Written answer
Departmental Contracts
The Minister provided aggregate consultancy spending since 2019 across several school programmes, rather than contract-by-contract dates, prices or details of delays and overruns. Costs included about €27.6 million for the Design & Build programme, €5.2 million for SEN works, €120,308 for PV inspections and €2.4 million for REPowerEU services; further SRRRP detail was withheld because of ongoing litigation.
843. Deputy Dessie Ellis asked the Minister for Education and Youth if she will list the number of contracts, by the date of each contract given to a company (details supplied); the contract price for each contract; if each contract was delivered on time and within budget; if any contract went over the agreed time for the contract to be delivered; if so, the additional length of time over the agreed contract time; and the additional costs that were incurred as a result of going over the agreed length of time. [77622/26]
Comment on this
The consultant referred in your query has been engaged by the Planning & Building Unit (PBU) of my department across several of its capital delivery programme as referenced below. (Note: as your query did not specify timelines, the information provided relates to PBU programmes contracted with the supplier since 2019).
Typically in these contracts the consultant has been appointed as a Project Manager to the delivery programme with responsibility for the overall coordination, reporting and delivery of the programme. Their appointment in addition to PM services also includes, through sub-consultancy services, the provision of design team services. These include Architectural services, Civil & Structural Engineers, Mechanical & Electrical Engineers, Quantity Surveyors, PSDP, Planning Consultants, Landscape Architects and Fire Engineers.
In relation to your queries around timelines, budgets and over-runs, the consultant is not appointed to individual projects, but rather a programme of work. Their scope varies depending on the structure and requirements of each delivery programme. For example; in the Design & Build Programme noted below, the Consultant along with its full team of Technical Advisors (sub-consultants) were appointed to the programme in 2019 and remain engaged in its delivery. This programme was established to provide a fixed number of large-scale, typically new build schools. These projects have been delivered in several tranches (Lots) based on a prioritised need as determined by my department. This is conducted within the available NDP capital budget to advance projects from inception, preliminary design, planning and construction/handover as funding permits.
In the case of the SEN Modular and repurposing programme noted below, the consultant is appointed to a framework for a fixed period of time (up to 4 years) and is required to deliver and report on an unfixed number of projects over that period.
The Consultant had been appointed to the following PBU programmes since 2019:
Design & Build and Employer Led Design Programme
Circa €27.6 million has been spent on Project Management and Technical Design Services provided by the Consultant under the Design & Build and Employer Led Design programme since 2019. This represents circa 2.0% of the spend on the programme. It is noted that this is the total cost for combined PM services (provided by the consultant) and technical advisory design team services (provided by Architectural, Civil & Structural, Mechanical & Electrical, Fire Engineering, Quantity Surveying, PSDP and Landscape Architect) consultancy services included within the consultants contract. It is not possible to separate the KSN element out of the total fee spent from the amount paid to their sub-consultants.
Special Educational Needs (SEN) Reconfiguration and Modular Accommodation Programme
Circa €5.2 million has been spent on Project Management Services and integrated design team services provided by the Consultant under the Special Educational Needs (SEN) Reconfiguration and Modular Accommodation programme since it was set up in 2023. It is noted that this is the total cost for combined PM services (provided by the named Consultant) and technical advisory design team services provided by Architectural, Civil & Structural, Mechanical & Electrical, Quantity Surveying, Fire Engineering, PSDP, and Assigned Certifier consultancy services included within the Consultant’s contract. It is not possible to separate the named Consultant’s element out of the total fee spent from the amount paid to their sub-consultants.
Schools Photovoltaic (PV) Programme
The Consultant while engaged on the Schools Photovoltaic (PV) Programme, are not engaged by the Department to provide project management services in respect of the Schools PV Programme. They are engaged by the Department to undertake technical inspections on completed PV installations, with €120,308 spent to date.
REPowerEU Expanded Schools Decarbonisation Programme
The Consultant while engaged on the REPowerEU Expanded Schools Decarbonisation Programme, are not engaged by the Department to provide project management services. They are however providing multi-disciplinary design team services for four schools on the programme, including Architectural, Civil & Structural, Mechanical & Electrical, Quantity Surveying Consultancy services. To date €2.4m has been spent on services from the Consultant.
Schools Remediation, Retrofit & Refurbishment Programme (SRRRP)
The Consultant has been engaged under a number of distinct programmes under the Schools Remediation, Retrofit and Refurbishment Programme (SRRRP) to provide integrated Project Management and Technical Advisory services in support of the planning, development and delivery of a number of school projects. A proportion of the costs incurred by the Department under the SRRRP relate to matters associated with ongoing litigation between the Department and Western Building Systems (WBS). As these matters are currently before the Courts, it is not possible to provide further detail regarding those costs at this time.
Given the scale of the school building programme, the consultant is supporting the delivery of a range of individual projects. The information provided on each the above programmes provides a summary overview on the information requested.