We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Written answer

Legislative Measures

Summary

The Minister said Ireland’s short-term letting controls are consistent with EU law, provided they are necessary, proportionate, evidence-based and transparently administered.

653. Deputy Seán Kyne asked the Minister for Enterprise, Tourism and Employment his views on whether Section 27C of the new Short Term Letting and Tourism Bill 2026 complies with the EU Court of Justice Smartflats judgment and EU Regulation 2024/1028. [77259/26]

Comment on this
Peter Burke Minister for Enterprise, Tourism and Employment Fine Gael

The recent judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) in the Smartflats case (Case C-813/24), delivered on 22 October 2026, provides important clarity regarding the regulation of short-term tourist accommodation within the European Union.

The Court confirmed that Member States may impose authorisation and planning requirements on short-term letting activity where such measures pursue legitimate public policy objectives, including the protection of housing supply, the preservation of the urban environment, and consumer protection. Significantly, the Court rejected any suggestion that planning controls on tourist accommodation are inherently incompatible with EU law. Instead, it recognised that national, regional and local authorities retain the ability to regulate the sector where justified by objectives of public interest.

At the same time, the Court emphasised that any authorisation or planning regime must comply with the requirements of the EU Services Directive. In particular, restrictions must be necessary, proportionate and evidence-based. The Court also highlighted the importance of transparent procedures, objective criteria, clear decision-making processes, and appropriate rights of appeal for affected operators.

The judgment is noteworthy in the context of ongoing efforts across Europe to address the impact of short-term letting on housing markets and local communities. It confirms that governments may introduce planning and registration frameworks to manage short-term letting activity, provided that such measures are carefully designed and properly justified.

Ireland's approach is consistent with this framework. Ireland has notified the European Commission under the EU Services Directive in respect of the planning measures applicable to short-term letting activity and has set out the policy rationale underpinning those measures. The notification outlines the legitimate public interest objectives being pursued, including addressing housing supply pressures and supporting sustainable community development, and explains why the planning requirements are considered necessary and proportionate to achieving those objectives. The Irish framework reflects a balanced approach, seeking to support a vibrant tourism sector while ensuring that the availability of housing for local residents is protected.

Comment on this