Written answer
Departmental Reviews
1410. Deputy Matt Carthy asked the Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration whether his Department has considered the need for a look-back review mechanism in circumstances where a member of the judiciary is subsequently convicted of offences against children or vulnerable persons; and if he will outline any procedures currently in place. [77549/26]
Comment on this
1413. Deputy Matt Carthy asked the Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration whether any formal "look-back" procedures exist to identify potential lessons, failures or missed opportunities for intervention in cases of historical child sexual abuse that do not ultimately proceed to trial; and whether he intends to introduce any such mechanism. [77567/26]
Comment on this
I propose to take Questions Nos. 1410 and 1413 together.
The investigation of allegations of child sexual abuse, and decisions on whether a prosecution is to be brought, are matters for the relevant independent authorities, including An Garda Síochána and the Director of Public Prosecutions.
The Government takes revelations of historical sexual abuse with the utmost seriousness. Formal independent inquiries have been undertaken to examine potential systemic issues in relation to the State’s historical response to historical child sexual abuse cases.
The Government recently established a Commission of Investigation to investigate the handling of historical child sexual abuse in day and boarding schools. Under its terms of reference, the Commission is directed to investigate the handling by schools, and persons and entities responsible for and associated with schools, of concerns of child sexual abuse, and in particular, the identification of failures to treat such concerns in a manner which adequately protected children and the causes of and responsibility of such failures. It is also directed to investigate the handling by An Garda Síochána, the Health Service Executive (or its relevant successor and predecessor organisations) and the Department of Education and Youth of concerns of child sexual abuse reported to them.
The Commission will conduct a survey in which people who have information about historical child sexual abuse in schools, particularly those who wish to share their own experiences, will be invited to answer some initial questions. This is expected to take place in autumn of this year. When the Commission is ready to hear from those who may wish to provide information, I understand that this will be widely advertised. The Commission will be able to receive information from persons who wish to provide evidence relevant to its remit and it will be a matter for the Commission to determine how it will receive and assess information within its terms of reference, including whether particular individual circumstances fall within scope.
Once the Commission formally begins its evidential phase, it will set out publicly the arrangements for engaging with survivors and other witnesses.
In addition, on a case-by-case basis, relevant agencies may review individual cases, policies, or procedures as part of their own functions and responsibilities.
Any proposal to establish a routine formal review mechanism of the type referred to by the Deputy would require careful consideration, having regard to the independent roles of An Garda Síochána and the Director of Public Prosecutions.