Written answer
Tourist Accommodation
The Minister said short-term letting providers will have to register with Fáilte Ireland and confirm planning compliance. He maintained that the Government’s restrictions—stricter in larger towns and cities, more permissive elsewhere—are justified under the SmartFlats ruling because they pursue legitimate housing and urban-environment objectives and meet EU requirements for necessity and proportionality.
1113. Deputy Michael Cahill asked the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage in view of the European Court of Justice ruling in the SmartFlats case, to support an approach to short term lets that recognises the contribution of self-catering accommodation to tourism, rural communities and local economies (details supplied). [77298/26]
Comment on this
1114. Deputy Michael Cahill asked the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage to ensure restrictions to short term lets are evidence-based, proportionate and compliant with EU law (details supplied). [77297/26]
Comment on this
1116. Deputy Michael Cahill asked the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage to consider the European Court of Justice ruling in the SmartFlats case, and to review his Departments proposed planning restrictions on STLs considering the ruling. [77296/26]
Comment on this
1146. Deputy Seán Kyne asked the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage his opinion of the recent European Court of Justice SmartFlats Ruling (details supplied); and whether it will impact Government plans for regulation of the short term letting sector. [77247/26]
Comment on this
I propose to take Questions Nos. 1113, 1114, 1116 and 1146 together.
In line with the introduction of the Short -term Letting and Tourism Bill, all short-term letting accommodation providers will be required to register with Fáilte Ireland. As part of the registration process, accommodation providers will need to confirm that they are planning compliant.
The Planning Acts provide that the short-term letting of a residential property is a material change of use of the property concerned, thereby requiring planning permission, unless otherwise specifically exempted.
The National Planning Statement on Short-term Letting sets out a threshold-based approach to consenting by planning authorities that generally precludes new planning permissions for short-term lets in larger towns and cities with a population in excess of 20,000 (twenty five at the most recent Census of Population). In all other locations, i.e. outside the largest towns and cities, policy is more amenable to granting short-term letting permission and accommodation providers will be able to avail of an extended period to meet planning compliance requirements.
Furthermore, in line with existing established rights, where it can be proven that a residential property has been operated by a short-term letting accommodation provider for at least seven years and no enforcement action has been taken by the planning authority, planning permission for retention may be sought to regularise an established but unauthorised use.
The National Planning Statement was informed by the work of a Working Group (comprising my Department, the Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment and the County and City Management Association) and engagement with relevant stakeholders.
The recent European Court of Justice ruling concerned the authorisation regime for tourist accommodation, including planning restrictions. The case provided the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) with an opportunity to clarify the extent to which Member States may regulate short-term letting activity under the EU Services Directive (2006/123/EC).
The CJEU confirmed that planning and authorisation requirements for short-term letting may be imposed where they pursue legitimate public policy objectives, including the protection of housing supply and the urban environment. The judgment emphasised that such measures must be necessary, proportionate, transparent and supported by objective justification.
I am satisfied that the Government’s policy approach with regards to short-term letting meets these principles.