.

By basing the VRT charge on an estimation of the vehicle’s value on a first arm’s length sale in the State, the current legislation ensures that similar vehicles are charged similar VRT when they are imported and registered here. The Deputy’s suggestion to instead base VRT on the vehicle’s purchase price abroad would not yield this equitable result. The OMSP approach set out in the legislation prevents market and tax distortion, and it also supports Ireland’s compliance with Article 110 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU), which prohibits Member States from imposing internal taxation on products of other Member States in excess of that imposed on similar domestic products.

The robustness of this statutory framework has been upheld by the Irish courts, which confirmed that the legislative assignment of valuation authority to the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners under the Finance Act 1992 is lawful. Furthermore, the methodology aligns with the jurisprudence of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) regarding the non-discriminatory depreciation of imported used goods.

Where an importer believes that the OMSP determined by Revenue does not fairly reflect the retail value of a specific vehicle, a statutory right of appeal is provided. Under Section 145A of the Finance Act 2001, a person may lodge a first-stage administrative appeal within 30 days of registration, provided the assessed VRT has been paid. If they remain dissatisfied, Section 146 of the Finance Act 2001 permits a further independent appeal to the Tax Appeals Commission.

All the taxes are monitored on an ongoing basis to ensure they are operating as intended, and changes to the legislation are brought forward where needed to improve the effectiveness of a tax.

Comment on this