We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Written answer

Departmental Policies

Summary

Peacekeeping maintains an existing peace, while peace enforcement may use force to restore peace amid ongoing violence; Irish troops have previously served in both traditional and more robustly mandated missions. Removing the Triple Lock would not establish a policy of peace enforcement: each deployment would still require case-by-case consideration and the necessary Government and, where applicable, Dáil approval.

153. Deputy Rose Conway-Walsh asked the Minister for Defence to clarify the distinction between 'peacekeeping' and 'peace enforcement' for the overseas deployment of Irish Defence Forces troops once the triple lock is removed. [77471/26]

Comment on this
Helen McEntee Minister for Defence Fine Gael

I thank the Deputy for raising this issue, as there has been a considerable degree of misunderstanding regarding the distinction between peacekeeping and peace enforcement, particularly in the context of the proposed reforms to the Triple Lock.

At the outset, I want to be clear that participation in missions operating under more robust mandates is not a new departure for the Defence Forces. Since 1990, the majority of overseas deployments by members of the Defence Forces have been traditional peacekeeping missions, including service with UNIFIL in Lebanon, UNDOF in the Golan Heights and UNTSO in the Middle East.

However, Irish personnel have also served for a considerable number of years in a number of missions operating under Chapter VII of the UN Charter , where the use of force was authorised in certain circumstances. These included missions in Liberia, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Mali and East Timor. Irish personnel have also served in UN-authorised operations such as KFOR in Kosovo, ISAF in Afghanistan and EUFOR Tchad/RCA in Chad.

In simple terms, peacekeeping involves helping to maintain a peace that already exists. Peacekeepers monitor ceasefires, support political agreements, protect civilians and help create the conditions for long-term stability. Traditionally, these operations are associated with Chapter VI of the UN Charter.

Peace enforcement is different. It involves the use, or threatened use, of force to restore peace and security where violence is ongoing or where parties have not agreed to cease hostilities. These missions are generally associated with Chapter VII mandates.

It is important to note that modern peace operations increasingly operate under more robust mandates. Many contemporary UN missions are tasked with protecting civilians, supporting stabilisation and maintaining international peace and security in complex conflict environments.

The proposed reforms to the Triple Lock do not alter these distinctions. They do not create a new category of mission for the Defence Forces, nor do they establish a policy of participation in peace enforcement operations.

Any proposal to deploy Defence Forces personnel overseas, whether to a traditional peacekeeping mission or to an operation operating under a more robust mandate, will continue to be considered on its own merits. Government approval and, where appropriate, Dáil approval will remain required. Consideration will continue to be given to the mandate and legal basis of the mission, military advice, available capabilities, force protection measures, Ireland's international obligations, the principles of the UN Charter, and, where relevant, the advice of the Attorney General.

The reforms are therefore about providing flexibility in where Ireland can contribute overseas, not about changing the nature of the missions in which the Defence Forces may serve.

Comment on this