Written answer
Departmental Policies
The Minister said the Triple Lock changes require no referendum, would preserve military neutrality and UN principles, and leave deployments subject to elected representatives’ approval.
118. Deputy Matt Carthy asked the Minister for Defence to put their proposals to remove the triple lock neutrality protection before the Irish people via referendum. [77527/26]
Comment on this
There have been a number of calls for a referendum or public plebiscite on the Government’s proposed changes to the Triple Lock, either to enshrine neutrality in the Constitution or to vote directly on the legislative amendments. Many of these calls incorrectly conflate an amendment to legislation, which the Defence Amendment Bill proposes, with an amendment to the Constitution.
The Triple Lock is not a constitutional provision. Ireland was a militarily neutral country before the introduction of the Triple Lock, and it will remain a militarily neutral country after the legislation is passed. Our military neutrality remains grounded in Ireland’s long-standing policy of non-participation in military alliances.
The proposed amendments do not alter this traditional position of military neutrality, despite the repeated and misinformed claims from certain quarters. Any overseas deployment of Defence Forces personnel will continue to be based on the principles of the UN Charter and international law, and will require the approval of Ireland’s democratically elected representatives.
It is important to emphasise most strongly again that the Bill does not remove the United Nations from Ireland's framework for overseas deployments. Nor does it diminish Ireland's longstanding commitment to the United Nations, to UN peacekeeping, or to the principles of the UN Charter. It also does nothing to undermine our constitutional position, which is clear on participation in a common European defence. Article 29.9 explicitly provides that the State shall not adopt a decision taken by the European Council to establish a common defence pursuant to Article 42 of the Treaty on European Union where that common defence would include the State. This was reconfirmed in 2009 following the Lisbon Treaty Referendum.
The Government’s position is that Ireland’s sovereign decisions on participation in peace operations should not be constrained by the geopolitical interests of other states. As an independent state, Ireland should retain the freedom to make the arrangements necessary to protect its sovereignty, security and critical national infrastructure, including its airspace and underwater cables.