Written answer
Defence Forces
The Justice Department is responsible for applying the EU requirement that new applicants for Temporary Protection demonstrate compliance with any applicable Ukrainian military obligations; existing beneficiaries who continuously held status by 4 August 2026 are exempt. Defence Forces and Defence Department views were sought on neutrality, and the Minister said the decision does not alter Ireland’s policy.
109. Deputy Paul Lawless asked the Minister for Defence if she has requested an assessment from the Defence Forces or departmental officials on the implications of European Union defence-related mandates concerning foreign military service exemptions for individuals seeking refuge here; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [77479/26]
Comment on this
I welcome the Deputy’s clarification that his question relates to the Council Implementing Decision (EU) 2026/1912 introduction of a new eligibility requirement for Temporary Protection, which provides that, without prejudice to Union law and fundamental rights, Temporary Protection shall only be granted to persons who satisfy their military obligations in Ukraine, upon presenting proof where applicable.
This is a matter solely for the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration in terms of managing requirements for those seeking refuge in Ireland, and I note that Minister O’Callaghan answered a PQ in this regard on 30th September last, where he stated the following:
An extension of Temporary Protection until 04 March 2028 has been agreed by the Council of the European Union. This provides continued certainty for people displaced from Ukraine who are already benefiting from Temporary Protection in Ireland. Existing beneficiaries will continue to have access to the rights associated with Temporary Protection, including access to employment and education, for the duration of the protection.
Council Implementing Decision (EU) 2026/1912 also introduced a new eligibility requirement for Temporary Protection. Article 2 of the Decision provides that, without prejudice to Union law and fundamental rights, Temporary Protection shall only be granted to persons who satisfy their military obligations in Ukraine, upon presenting proof where applicable.
Following a corrigendum published in the Official Journal of the European Union, this requirement applies from 05 August 2026. It does not apply to persons who were already enjoying Temporary Protection in a Member State on or before 04 August 2026 and who have continuously retained that status in that Member State. In Ireland, new applicants for Temporary Protection from 05 August 2026 are therefore required to demonstrate that they were authorised under Ukrainian law to leave the territory of Ukraine.
Applicants are asked to provide appropriate evidence to establish that they satisfy the applicable requirements. Where an applicant is unable to provide sufficient evidence, they may not be eligible for Temporary Protection.
The requirement applies to new applicants irrespective of gender, where military obligations under Ukrainian law are applicable to the individual concerned. It should not be understood as a general requirement that every applicant produce a particular military document. The relevant consideration is whether the applicant satisfies any military obligations applicable to them under Ukrainian law and, where applicable, can provide sufficient evidence of this.
The measure was adopted at EU level as part of the Decision extending Temporary Protection. The Council stated that, while continuing to provide protection to people displaced from Ukraine, account should also be taken of Ukraine’s defence needs and its ability to defend itself against Russia’s war of aggression.
The Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration is implementing the requirements of Council Implementing Decision (EU) 2026/1912. Decisions on individual applications are made having regard to the circumstances and evidence presented in each case.
Minister O’Callaghan added that he does not propose to instruct his Department to cease applying the requirement contained in Article 2 of Council Implementing Decision (EU) 2026/1912.
As this matter is the responsibility of the Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration, Minister O’Callaghan, views on this matter have only been sought from the Defence Forces and from the Department of Defence on any impact it may have on Ireland’s long standing policy of military neutrality, which has always been defined by non-membership of military alliances and the absence of mutual defence commitments. Nothing in this Council Decision alters that position.