We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Written answer

Departmental Inquiries

1667. Deputy Matt Carthy asked the Minister for Children, Disability and Equality whether she will support the establishment of an independent public inquiry into historical child sexual abuse connected to St John Ambulance; including an examination of whether opportunities to investigate allegations and intervene to protect children or hold individuals to account were missed. [77557/26]

Comment on this
Norma Foley Minister for Children, Disability and Equality Fianna Fáil

St John Ambulance Ireland is not a body under the aegis of the Department. It is an independent registered charity, and the Department has no role in the governance or oversight of the organisation. The Department has no contractual relationship with the organisation.

Having said that, like all independent similar organisations, St John Ambulance Ireland is required to abide by relevant statutory legislation i.e. the Children First Act, 2015 in relation to safeguarding and mandated reporting. The Children First Act 2015, provides for a number of key child protection measures, including raising awareness of child abuse and neglect, providing for mandated reporting of child protection concerns and improving child protection arrangements in organisations providing services to children.

The Dr Geoffrey Shannon Report —officially titled the "Independent Review of the Handling of Past Complaints of Abuse in St John Ambulance Ireland", was commissioned by the Board of St. John Ambulance Ireland, in 2021,  to investigate the management of historical child sexual abuse allegations within the organisation and evaluate its ongoing child safeguarding practices. The Review was initially recommended by Tusla and this Department following a number of complaints of historic child sexual abuse against a former volunteer at St. John Ambulance Ireland. Dr. Shannon’s Review was published in March, 2023.

The review had two main purposes:

1. Review the handling of past abuse allegations to assess the adequacy, transparency, and effectiveness of the organisation's responses to complaints by Victim- Survivors, taking into account Government guidelines and St. John Ambulance Ireland policies on child protection at that time.

2. Audit of current child safeguarding standards and the adequacy of arrangements in place at that time for the protection of children and vulnerable adults who may come into membership of St. John Ambulance Ireland.

Beyond examining historical failures, the report aimed to look forward by assessing the reliability and safety of current safeguarding structures within St. John Ambulnace Ireland and provide a roadmap of actionable recommendations to establish robust, independent oversight mechanisms. The Report provided 11 main recommendations for implementation by St. John Ambulance Ireland.

The Department has been clear that all the recommendations in the Shannon report should be complied with as soon as practicable by St. John Ambulance Ireland. However, it is a matter for St. John Ambulance Ireland, as an independent organisation, to implement these recommendations. Tusla has worked with St. John Ambulance Ireland on its Safeguarding Statement on an ongoing basis. SJAI received a letter of compliance on its updated Safeguarding Statement from Tusla in January this year, ensuring it is compliant with Tusla’s safeguarding policies and procedures.

The Department continues to take the issue of child sexual abuse very seriously. The Department previously funded the post of the National Safeguarding Officer, on a once off and finite basis, for a specified 12-month (June 2024 to June 2025) period to ensure that the recommendations of the Shannon report were fully implemented. This was to ensure that there is an extra layer of oversight and governance and to further strengthen the safeguarding regime in the organisation relating to safeguarding and child protection. The appointment of the National Safeguarding Officer was one of the main key recommendations in the Shannon Report.

Officials in the Department, including the Social Work Specialist, met with the Commissioner of St. John Ambulance Ireland and the National Safeguarding Officer to discuss the Service Level Agreement in place between the Department and St. John Ambulance Ireland and the implementation of the Shannon recommendations.

The Department has been advised by St. John Ambulance Ireland that the National Safeguarding Officer has reviewed each of Dr Shannon’s recommendations and is satisfied they are either fully implemented or are being implemented on an ongoing basis. This was advised to the Department by the National Safeguarding Officer in March 2025 and his report to the Department was published on the St. John Ambulance Ireland website.

Some of these recommendations by their very nature are always ongoing with no set end date, as they require ongoing review and adjustment where appropriate, with further editions of policy and procedures developed such as an ongoing review of vetting and safeguarding policy and procedures. It is important to review these on a regular basis from a child protection and welfare perspective.

St. John Ambulance Ireland have to date published four reports on the implementation of these recommendations which can be accessed on their website. Progress on the implementation of each individual recommendation, as provided by St. John Ambulance Ireland, is provided in these reports, and the implementation status of each recommendation is included also.

The Department has been advised by St. John Ambulance Ireland that the National Safeguarding Officer continues to work independently with St. John Ambulance Ireland on all Safeguarding matters throughout the organisation on a contractual basis. The National Safeguarding Officer is also committed to the publication of an Annual Safeguarding Audit Report with the first one published in August 2025 and another one due to be published soon. The National Safeguarding Officer reports to the St. John Ambulance Ireland Board on all Safeguarding matters throughout the organisation, with Safeguarding now a standing item at each Board meeting.

I cannot comment on any Garda investigations into this matter or any decisions made by the Director of Public Prosecutions.

I am satisfied that progress is being made, and mindful of the independent, comprehensive review of these matters undertaken by Dr Shannon published in 2023, I have no plans to establish an additional inquiry.

Comment on this