Post European Council Meeting: Statements
Taoiseach reported progress on EU competitiveness initiatives and presented Ireland’s €1.62 trillion compromise proposal for the 2028–34 budget, aiming to boost competitiveness while protecting CAP and cohesion funding. Leaders reaffirmed support for Ukraine and its EU accession, and called for de-escalation and humanitarian access in the Middle East. Deputies welcomed some Presidency work but raised concerns about CAP funding, calling for stronger EU action on Israel and Russia; several also criticised the EU’s military direction and warned against weakening Irish neutrality. Other contributions highlighted energy costs, workers’ rights, housing, children’s online safety and development aid.
I welcome the students of Nagle Community College to the Gallery. They are led by the school's principal, Nicholas O'Keeffe, and the son of the Chief Whip, Mary Butler, Jack Butler, who teaches there. All of the students are very welcome to Dáil Éireann.
The meeting of the European Council on 15 and 16 October was the first to take place during Ireland's Presidency term. It was a long meeting with a very full agenda, with leaders having discussions on a number of key Presidency policy priorities. The priorities included competitiveness, the next multi-annual financial framework, Ukraine and enlargement. Other items on the agenda included migration, European security and defence and, of course, the Middle East. I will set out the main results of the European Council meeting on competitiveness, the multi-annual financial framework, Ukraine and the Middle East. The Minister of State, Deputy Thomas Byrne, will speak later to the other issues.
Leaders reviewed ongoing work to strengthen the competitiveness of the European economy against the backdrop of increased geopolitical uncertainty. I briefed colleagues on the considerable progress being made by the Irish Presidency on the implementation of the One Europe, One Market roadmap, which is the blueprint for European competitiveness, building on the Draghi and Letta reports. The targets set out in the roadmap were jointly agreed by the European Union’s three institutions, the European Parliament, the Council and the European Commission. As the current holder of the Presidency of the Council, Ireland is doing all we can to meet the goals agreed in the roadmap.
In this context, the European Council had a useful exchange with President Metsola of the European Parliament on the importance of continued constructive engagement by the European Parliament to advance negotiations with the Council on key files in line with the ambitious timelines in the roadmap. I also took the opportunity to highlight specific priority files where an extra political push is required. This includes finding the right balance on the Industrial Accelerator Act, where compromise will be required to reach political agreement this year.
On European Union Inc., our political exchanges at this European Council set the path for the Council negotiating mandate secured by the Irish Presidency on 23 October, with significant progress there. This is a measure that will make a real and practical difference to Europe’s start-up and scale-up potential. It represents a significant milestone for the Irish Presidency, and I thank our hard-working teams in Brussels and Dublin for their efforts in securing this result. As holders of the Presidency, we look forward to early progress in the European Parliament so that we can advance negotiations to conclude the file.
On foot of the leaders’ exchanges, we also secured agreement on an important package of measures to simplify European Union digital regulation. We now have agreement on three of the four omnibus simplification packages we are aiming to conclude this year.
The discussions among leaders also helped advance the European Union’s savings and investment union. The Irish Presidency has reached an important agreement with the European Parliament on measures to revive and simplify the European Union’s securitisation market.
At the ECOFIN Council in October, the member states reached a political agreement on the market integration and supervision package. I pay tribute to the Tánaiste and his team for their hard work in delivering this important agreement. These key elements of the savings and investments union, or the securing a capital markets union, will help to create a truly single market for capital, including stronger financing for fast-growing young firms at the technological frontier.
Our October meeting also included important political exchanges on the review of the emissions trade system, ETS, which will inform the ongoing work towards achieving political agreement on this difficult package at the Environment Council in December.
Energy was a key focus of discussion in the broader competitiveness context and leaders underlined the critical importance of tackling high energy prices. We discussed the impact of the current geopolitical context on global supply chains, energy security and prices, including the effects on citizens, in particular the most vulnerable, industry and the wider economy. We underlined the urgent need for a co-ordinated European response, with targeted and temporary measures that reflect the specific circumstances of member states and safeguard the Single Market. The Commission’s proposal to postpone the methane regulation was welcomed in that regard. Alongside immediate measures to protect households and industry, we reaffirmed that accelerating the transition to clean, homegrown energy is the most effective way to strengthen Europe’s energy security and structurally lower energy prices.
Our discussion on global macroeconomic imbalances at the European Council underlined that China’s economic model is presenting significant challenges for Europe, including de-industrialisation. Leaders welcomed the progress made by Commissioner Šefčovič during the recent European Union-China trade and investment consultations in Beijing, including agreement by China on an approach to significantly moderate exports of hybrid vehicles and on ways to improve market access for European exports. It is important to acknowledge that these agreements reached with China represent the first step towards achieving rebalanced trade between China and the European Union.
In parallel with the ongoing dialogue with China, there was broad support for recent Franco-German proposals that advocated swifter use of existing trade defence tools and the development of new ones to rectify structural imbalances in trade. The importance of unity on this issue cannot be overstated, and we should proceed in a manner that ensures that the European Union remains a strong, innovative economy that is competitive and open to investment, and an advocate for free and fair trade.
At the October European Council, I presented the Irish Presidency’s revised negotiating box on the 2028-2034 multi-annual financial framework, in other words the budget for Europe for the next seven years. This meeting marked a significant milestone and achievement by our Presidency, the delivery of a robust compromise proposal on the future European Union budget. In sharing our rationale and approach, I made clear to European Union leaders that the objective of our revision was to present a modernised and flexible budget that invests in new and emerging priorities on the one hand, while at the same time protecting treaty-based policies such as the Common Agricultural Policy, CAP.
The proposal also reflects the fiscal realities that all member states face. The Irish Presidency proposal reflects an ambitious budget of €1.62 trillion, a 30% increase on the current multi-annual financial framework. Our proposal remains future-oriented, with a strong focus on competitiveness, research and innovation while reflecting a greater focus on security and defence in the context of a more uncertain world. It proposes a package of European competitiveness funds totalling more than €400 billion and the competitiveness heading overall has more than doubled compared with the current multi-annual financial framework.
We have also responded to the calls of a very large number of member states that want to see national envelopes under heading 1, Cohesion and the Common Agricultural Policy, protected as part of that positive, future-focused agenda. These are valued, impactful and proven policies that can continue to support and develop our regions, our rural communities and our farmers into the future. We have also sought to ensure flexibility within national envelopes in how member states allocate this European Union funding.
We have protected support for recovery and reconstruction funds for Ukraine and also humanitarian assistance for the most vulnerable. We approached our task with an open mind and not with any fixed agenda. We also listened to those member states that contribute most to the budget that the previous proposal was simply too large for our current fiscal circumstances. That is not something that can be lightly set aside if we are to reach agreement. That is why we reduced the overall volume by about 8%, or €141 billion, compared with the Commission’s proposal. That should not distract us from the very real increases that are being made when compared with the current MFF.
This Irish proposal is for a budget that is 30% above our current MFF and almost every programme receives an increase in our negotiating box when compared with the current situation. The revision seeks to bridge the differences between member states on volume, long-term spending priorities and how the European Union will generate its revenue.
As is the nature of difficult budget negotiations, our negotiating box was never going to please everyone. However, it has been broadly welcomed by leaders as an important step in the right direction. I am confident that it has advanced discussions further on the path to agreement before the end of the year. I am particularly keen that we get agreement. It now falls to President Costa to take these negotiations forward. The Irish Presidency remains at his service to assist with this complex and challenging task.
Russia’s illegal war in Ukraine is deadlier for civilians today than at any point since the start of the full-scale invasion. By August 2026, more civilians were killed and injured in Ukraine than during the whole of 2025. At the European Council, leaders reaffirmed our steadfast support for Ukraine. President Zelenskyy gave an overview of the situation on the ground in Ukraine. We maintained our call for a ceasefire and for Russia to cease its aggression and engage in meaningful negotiations. We strongly condemned Russia for deliberately targeting Ukraine’s civilian, energy and transport infrastructure, healthcare and education facilities. Despite all peace efforts, Russia has repeatedly shown it is intent on escalating rather than de-escalating the conflict. The Black Sea corridor remains blocked as Russian strikes target commercial shipping and weaponises food and global food security.
Russia is a direct threat to the global security order beyond Ukraine, repeatedly violating member states’ airspace and territorial waters. Ireland is committed to ensuring Ukraine receives the support it needs to resist Russian aggression, to strengthening pressure on Russia through European Union sanctions and to advancing Ukraine’s pathway to European Union membership. The European Union’s robust targeted sanctions in response to Russia’s war of aggression are impacting on the Russian economy, making it harder to access battlefield foods and to pay for war. Leaders also reaffirmed the European Union’s determination to take forward further measures to raise the costs to Russia, including by targeting the shadow fleet and its enablers. Ireland is working to ensure that Ukraine has access to the finance it needs to defend itself against Russia’s aggression.
As a Presidency, we have facilitated the disbursement of the instalments of the European Union’s €90 billion support loan for Ukraine. However, Ukraine still has significant financing needs for 2027, potentially in the region of €70 billion. This is a direct result of Russia’s continuing and escalating aggression. The European Union and its member states will need to rise to this challenge. Leaders will return to this issue at a special meeting of the European Council in late November. As part of the enlargement process, Ireland launched negotiations on clusters 2, 3, and 6 for Ukraine, in addition to the launch of cluster 1 earlier in the year. We are working to achieve the opening of the remaining two clusters and hope that this can achieved before the end of our Presidency.
Moldova is also feeling the impact of Russia’s war of aggression and its threat to the security of the entire region. The people of Moldova are suffering daily from Russia’s hybrid activity. It is therefore important that the European Union also works to advance Moldova’s path towards European Union membership. The European Council leaders welcomed progress made on its accession negotiations, with the opening of four of six negotiating clusters to date. The opening of all clusters is a priority of our Presidency.
The European Council expressed its grave concern about the deterioration in the security situation across the Middle East and the continuing military escalation in the region. We agreed on the importance of all actors avoiding further escalation. Dialogue and diplomacy remain the only viable path forward. Maritime security was a particular focus. Freedom of navigation through the Strait of Hormuz and the Red Sea is vital for global trade and energy security. We also reiterated that Iran must never be allowed to acquire a nuclear weapon. The Council clearly condemned human rights violations in Iran and the European Union must continue to take measures targeting those responsible for these violations. On Yemen, Ireland joined the Council in strongly condemning continued Houthi military escalation, including attacks against Saudi Arabia, including civilian infrastructure, and repeated attacks on civilian shipping.
Leaders discussed the deteriorating situation in Gaza and the West Bank, and again called on Israel to allow immediate, unimpeded access and sustained distribution of humanitarian assistance at scale into and throughout Gaza. We reiterated the European Union’s commitment to the two-state solution. Indeed, a key focus of Ireland’s Presidency of the Council is to reaffirm the European Union’s commitment to a comprehensive, just and lasting peace in the Middle East based on a two-state solution that guarantees the right of both Israeli and Palestinians to self-determination and to live in peace and safety within secure borders.
We are now at the fifth month into Ireland’s Presidency term. The October European Council meeting marked both a significant milestone with the presentation of the Irish negotiating box and a significant opportunity for progressing our other Presidency priorities. I look forward to welcoming my fellow European Union leaders to Dublin next week for an informal meeting of the European Council. This will be preceded by the European Political Community summit the day before, which will be the largest meeting of international leaders ever hosted in Ireland. I look forward to updating the House on these events and future meetings of the European Council, and on the results of the Irish Presidency as we head into the most intense and pivotal phase of our term in office.
Comment on this
In the first instance and before I go into the substance of it, it is important to acknowledge that during the course of the Presidency many members of staff in the Department of foreign affairs spent a considerable amount of time organising it. We must pay tribute to the enormous initiative of those people and acknowledge that.
I will begin with Palestine. I just left a meeting with Francesca Albanese, who met the foreign affairs committee yesterday, informally. She will appear before the European Union affairs committee today. The statement the Taoiseach made acknowledges it, but a great deal more is needed. The situation in Palestine remains profoundly serious both in a humanitarian and political sense. Depressingly, the recent Israeli election shows that while there are differences in policies, ultimately, both the Israeli Government and opposition are dedicated to expanding settlements and undermining the pathway to a sovereign and independent Palestinian state. That needs to remain our position. Clearly it is, but it is the way that the politics of Israel remain focused on undermining that.
There is a great deal more that this State can do. There is more Europe can do. The continued existence of the EU-Israel Association Agreement is a stain on the reputation of the EU. The idea that the human rights clause could not have been invoked, dozens and perhaps hundreds of times in recent years, is absurd. The Irish Government is also at fault. It is appalling that so many licences were given for dual-use items that went on to go directly to the IDF during the height of the genocide. Products produced here in Ireland were effectively going on to assist the genocidal policies of the Israeli Government. It is shameful and wrong. Questions remain as to how that sign-off would have been given.
In relation to the Middle East, I echo what the Taoiseach has said about human rights abuses with Iran. I have never felt that there is any contradiction between condemning an illegal war in Iran and the chaos that is caused in that region. It is very clear that there are human rights violations. There were executions of protestors in recent days. It must go on the record again that it is a repressive and ruthless government. Nonetheless, the war that was encouraged by the Israeli Government and supported by President Trump has caused chaos in the region. There is no disputing that. At the time, I and many others said that ultimately American workers and families would pay the price for the attacks on Iran through the impact on the cost of living. That is clearly seen in the elections yesterday. It has caused chaos throughout the world. It is important to state that we will watch in the coming days the response from the US Administration. I hope that it will not see a further escalation.
I will touch on the issues in Sudan. It is too often neglected, both in these Houses and internationally. It has been a bit longer than a year since the massacre at El Fasher, with some of the worst scenes of violence that we have seen in this century. The numbers who were killed in that slaughter are not yet fully known, even at this stage, but it was certainly over 20,000 and hundreds of thousands of people were displaced. It is the most appalling humanitarian situation in the world. In this area, we have leverage and things we can do. A candidate from the United Arab Emirates is putting themselves forward for Secretary-General of the United Nations.
The Irish Government must rule out support for Lana Nusseibeh. There has to be a price paid for the United Arab Emirates' complicity in the appalling slaughter we have seen. She has been part of the Emirati cover for the ongoing supply of drones, weaponry and other support for the RSF, which is responsible for these slaughters. The Government has the option of stating it will not support that candidacy and it must do so.
I again condemn recent attacks on civilians in Ukraine by Vladimir Putin. It is clear the statements he is making are paying lip service to negotiations and he is not interested at this point in meaningful negotiations. Sanctions need to continue to be part of it. I have raised time and again with the Taoiseach and the Minister the need for Ireland to raise its voice. The Taoiseach referenced the energy situation. Russia continues to have significant influence because of its grasp on energy. Ireland could put forward sanctions in relation to Rosatom, the Russian atomic agency. That is a clear demand of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy. Ireland should be more vocal in supporting that.
Comment on this
Another European Council meeting has taken place that signally fails to grasp the geopolitical realities facing the world. While Iran is rightly criticised for its attacks in the region, the conclusions of the European Council read as though it simply launched spontaneous attacks on its neighbours. Nowhere in the conclusions is the United States or Israel criticised for starting a war that has worsened an already critical cost-of-living crisis in Ireland and across the EU. Why are we so afraid to call out the United States for its warmongering? Why does it have carte blanche to destabilise entire regions, sit back and point the finger at those it attacked? If we are too cowardly to assign blame where it belongs, how can we be surprised when the US and Israel do the same thing over and over? It is cowardly. The Iranian regime is not to be defended but if we are to have a serious conversation about peace in the Middle East, it was US and Israeli warplanes that dropped bombs on 28 February this year. That is why the Strait of Hormuz closed and why a tank of diesel suddenly costs €30 or €40 more. Now that the US Republican Party has been embarrassed in the mid-term elections, the world is holding its breath for Donald Trump's reaction. It is an irrational actor we are dealing with and we are too afraid to call it for what it is.
The conclusions on Gaza similarly fail to grasp the severity of the situation. We are still urging Israel to allow humanitarian aid to reach the Palestinian people unimpeded. It is clear Israel is waiting for winter to kill those Palestinians it could not bomb. Starvation, dirty water and collapsing buildings can kill as readily as a bullet or a bomb. Diseases are rampant, especially those affecting young children, but the European Council is more concerned with Hamas's political future than children who are dying right now. I question the priorities and motives of the Council. I question its humanitarianism. In the West Bank, the Palestinian Authority is criticised for not scheduling elections as settler violence spills out of control. Again, we urge Israel not to continue to steal land in the West Bank and ethnically cleanse its rightful inhabitants. Israel must be held to account; it must be sanctioned. Israel cannot be treated with kid gloves while the crimes against humanity play out before our very eyes.
Comment on this
I was very disheartened to hear the Taoiseach. He hardly mentioned the proposed cuts to CAP. What does this say for the farmers and what they face? Today is a major milestone for the Irish Presidency, said the Minister for agriculture following last week's meeting of the European agricultural council. It is a major milestone all right in that under the Irish Presidency the agricultural council has proposed dismantling CAP as we know it. The IFA is going around lobbying TDs to say this. The proposal involves scrapping the two-pillar structure and folding agricultural funding into wider national and regional partnership plans. Pillar 2 would no longer be protected by a dedicated funding structure, leaving vital rural development and environmental programmes competing for money.
Farmers must be properly rewarded for being good stewards of the land. Environmental protection must go hand in hand with farm profitability and not come at the expense of it or of regional development. What has the Minister of State, Deputy Byrne, done to secure this for Irish farmers? What will he do in the fight for them? We want to hear about it. Is the Commission proposal of a 20% to 25% CAP budget cut still on the table? The Government, Minister of State and Taoiseach should not stand for this. If a cut to our farmers of one quarter, or even one fifth, is coming, this will not work for our farmers. The Government cannot sign off on any European budget which contains a single euro less for our farmers. According to analysis by farming organisations in my constituency of Cavan-Monaghan, these cuts would reduce family farm incomes by €2,100 to €2,300. Our rural communities and family farms cannot be left paying the price for a weakened CAP. We need the Minister of State to stand up. They cannot afford a weak Government advocating for them. Now is the time to fight and I ask the Minister of State to do that.
Comment on this
I appreciate the chance to share a few thoughts I have following the European Council meeting. Primarily, credit is due to the Taoiseach, the Minister of State and the team across government for steering our Presidency of the EU. In a world that feels increasingly turbulent, Ireland is not just sitting at the table making up the numbers. We are helping to set the agenda and that is really important. We come from an island on the western edge of the Continent and it matters that we have our voice heard and can enact change. EU membership has shaped a modern Ireland. It built our economy, opened doors for generations of young people, backed our family farms and gave homegrown businesses the muscle to trade globally, yet we all know the Union cannot rest on past achievements. The playbook that brought us stability over the past 50 years will not automatically guarantee it for the next 50. That is why the focus on competitiveness, energy costs and a working Single Market hits the right note.
Wearing my hat as Fianna Fáil spokesperson on enterprise and the circular economy, I want to talk straight about what competitiveness looks like on the ground. In Brussels, people talk endlessly about directives, frameworks, roadmaps and benchmarks, but drive through Athenry, Tuam, Gort or Loughrea and ask a shopkeeper or engineering firm owner what competitiveness means. It means opening an electricity bill without dread, finding and keeping decent staff and spending Friday evening running your business or with your family instead of drowning in compliance forms and box-ticking. Ultimately, it is about whether the doors stay open on Monday morning. If we want businesses across Europe to thrive, we have to stop tying their hands behind their backs. Progress on initiatives such as the One Europe, One Market roadmap, the EU Inc. model and the savings and investments union is welcome, if it allows Irish firms to scale without hitting an artificial wall or having to flee across the Atlantic for capital.
We need a bonfire of red tape. Every duplicated declaration, unnecessary audit and overlapping rule drains energy from enterprise. Cutting back on administrative friction is not an ideological debate; it is simply common sense. One practical example is the packaging and waste regulations. In Galway East there is a small business called Mishnóc that makes the most beautiful leather goods. As there is no one-stop shop for European waste and packaging regulations, it would have to independently go throughout member states to find a company to deal with it. That administrative burden is massive. The one-stop shop for VAT has worked so well and we need to see that rolled out for the waste regulations. Mishnóc has essentially stopped selling into all the other European districts because of this and it has hampered its ability heading into the Christmas season.
In terms of energy, the Council was right to highlight how war and global instability have wreaked havoc on power prices. Nowhere is the pain felt more acutely than right here.
Energy is not just an abstract line item for businesses; it is something that hits every home, business and department. The energy bill is loud and present. It has to be dealt with systemically. For a manufacturing organisation in Galway, it is the difference between hiring five more people or shelving an expansion. For a family in a rural parish, it dictates what is left in the bank account come the third week of the month or for farmers, it is a crushing overhead eating away at already razor-thin margins. A long-term pivot away from unsustainable fossil fuel imports makes strategic sense but let us be clear - the green transition cannot become a luxury tax on ordinary people. We need renewables, a modern grid and storage capacity but communities will rightly push back against massive infrastructural upheaval if all they see at the end of it is higher standing charges or dearer bills. The public has to feel the dividend in their pockets, plain and simple. The regulations have to be up to date for the technology and scale of the proposals we are dealing with. I raised that with the Minister of State during Topical Issue Matters around wind energy guidelines.
On agriculture, discussions around the post-2027 CAP framework are critical. I grew up on a farm in County Galway. I am a member of Macra na Feirme. I do not need a briefing document to explain to me how vital CAP is to rural communities. It is not a handout. It is an economic bedrock that keeps schools open, local shops trading, adds high-quality food to our tables and ensures there is resilience in our country for our own food supply and in our rural economies. The Government's fright to ring-fence CAP and cohesion funds in the multi-annual budget has my full backing but the money alone will not fix what is broken if the schemes continue to remain an administrative nightmare. Farmers want to be out in the yard and in the sheds. They do not want to be sitting under fluorescent lights trying to decipher bureaucratic jargon or upload endless geotagged photos of progress on the farm. This is not what they wanted to be a part of or what they signed up to. They need to be given their time back so they can do what they do best, which is keep the farm going.
The Council once again confronted brutal international realities. The ongoing devastation in Ukraine is a grim reminder that peace and sovereign borders can never be taken for granted. Europe must stand firm behind Ukraine's right to defend its territory and secure a durable and just peace. Equally, the catastrophe unfolding across Gaza and the West Bank demands unyielding moral clarity. Ireland has always been respected because we call things as they are. We must keep pressing for full compliance with international humanitarian law, unimpeded aid delivery, the release of hostages, an immediate halt to civilian bloodshed and a viable political path to a two-state solution. Pushing for that is what will define who we are.
Next week, when European leaders gather in Dublin for the EPC summit and the informal Council meeting, it will be a proud moment for our diplomatic standing. However, the measure of our Presidency will not be recorded by group photos or standing on the steps of Dublin Castle. It will be judged by whether apprentices across Europe can afford an apartment, a small manufacturer can keep employing more people, delivering more in their own communities and keep trading better. It will matter when a farmer working seven days a week can get a fair wage for the work they do and the next generation feels Ireland and Europe offer them a future worth staying for.
Comment on this
It is time we had a serious and honest discussion about the direction in which the European Union is heading. There is clearly a growing drift towards militarisation and the centralisation of power, a growing democratic deficit and overreach by EU bureaucrats and unelected officials. These are all the things we warned about during the Nice and Lisbon treaty referendums. which Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and the Labour Party told us at the time would not happen. We now see that EU funds are moving away from cohesion funding, CAP and regional development funding towards greater military spending. That is a very worrying signal in respect of the EU's direction. Under the proposals brought forward by Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, Ireland is expected to pay more into an EU budget but get less back on the most important programmes such as CAP. Instead, EU funds will benefit EU arms companies and a militarisation that does not have the support of the Irish people. That runs contrary to Ireland's tradition of military neutrality, a position that has allowed us to pursue an independent foreign policy, stand up for international law and contribute positively to peacekeeping and conflict resolution.
The Government's decision to dismantle the triple lock cannot be viewed in isolation from all of that because it comes alongside deeper involvement in EU military structures and an increasing focus across Europe on rearmament. At a time when the EU is prioritising military expenditure, Ireland should be at the forefront of defending our independent voice, not weakening the safeguards that have protected our neutrality for decades. Sinn Féin and communities all over Ireland will resist any attempt to undermine Ireland's military neutrality. We will ensure the demand for a referendum. If the Government is confident about dismantling the triple lock neutrality protection, then it should be confident enough to put it to the people. We will continue to demand that it does so.
Next week, as Ministers will dine and wine with members of the European Political Community, it now appears likely that our SNAs, nurses and care workers will be on the picket lines once again. They are just asking for a fair wage and for Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael to recognise the financial pressures ordinary workers and families are under. The tone-deaf approach of this Government is galling. It is forcing vital workers to the picket lines but the bankers, developers and vulture funds have never had to strike for sweetheart deals. The head of Dublin Airport did not have to strike for the Government to give him a pay hike of €95,000, nor did the head of Uisce Éireann for approval of a €118,000 annual increase. The head of the ESB did not have to strike for €92,000 extra, neither did Iarnród Éireann's for €75,000 extra nor the head of the National Stud for a €60,000 pay rise. All were gifted by Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael. It is very easy to see whose side this Government is on. The Irish people are clearly on the side of our SNAs, nurses and other public service workers. We will stand if we have to alongside our striking workers next week until the Government sees and realises the real struggles workers and families are living under.
Comment on this
October's EU Council meeting came at the midway point of Ireland's Presidency. In May and June, while dotting the i's and crossing the t's on plans for the Presidency, the Government might have thought of the public sector workers servicing these events and keeping the country running. Instead, it let the public service pay agreement lapse for the first time in decades. After months of delay and insulting low-ball offers, the Government is now set to host a crucial meeting of the European Political Community next week in the midst of yet more strike action, potentially, unless a resolution is reached at the eleventh hour. That failure delay lies squarely at the feet of the Taoiseach and Government Ministers. European leaders may fly here next week only to be greeted by picket lines of workers asking the Government for a fair deal.
The October Council meeting we are here to discuss was a mixed bag. I welcome the Taoiseach's speech in which he emphasised the focus upon Ukraine, ensuring effective sanctions against Russia and the fast-tracking of Ukraine's accession to the EU. In the Labour Party, we very much welcome all of those things but I ask that the Minister of State convey to the Taoiseach our ongoing concerns about the issue of Aughinish Alumina. It is unconscionable that any exports from Ireland would feed Putin's brutal war machine particularly now as we see the people of Ukraine, civilians and children, under an ongoing onslaught from Putin. I ask that the Minister of State bring that issue in particular back to the Taoiseach.
Speaking of effective sanctions, clearly, on the Israel-Palestine issue we need to see more effective sanctions against Israel. The EU is undermining its own mission as a peace project while we still see trade ongoing with Israel. While the eventual passage of the weakened occupied territories Bill was a late but welcome step, the trade Ireland and other EU countries does with illegal settlements is peanuts compared with the value of the EU-Israel Association Agreement. It is a stain on the EU that that agreement remains in place.
Will the Minister of State ask the Taoiseach to update us on whether he took the opportunity at the European Council meeting in October, given that Ireland holds the Presidency, to make a clear case for ending the agreement, for ensuring it should no longer stand, and to work with like-minded countries to build a coalition against the association agreement to ensure that effective EU pressure would be brought to bear on Israel's genocidal regime?
In his speech the Taoiseach also referenced the climate crisis and the climate catastrophe, but in reality it received only lip service in the read-out of the Council meeting. This is an existential crisis. It necessitates urgent action and co-operation across member states. We welcome the Commission's recent proposal for an EU climate resilience law, but we need to do much more to deal with the climate transition and energy crisis double whammy. Will the Minister of State ask the Taoiseach if he ensured discussion of the proposal from the S and D group in the European Parliament for a temporary energy emergency regulatory tool aimed at fast-tracking the rapid roll-out of renewables? As the Labour Party has said many times in this House, renewable energy is not just about climate protection; it is also about energy security and ensuring better cost-of-living measures. We have seen socialist governments in Spain accelerating the roll-out of renewables, bringing down energy costs for struggling households. Will the Government ensure the renewable energy transition is top of the agenda for the remainder of Ireland's Presidency?
Another issue that needs to be prioritised in the Presidency is housing. It was notably absent from the post-meeting read-out. Again, this is a real concern for the Labour Party. It is a pan-European problem. The work of our MEP, Aodhán Ó Ríordáin, through the S and D group, has shown what is possible through EU structures. Aodhán Ó Ríordáin made it clear in his election in 2024 that housing was his number one priority. We saw, thanks to the S and D group, as the Minister of State will know, the establishment of the Parliament's first housing committee last year and the appointment of Dan Jørgensen as housing Commissioner. Young people across the EU are stuck in their childhood bedrooms, locked out of any aspirations to home ownership or even to renting their own home. Next week, the Minister of State and the Taoiseach will be welcoming leaders of every member state to a city with more than 12,000 people in emergency accommodation and homelessness. While clearly Ireland has squandered the opportunity of this Presidency to date to push for EU action on housing, will the Minister of State ask the Taoiseach to ensure investment in social and affordable housing will be at the heart of the next multi-annual financial framework and at EU budgetary level? I am aware the Taoiseach focused on that in his speech.
Before I finish, I will speak briefly about workers' rights. It is concerning, in a country with some of weakest collective bargaining rights in Europe, to see so little emphasis on workers' rights and the use of the EU buzzword "competitiveness" often being used now to suppress the protection of workers' rights. That is a real concern for the Labour Party, the party of European Socialists, of which we are a member, and the S and D group. Will the Minister of State ask the Taoiseach how he is going to stand over the Irish Government's lack of action on workers' rights, particularly when we are likely to see strike action and people on the picket line because of the Government's failure to agree a public sector pay deal next week?
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to contribute following the European Council meeting of 15 and 16 October, particularly as Ireland continues its Presidency of the Council of the European Union. I will focus on three areas today, namely, the future of rural communities and farming, children's online safety and Europe's responsibilities in international development.
I will begin with rural Ireland and the future of CAP. As a TD representing Mayo, I know just how important European investment is to our rural communities. I think of programmes such as LEADER. We have so many projects in Mayo run under LEADER. I think of the South West Mayo Development Company, which recently completed a project, Cabots Cookery School, that has completely reinvigorated a rural area. These projects, which are vital in Mayo and rural communities, are investing directly in communities and allowing local people to identify their own priorities. As our negotiations continue on the next European budget, it is essential that rural development remains a priority.
I particularly welcome the hard work and progress being made by the Minister for agriculture, Deputy Heydon. He secured agreement on the Council's partial negotiating position for the Common Agricultural Policy on 26 October. He is over his brief, is having regular engagements with the Irish Farmers Association, IFA, the Irish Natura and Hill Farmers Association, INHFA, and other interested parties and I know he understands the realities facing Irish farmers on the ground. We know the upcoming changes to CAP are causing huge concerns. We know there is a proposed reduction in expenditure, but I have every confidence that our Minister will fight tirelessly to support the best possible CAP agreement for farmers. This agreement represents important progress recently, but we know that financial negotiations are far from concluded.
I recently met representatives of the IFA in Mayo and I acknowledge the constructive engagement we had and the very real concerns they raised. The figures they presented to me are deeply concerning. According to their analysis, Mayo farmers could face a cumulative loss of €131.1 million over the next CAP period under one proposed payment scenario. This rises to €219.4 million under a lower payment scenario. These potential reductions are highly concerning. The IFA is calling for an increased CAP budget, proper recognition of active farmers, simpler regulations and appropriate transition arrangements. These are concerns that deserve to be heard. I strongly support the Minister's efforts to secure a properly funded CAP that protects farm incomes and the future of rural communities.
Second, on children's online safety, I am chair of the Joint Committee on Children and Equality in the Oireachtas. We recently launched our online safety report with a focus on well-being. In this regard, I welcome the European Council's conclusions on protecting children online. We are looking forward to the EU KIDS Act being examined fully and the proposals concerning a minimum age for social media access being expanded further. We have 45 recommendations in our report and we look forward to them being considered when the EU KIDS Act is transposed into national law.
One of the strongest messages from our work is that responsibility for protecting children cannot simply be placed on parents or schools. Platforms must be designed with children's safety and well-being in mind from the outset. Christmas is coming and people will go to the shops to buy toys. When we go into a shop we can see a stamp on a toy to show that it is safe and we are then happy to give it to our nieces and nephews or our children. Yet, we have our children on platforms that are designed, or look like they are designed, for their age but carry huge risks. Safety by design must be built in from the beginning. With that, considerable importance must be placed on hearing directly from children and young people. At two meetings of our committee, we spoke directly to young people. That is important under Article 12 of United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. The children talked to us about how much they use the online world for learning, communicating and creating. We have to get the balance right between children's right to privacy and right to safety but also their right to connection, creativity and learning. Ireland has an important opportunity during this EU Presidency to advance meaningful European action on age assurance, platform accountability and harmful design features. We must ensure that children's rights, safety and well-being are central to the development of a European digital policy.
Finally, I will address international development and official development assistance. Last week, I travelled to Ethiopia, with two of the Members in the Chamber, on a cross-party visit that focused on maternal and child health and nutrition. It was a very inspiring but deeply sobering visit. Ethiopia is a country with enormous potential, but one facing serious challenges arising from conflict, displacement, food insecurity and climate shocks. Having spent almost two decades working in childhood development, I know the importance of the first 1,000 days of a child's life, from pregnancy to the age of two. Adequate nutrition during this period is fundamental to healthy physical growth and brain development. Supporting children's nutrition is about much more than providing food, however. It requires access to healthcare, clean water, maternal health services and functioning community support systems. What stuck me was the importance of co-ordination between communities, healthcare workers, governments and international partners. While we were there, we saw absolutely amazing work being done in advancing the digital agenda. We visited a neonatal intensive care unit where there were not enough ultrasounds or tracing machines for the babies but it had already transitioned to paperless data and that data was fed back in at the national level. We also heard how data is being used in refugee camps to give real-time data on available stocks, but then, quite starkly, one can visit a primary care centre where a mother may have walked two hours to get some nutrients and which has no clean water or there is a lack of gloves. There was a stark contrast between some of the aims they had and some of the realities on the ground.
This brings me back to the European Council's discussion on the next multi-annual financial framework. The European Union, and Ireland more specifically, have a long-standing development partnership with Ethiopia. That partnership supports longer term development, including in areas like agriculture, renewable energy, healthcare and education.
These investments matter because humanitarian assistance and long-term development must go hand in hand. We cannot expect a child to thrive without access to basic services and we cannot build sustainable development without peace and stability. As Europe negotiates its next seven-year budget, there will understandably be competing demands. We must invest in our own security, our competitiveness, agriculture and rural communities, but I do not believe that investing in Europe's future and investing in the well-being of vulnerable children elsewhere in the world are mutually exclusive. Development co-operation is also an investment in peace, stability and opportunity. I therefore ask the Government how Ireland intends to ensure that poverty reduction, maternal and child nutrition and humanitarian assistance remain priorities for us in these negotiations. How can we strengthen our co-operation between the EU, Irish Aid, UNICEF and other partner organisations to ensure that funding delivers measurable and lasting improvements? I returned from Ethiopia with an even greater appreciation of the importance of this work, and of UNICEF and our embassy on the ground. Ultimately, Europe's success must be measured not only by its economic strength but also by the difference it makes to people's lives both within Europe and beyond.
Comment on this
Yesterday there was an announcement by the Minister for justice, Deputy Jim O'Callaghan, and the Irish Prison Service that they recognise the importance of the old Cork detention barracks, or the old Cork prison, as it is called. People like Thomas Kent were imprisoned, executed and buried there. Terence MacSwiney started his hunger strike there, and many other republicans, not only Cork republicans but also nationalist republicans, were imprisoned there. The Minister has recognised that there is historical value in that building after Cork City Council voted to preserve it and to have it enshrined that it be protected. The Minister, however, has now come out in favour not of totally demolishing the prison but of the majority of it being demolished, with some parts of it being kept because of their historical value. Those parts, however, will be locked behind the new prison walls of the two new prisons being built, so people in Cork or anywhere else who want to visit this site of republican history will be barred by large prison walls and a Government that does not care about our history and our republican heroes but instead only pays lip service to them. I ask the Minister of State to take that to the Minister. To give the Minister of State an idea, at the European Council, Pedro Sánchez might tell him about the regret Spain feels following the demolition of Carabanchel Prison in Madrid, or perhaps the Minister of State's Polish counterparts could fill him in on Pawiak Prison in Warsaw, what that means to Polish people now and how much they regret decisions they made. I ask the Minister of State to take that on board and reach out to his European colleagues and ask them about that.
Another issue I want to raise is the huge issue with Cork city's active travel scheme and the traffic in Cork at the moment. The Government is trying to encourage people to get out of their cars and get the cars off the road, but what we have is a bus service that does not arrive on time, one that is delayed and that does not work. At the same time, we have no light rail, we have cycle lanes that go nowhere and end abruptly, and there is no alternative for people. People therefore have to get in their cars, and now they are being stuck in them for hours. There is absolute gridlock in Cork in the mornings and evenings. What we need is a dependable bus service. Can we look at putting emergency park-and-ride facilities in GAA clubs and other sporting organisations' car parks to get people off the road? We have targets to meet, emission targets in relation to global warming and energy, and at the same time we are driving more and more cars down the road.
I will leave the Minister of State with two things. A man contacted me who had - the Minister of State is kind of shaking his head-----
Comment on this
It is just that this was not raised at the European Council.
Comment on this
Do you know what it means? You are not reaching your targets in relation to emissions, getting cars off the road or global warming. You are driving more and more people into their cars. That creates gridlock, so if you want to know what it means, it is that you are not doing your job here because you are going off to Europe, where you can be the good boy over there, saying, "Oh, we are doing all this."
Comment on this
No. The Minister of State asked me a question and I answered him. I will give this example.
Comment on this
It took a man two hours and 45 minutes to travel from the northside-----
Comment on this
-----to get to Ballincollig for a job interview and he missed the interview by 45 minutes.
Comment on this
You might ask what that has to do with Europe. If you were doing your job, it would have something to do with it.
Comment on this
When European leaders come here on 12 November, they should consider that the US voters have just rejected Trump's agenda of warmongering against Iran and complicity with Israel's genocide against the Palestinian people and the cost that all of that has had for ordinary people in America, who are hammered with the cost of living. When the American people are rejecting Trump's warmongering and complicity with Israel, the European leaders coming to Dublin on Thursday week are embracing that agenda - to discuss the plan of Europe to double arms expenditure and continue its complicity with the Israeli regime while it commits an ongoing genocide against the Palestinian people. That is what the Irish Government is planning to do: trash our triple lock, trash our neutrality and join European leaders who, at the bidding of Donald Trump, want to double the European arms budget from €400 billion to €800 billion and continue trade with the Israeli regime while it massacres Palestinian people, continues the campaign of ethnic cleansing and continues the regime of apartheid. Europe is the biggest trading partner for the Israeli regime, and Ireland is the biggest trading partner in Europe with the Israeli regime that continues that genocide. Then the Government prattles on about a two-state solution, which is a dangerous alibi when the Israeli elections make it clear that there is no political party in the Israeli regime interested in peace or justice for the Palestinian people. They all want to just continue with the genocide and the ethnic cleansing. The Irish Government, however, pretends as if the Israeli regime is a normal one. It does billions' worth of trade with it and it allows Europe to sell weapons to it as it massacres Palestinians. Now the Irish Government wants to extend that logic to hundreds of billions more being spent on weapons and arms while there is no money for workers, who are going out on strike, while there is no money in Spain for housing, and while there is no money for education so that French students have to come out on the streets. Working people are paying for the warmongering and the complicity with genocide. We will protest next Thursday week, marching to the convention centre to say no to war and genocide in Europe.
Comment on this
It is, incredibly, almost five years since Putin invaded Ukraine. The death toll is utterly horrifying, running into the hundreds of thousands of people. However, we cannot close our eyes to the abuses of human rights that are taking place in Ukraine. The Government should not continue to close its eyes. When President Zelenskyy is here in Dublin in a couple of weeks' time, the Minister of State needs to ask him about the policies of internment and forcible conscription into the Ukrainian army that have been rolled out across Ukraine. People are being taken off the streets in unmarked vans to enlistment centres if they cannot produce the right exemption documents in a policy known as busification. Those conscripted have been reported to be injured by the officers enforcing this practice. One man, Andrii Dombrovskyi, who is 26 years old, reported having his leg broken during detainment. This is conscription for the working class, for ordinary people; it is not for the rich because the rich can bribe their way out of conscription. We cannot ignore this. The Minister of State needs to call out the abuses of human rights. The other thing, though, is that the Irish Government needs to not be complicit in these abuses of human rights because right now Ukrainians are suffering under the new temporary protection rules, which require proof of military exemption in order to be able to get temporary protection in the European Union. Ukrainians who do not have it are forced back into a war that they do not support and that they do not want to fight in. The Irish Government is currently complicit by sending back people who have come here seeking refuge, saying they do not want to fight. If they do not have the military exemption documents, they are sent back by the Irish Government to fight.
It flies in the face of the Convention relating to the Status of Refugees, which says that refugees cannot be returned to a country in which they are likely to face a threat to their life. Hungary has opted out of these new rules. The Irish Government should as well. We should also be counting the years Ukrainians have been here under temporary protection towards naturalisation. There is no reason for these people to be denied citizenship while under this protection.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to contribute to these post-European Council statements. I welcome the fact that it is a standing item. It gives us, as TDs, the opportunity to contribute to the debate, albeit after the discussion, in the hope that it sticks in the minds of the Minister of State and other Ministers as they participate in other meetings of the European Council. I also note the event that is going to take place on Thursday week with a very significant presence from European leaders, that is, the meeting of the European Political Community. It is an important opportunity to discuss many of the issues facing the Continent at the moment. None of them are simple. They are complex. It is often forgotten in this country that there are many different views on all of these issues. Countries that are in closer proximity to threats that Ireland is not exposed to may understandably have very different approaches. It is the sovereign decision of the Irish people to participate in a Union that features all of that complexity. In joining the European Union, one of the things we joined was the complexity of the Continent. It has been complex for hundreds of years. It is about trying to navigate those differences and the different agendas different countries have.
Having said that, I would like the most recent meeting of the European Council to have said more with regard to the situation in Gaza. The ceasefire, if it can be called a ceasefire, has provided some breathing room but there has not been enough progress on any side. The Palestinian election has been deferred. The Israeli election has taken place but we do not yet know what the outcome will be. Europe has a role. This House has said that. In calling for a review of the European trade agreement, the Taoiseach has also said it. Europe can do more with regard to the conflict in the Middle East. I would like to have seen some of that in the European Council's statement.
I also want to see more on the implementation of a single market for financial services and financial products. I will go on to talk about the different freedoms we have in the EU in a moment but, alongside the free movement of people, the free movement of goods and capital is a cornerstone of what the European Union actually means. My inability, as a consumer in the European Union, to procure a mortgage, an insurance product or another financial product from any EU member state is a restriction. It is a failure of the European Union as a whole to grasp some of these issues, which I agree are very thorny, to deliver a single market for financial products. I know some steps have been taken with regard to regulatory oversight and so on but this is something that would really give consumers value. I accept that we also want to protect consumers but this would give consumers value. It is an example of how we have to move more. We have been able to do it in many other spaces, such as telecommunications and data roaming across the EU. All of these things have given benefits to consumers. It is important that we get the single market for financial products across the line. I urge the Government to do what it can within the remaining period of the Presidency.
I understand that the EU budget is probably the biggest issue facing the Union. From my observations, it appears that Ireland is not taking the easy answer of just passing it on to the next holder of the Presidency. We are doing our very best to find a solution. I know the Government is respected for its ability to bring different countries together.
Along with some of my colleagues, I recently had the opportunity to travel to Westminster to meet with some of the political parties in the UK. I also had some engagements in Belfast as part of an event at Stormont. There is definitely a change in the debate on Britain's role with the European Union. That is welcome. As somebody who really regretted Britain leaving the EU, it is welcome to see that it wants a greater and deeper connection with the EU. I also note Ursula von der Leyen's offer for Canada to become an associate member. I know that Britain and Canada are in different positions, with one being on the European Continent and one not, meaning that one is eligible for membership and the other not, but we have to be very careful about what European Union membership means, particularly in the context of British politicians considering this matter.
The four freedoms of the EU exist for a very valid reason. The social justice check on the free movement of capital and goods is the free movement of people. If you allow capital and goods to be traded, they will be attracted to different centres around Europe. You have to allow Europe's population to avail of the benefits wherever those benefits arise. I would hate to see any dilution of that social justice check on the free movement of capital. The European Union is not just a financial or economic arrangement. It is an arrangement for the people of Europe and it must be of benefit to them. The Irish Government should protect that free movement within the European Union at all costs. We should not allow others to cherry-pick the benefits of membership, whether they are associate members or have a new relationship with the Union. It is not about being inhospitable or not seeing the benefit of common agreement on things. However, the European Union means something and we should protect that.
That leads on to the matter of the candidate countries. I know there will be moves during our Presidency with regard to Montenegro and other countries. There is sometimes a rush to push for EU membership. In some ways, I am glad that it takes so long to become an EU member country. It should. There should be alignment, constraints and minimum standards to be reached in order to become an EU member. That applies to Ukraine as much as to any other country. The aspiration of EU membership should be there but I caution against having any sort of fast-track mechanism. I do not think anyone would argue that Montenegro has been on a fast track.
Comment on this
If I may make my point without interruption, I would argue that what is valuable about Europe and what is important to it should be criteria for all member countries. As I have said, the aspiration of membership, association with the European Union and sharing our values are all important but, if the European Union is to mean something, we need to protect those freedoms that are so important. We also need to protect the process by which countries become members of the European Union.
Comment on this
We are at a time of great uncertainty across the globe. The actions of the United States are having a devastating impact on our economy. It continues to pursue its policy of endless wars in the Middle East and ordinary workers across Ireland and the EU are forced to pay the price. Where is the strong leadership from the European Commission to stand up to this bully and say that enough is enough? Other world leaders have shown leadership but the EU, along with Ireland, continues to approach the United States with cap in hand.
As I have said, we are in deeply uncertain times. This is a time when we should be increasing supports for domestic producers rather than increasing our outsourcing of food production to third countries that are beyond our control. Food security is fundamental to a strong and secure state. At present, we import 85% of our fruit and vegetables. I was recently at the launch of Talamh Beo's policy proposal for basic income supports for local food producers. This group has shown that we have enormous potential in this area. In the same year in which the Irish taxpayer is spending upwards of €300 million so that the Government can wine and dine EU officials as part of the EU Presidency, our farmers and primary producers are being told that a 24% reduction in the CAP looks likely.
Our farmers are already struggling, and the EU now wants to drive that blade further in.
Farming in Ireland and across the EU can be viewed as just an expense or just another business because unlike other businesses, when a farm ceases or goes under, it is not just layoffs. It is empty shelves and a generational loss of knowledge. I have to question how the European Commission sets its priorities, driving up military spending while stripping the spend on food and agriculture.
The Minister of State should have a look at China, a state three times the size of the EU in almost every respect from population to landmass. It spends far less than the EU on its military budget. Rather than wasting endless money on weapons, China is driving forward investment in food production and food security, and as China has overtaken the EU on almost every front from research and innovation to manufacturing, maybe it is time that the EU stopped following the United States in its blind policy of weaponising and stockpiling and started looking at China's policies in investing in agriculture.
Where has the Government's voice been in advocating for an increased CAP and in stopping the stripping of CAP to boost the military industry? Every €1 of Common Agricultural Policy funding spent in Ireland generates €1.44 of economic output back into the wider rural economy. This money does not just stop at the farm gate. The funds immediately circulate through secondary rural businesses. Unlike some of the Fine Gael members who said here today that they have faith in the Minister for agriculture, and that we will see a better deal, I unfortunately do not have that same faith.
Comment on this
China has 2 million soldiers. Is that what the Deputy is talking about?
Comment on this
The Minister of State should not say anything. He sold us out with the triple lock, so we will not go down that road right now.
The European Council has acknowledged the problem of soaring energy prices and has asked the Commission to examine further measures-----
Comment on this
-----but the reality is that people in Ireland cannot heat their homes, fill their tanks or pay their electricity bill. European statements and reports require real action. The figures tell a very worrying story. According to the CSO, diesel was averaging €2.06 per litre in September. Petrol stood at €1.96 per litre. Diesel prices have increased by 22% in just 12 months, while petrol is up 14%. For somebody filling the standard 60 litre diesel tank, it now costs €123.60. That may not mean much to people living in cities with public transport options but in rural Ireland and places like west Cork, a car is not a luxury. It is a necessity for getting to work, school medical appointments and everyday services.
The Central Statistics Office, CSO, reports that heating oil prices increased by a staggering 58.6% over the past year and the Government's budget threw people €40; my God. Many households have no realistic alternative to oil heating. Older people, families and those on fixed incomes are facing enormous pressure to simply keep their homes warm.
However, the most alarming figure of all is perhaps electricity. Eurostat's latest figures show that Ireland now has the highest household electricity prices in the European Union. Irish households are paying on average 39 cent per KWh which is almost 40% higher than the European average of 28 cent per KWh.
To put that into perspective, a household using 4,200 KWh a year pays roughly €462 more than the average household across Europe. At a time when households are paying some of the highest electricity bills in Europe, the chief executive of the ESB was awarded by the Government - it patted him on the back - with an increase of €91,917 to bring his annual salary to €410,000. It is astonishing. The Government is so out of touch.
People trying to pay their energy bills will find it very difficult to understand that decision, and what is the Government's answer in the budget? It came forward with a very good idea of grants worth €9,000 for solar and batteries. We now find, although the Minister of State has no interest in what I am saying and there is nothing new there, that people in social or council housing will be unable to get that grant. People in community houses will also be unable to get that grant. It is the same as the targeted agriculture modernisation schemes grant for farmers in relation to solar. One hundred will apply, four or five will get it, and the rest will not. However, the Government will put out a glossy story that it is going to be a big give away. This is an outrageous attack on ordinary people in social housing. At a time when families are already struggling with mortgages, rents, insurance and every day living costs, that is simply not acceptable.
These costs are also hitting key sectors of the economy such as our fishing fleet. The Minister of State is out in Europe long enough to bring something home to the fishermen in this country. The Government has walked away from the Rockall situation because it is cowardly. It will take on the real factions out there.
I know of a fisherman - I have already brought it up in the Dáil but it is falling on deaf ears - who paid €22,850 last week to be out fishing for five days. That is not sustainable. That is the end of the fishing industry, and Fianna Fáil stands over that following many decades of turning its back. The Minister of State is out there in Europe, and what has he done? Deputy Timmy Dooley was appointed to a junior Ministry but what has he delivered? It looks like Fine Gael has tied Fianna Fáil's hands on this.
I am also worried about the CAP going forward. It is another serious issue as well.
Comment on this
Incredibly, EU energy costs are way higher than practically every trading block in the world. High energy costs are a self-inflicted wound for the EU. They are a form of self-harm for the EU and are happening for a number of reasons.
First, energy is overtaxed. We are talking about a staple that people need and yet if a person goes into a petrol station today and spends €100 to fill their car, €45 of that will go into Government taxation. The Government took in €4.3 billion from taxes on fuel last year. Some €1.1 billion was on carbon tax. These are the highest figures in the history of the State and came in the jaws of a cost-of-living crisis.
The other element, and this is seldom said, is that this is not just bad for households and families but it is bad for the economy, business and enterprise. Another aspect that is really frustrating and has been mentioned since the start of the Ukraine war is the way the European Union charges for electricity. It charges on the basis of marginal pricing. The last unit of electricity is based on the last unit of production, which is gas. We have been listening to Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael talking for nearly four years now about how that needs to be decoupled at some stage but, of course, we ceded that to the EU, so we can do nothing about it, and this is the Minister of State who wants us to cede our military objectives to the EU as well in terms of a defence union.
It is really important that we keep power and control over issues such as energy costs in this country. It is important that we get a devolution of power back from Brussels to Ireland on these issues as well.
Comment on this
We now have 20 minutes for questions and answers. There will be one minute for each.
Comment on this
One of the largest issues I raised was in relation to Sudan and there were statements on that at previous European Council meetings. I put it to the Taoiseach that the Government should make a statement that it will not support Lana Nusseibeh, the candidate for the UN Secretary General. A statement needs to be made to the Emirates that Ireland and the world rejects its facilitation, support and complicity in the genocidal actions of the Rapid Support Forces, RSF, particularly in El Fasher but throughout this war.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach raises Sudan at every Council meeting. It has been in the conclusions in the past and is regularly on the agenda for the Foreign Affairs Council as well. The EU is very much focused on that crisis. It is more than a crisis really. We are talking about millions of people affected by it. It is one of the gravest humanitarian crises the world has ever seen. This is something the Taoiseach keeps coming back to.
Regarding the next Secretary General of the UN, that is a matter for the Taoiseach and Government. As the Minister of State for European affairs, I cannot speak to that.
Comment on this
As I was saying earlier on, people in the United States have rejected Trump's warmongering against Iran, his complicity with Israel for its genocide and the cost that it has had for ordinary working people in America in terms of the cost of living. I put it to the Minister of State that European leaders should be rejecting that agenda but instead they are embracing Trump's agenda with the plan to double arms and military expenditure across Europe. It is also continuing to trade with Israel despite the fact it is committing genocide against the Palestinian people, as well as continuing to allow the flow of arms to Israel and treating it as if it is a normal state. Ireland is also guilty of that. It is Israel's biggest trading partner in Europe and is ramping up military spending while working people are being forced to go out on strike because the Government will not give them a decent pay increase.
Should the Government not learn something from what is happening in the United States and the fact that ordinary people in the United States are turning against this agenda of warmongering, complicity with Israel and the cost that has on ordinary working people?
Comment on this
There is no warmongering by the European Union. It is an institution of peace. There is no warmongering by the Irish Government. We do not have a sufficient military. We want to spend more on our own military. Within the EU, decisions on military spending are matters for the member states themselves. Why are some member states deciding to massively increase their military spending? It is because of the huge threat they face from Russia, a threat the Deputy continually underplays. Today his colleague wanted us to investigate Ukraine. That is what we were asked to do on the floor of this Chamber today, to investigate Ukraine.
Comment on this
We are asking not to send Ukrainians back to fight in a war they do not want to fight in.
Comment on this
No, the Deputy's colleague wanted an investigation and for us to tackle Zelenskyy about the allegations that were made here on the floor of the Dáil. This is at a time when Russia is blowing missiles into civilian populations in Kyiv and around Ukraine, and when we see all sorts of what is called hybrid activity, although some of it is very much kinetic activity, happening on the boundaries of the European Union and within European Union member states. We saw a cyberattack across the European Union just the other day.
When we talk about military spending, some countries are rearming for sure because they want to make sure nobody can get past them and particularly Russia, but we are also talking about increases in spending on cybersecurity, protecting ourselves from these types of threats and making sure we have full vision of what is happening on our seas. That is what is happening at the moment. The European Union is not a defence alliance.
Comment on this
NATO is a defence alliance. We are not part of NATO and are not joining NATO.
Comment on this
We are aligned.
Comment on this
We would not even be able to reach the spending targets NATO members are required to meet.
Comment on this
Why are commanders coming to Ireland regularly?
Comment on this
It will not arise on our side or on their side. There is no ramping-up of military spending. What we are trying to do in Ireland is ensure we have a military that can protect this country.
On trade and relations with Israel, foreign policy is a matter for unanimity at the Council table. Every time there is a referendum, we have a discussion about the veto, the Lisbon treaty and the Nice treaty. The Deputy will have been very strong about protecting the veto. That is the veto in action. If you cannot get every single member state to agree, you cannot implement something at a European Union level from a foreign policy point of view or a sanctions point of view. That is simply the reality. The veto and unanimity is something every member state holds dear. As regards this country's trade with Israel, we have brought in the occupied territories Bill - that is in - but the Deputy is looking for full trade sanctions on Israel and a complete end to trade.
Comment on this
The Deputy has to tell the workers in Ireland who would lose their jobs because of that what the consequences would be for them. I do not know the details but I read in the newspaper about Intel employing thousands of people and it actually seems to be, according to newspaper reports, the main source of trade with Israel because of the supply chains that are there. If the Deputy wants to go down to the factory and tell people what the consequences of his proposal would be, then he should do that. However, the Government has to make decisions that are not just in the interest of good foreign policy, which is what we always try to do, but are also in the interests of the Irish people.
Comment on this
Obviously, I condemn the Russian war against Ukraine. It is an horrendous loss of life and limb. It is a meat grinder of a war, unfortunately and shockingly, at the moment. Both Ukrainian and Russian soldiers are losing their lives in horrendous numbers. The truth is that peace will come through a negotiated peace at some stage. The Government is now the President of the Council of the European Union. Has it made any efforts to create a negotiated peace between Russia and Ukraine? Has it spoken to the Russian ambassador? Has it reached out to Putin's Government? Has it asked Zelenskyy whether there is any way, as holding the Presidency of the European Union and in that role, in which talks could be facilitated towards developing a peace process? I would say "No". I do not think this Government has done that. I do not think it has lifted the phone to anybody on that.
I will explain why. The EU does want peace, but it wants peace on its own terms in relation to this. It does not want a peace to happen immediately. It wants to make sure Russia is well defeated in terms of this war. My worry is that this particular policy of the European Union is actually prolonging the war in Russia and Ukraine. What steps has the Government taken - any steps - to see if it can form negotiations between Russia and Ukraine?
Comment on this
It is not a case of peace on the EU's terms; it is peace on Ukraine's terms. It has been invaded and its sovereignty has been attacked. Its territory has been taken by Russia, completely in breach of the principles of the UN we hear about all of the time in the Chamber. There have been offers of peace talks. Zelenskyy has offered to talk peace with Putin, but Putin has constantly refused to talk peace. The Deputy is shaking his head at that.
Comment on this
This is one thing that lost out in America, by the way, the whole pro-Russia thing. The far left and the far right are identical on Russia. They are absolutely identical. They are always asking, did you not ring the Russian ambassador? It is a crazy question. As if he has any power in the Russian system.
Comment on this
The Government has the Presidency of the European Union.
Comment on this
From the far left, we have heard Ukraine should be investigated. From the far right, we have heard we had better ring the Russian ambassador.
Comment on this
"Far right" is rubbish. Will the Minister of State stop calling people names? It is stupid.
Comment on this
We want peace on Ukraine's terms. Look at what is happening there today. Missiles and drones, probably as we speak, are being sent into civilian buildings by the Russians.
Comment on this
Has the Government picked up the phone?
Comment on this
The Russians need to stop doing that, and that message is clear and consistent from the Taoiseach-----
Comment on this
-----the President of the European Council, the President of the Commission and the high representative for foreign policy.
Comment on this
In recent weeks, we have seen talks talking place between the Finnish President, the Norwegian Prime Minister and Putin. They have debriefed their colleagues on that, but there is absolutely no evidence that Putin wants to end this war. He should and he must. The principles of the UN Charter dictate that he should.
Comment on this
In his opening statement, the Taoiseach talked about a long meeting and full agenda. The priorities included competitiveness and the next multi-annual financial framework, MFF. There was scant detail about the negotiations around the MFF, but we know development aid and development partnerships are on the chopping block. One of my colleagues talked about how we have just returned from Ethiopia as part of a cross-party visit organised by UNICEF Ireland, where we saw with our own eyes the positive impact of this aid and the dire consequences should it be withdrawn, like USAID under President Trump. I have seen hunger and poverty in Ireland but not on the same scale or to the same extreme. Will the Minister of State outline what the Government's position was on maintaining the development budget as it is? Will we fight for this life-saving, life-changing assistance?
The Taoiseach talked about the proposals for the increase in the budget and so on, but this area of funding looks as though it may be cut. When we talked to a lot of the groups within Ethiopia, the big concern was who will replace USAID, but more important, what the response of Europe will be to that.
Comment on this
I will set out the national position first because it is very important to say this. It is accepted around the world. We are one of the few countries that are not cutting development aid. In fact, we are one of the few that are increasing it in our national budgets. It is important to say that. In that sense, I agree with the Deputy.
On the MFF, I can talk all day about that because I had the privilege of chairing the negotiations at my level before they went to the leaders. We were the honest broker and we had to get a negotiated agreement. It is not misinformation. We have set out the figures and it is extremely complex.
Specifically on Global Europe, which incorporates foreign aid, the negotiations are still under way and I say that to our colleagues in agriculture as well. Under Global Europe, the current figure in the current multi-annual financial framework, what we are spending at the moment over the seven-year period, is €120 billion. Under our negotiating box, it goes up to €178 billion. While that is not as high as the €215 billion figure the Commission wanted, at current prices it is still a 48% increase on what we are spending at the moment. That message is very difficult to get across because there is a range of figures and they all relate to different things in the negotiating box. Even some experts are picking the wrong figure to compare things. We should compare what we are spending already and what we are proposing, and that is a 48% increase under current prices. On what the Commission proposed, yes, we have reduced the €215 billion figure, under current prices, which the Commission looked for, but we will still be spending a lot more than what we are spending at the moment.
These negotiations have a way to go. I cannot guarantee that figure will stay; it is up to the leaders.
We have protected agriculture and the Common Agricultural Policy. I had a very good meeting with the IFA and I know the Taoiseach has also discussed things with the president of the IFA. The negotiations are not finished and I have to be very careful about that. Why do we protect the Common Agricultural Policy? It is because all the member states, with the exception of a small number, want to. Even some of the contributor countries want to protect the Common Agricultural Policy. Within the national and regional partnership plans, there are other funds where flexibilities have been introduced that could potentially help the agriculture situation and make up some of the difference between the last MFF and this MFF. A lot of that remains to be worked out, but I am confident we will reach a situation where the Common Agricultural Policy will be protected and I will certainly apprise the IFA of that position. I am happy to meet Sinn Féin TDs who have talked about 20% cuts to CAP. I am more than happy to meet and talk with them about that.
Comment on this
Let us be clear: Putin is a warmonger, authoritarian and imperialist. However, so are many of the powers in the European Union whose leaders will be here next week and who the Minister of State will be meeting with. Many of the European leaders' hands are dripping with the blood of dead Palestinians massacred by Israel, courtesy of the trade, arms, funding, political support and impunity given to it by the European Union. The EU is every bit as culpable and guilty as Vladimir Putin but the Government does not say that. In fact, it welcomes the EU with open arms and embraces its agenda to rearm Europe. It has renamed it so that it is entitled ReArm Europe. That is the agenda.
The reference made by Deputy Paul Murphy was to the fact that if refuge means anything, it means the right of people not to fight in a war they do not want to die in. As of August, Ukrainians coming here will not get temporary refuge if they do not have their military exemption from the Zelenskyy government, which is currently rounding up people and insisting they fight even if they do not want to. That is conscription. Part of why there was an Irish revolution was because people were against conscription in the First World War. We are now enforcing conscription against young Ukrainians who do not want to fight in a slaughter. The Government is assisting in that and if it does that to Ukrainians, it will probably do it to Irish people in the future.
Comment on this
Thankfully, our ancestors battled against the conscription of 1918, which was conscription on behalf of a different country and an oppressor. It is a wrong comparison.
Comment on this
And you are joining in with the imperialist war effort.
Comment on this
It is also gravely wrong to compare EU leaders, who are our friends, neighbours and in some cases almost our cousins, to Putin. That is wrong.
Comment on this
You are assisting a genocide.
Comment on this
It is wrong that they are assisting a genocide.
Comment on this
It is also wrong of the Opposition to describe this meeting as wining and dining our leaders. When you bring your neighbours and friends to your home, you put on a good show. You tidy things up, you invite them in, you have a conversation and you put the best food and wine that you have out. That is common courtesy; it is normal practice. I am certainly looking forward to this meeting next week, which will bring together almost 50 countries of the world. Almost all of the democratic world will be in Ireland. They are our friends, our allies and most of them share the same values as us.
Comment on this
They are arming a genocide.
Comment on this
It is wrong to compare them to Putin. It is crazy to do so.
Comment on this
They are arming a genocide.
Comment on this
Aontú is stronger on workers' rights, the cost-of-living crisis, public services, tax justice, Gaza and Irish unity than anything in Fianna Fáil. Fianna Fáil is closer to Trump on all these issues than Aontú. Calling people names, no matter what side of the political divide they are on, shows an intellectual deficiency on the Minister of State's side of the debate.
Albert Reynolds and Charlie Haughey reached out to the IRA in the eighties and early nineties for the purpose of trying to create peace negotiations. Many within the political establishment here landed on them and on John Hume like a tonne of bricks. They said there was no way republicans had any interest in peace whatsoever, but they did so anyway. They took a chance, tested the republican movement in the effort of peace and the peace we enjoy today is a result of those individuals taking that chance and making that effort.
However, here is the Minister of State today, in the dying days of the European Presidency, admitting that his Government has made absolutely no effort whatsoever to see if we could create peace negotiations between Russia and Ukraine. That is a disgrace.
Comment on this
Deputy Tóibín, I will allow the Minister of State to come in very quickly, and then Deputy Ó Laoghaire.
Comment on this
If I heard the Deputy right, he suggested we are fast-tracking the EU application for Ukraine, which he seemed to be critical of, but we are not fast-tracking it. He also suggested we call the Russian ambassador. We are not going to do either of those things and we do not land on people like a tonne of bricks. We supported the efforts of the USA to try to get peace. We supported conversations that President Stubb had with the Norwegian Prime Minister and Putin. We support any lines of communication that would be open-----
Comment on this
-----but Putin has to stop this war. There is an invasion going on, so it has to be stopped. That has to happen.
Comment on this
I will not just talk about Russia. The contribution from Sinn Féin today about how we should be emulating China was one of the strangest statements I have heard in this House in some time. Deputies were favourably talking about China's military and agricultural policy. If that is the Sinn Féin policy now, I think it should explain that to the people. If it is talking about neutrality on the one hand and then telling us how great China's military spending is - 2% of its GDP is on two million soldiers - something very strange is going on in Sinn Féin.
Comment on this
I think that is probably one of the milder examples of putting words into people's mouths in the past 40 minutes. The Minister of State knows himself that it was scutter, but we will move on from that.
I recall the Minister of State in the media about a week and half ago talking about bringing debate in these Chambers to a new depth. It was about two days later that his Taoiseach accused the Opposition variously of being Nazi sympathisers, in the pocket of Putin and acolytes of Trump. The Minister of State will forgive the Opposition for taking his appeals for high-minded debate with a grain of salt.
Comment on this
Deputy, we want to hear the Minister of State reply, instead of storytelling. We want questions.
Comment on this
Deputy Boyd Barrett is right. There is profound complicity on the part of the EU in relation to what is going on in Israel. Can I get an update on the EU-Israel trade agreement and the need for that to be suspended? That human rights clause has been broken dozens upon dozens of times.
Comment on this
The Deputy's time is up. I will allow the Minister of State 30 seconds to reply to that question before he moves on to his statement.
Comment on this
Again, I answered that question earlier. With foreign policy, there are rules on the veto in trade policy and other rules, and it has not been possible to get agreement around the table. It is as simple as that. Ireland has been in the vanguard of trying to get the strongest possible action there. That is recognised across Europe and the world, except of course on the Opposition benches of this House.
Comment on this
That is the end of the question-and-answer session. I call on the Minister of State to give his final statement and reply.
Comment on this
Ba mhaith liom buíochas a ghabháil leis na Teachtaí as a gcuid ráitis agus ceisteanna. Tapóidh mé an deis seo labhairt go gairid faoi mhíreanna eile ar chlár ghnó Comhairle Eorpach mhí Dheireadh Fómhair. Rinne na ceannairí plé straitéiseach maidir le méadú. Thug an Taoiseach faisnéis do na ceannairí maidir leis an dul chun cinn atá déanta againn le linn téama Uachtaránachta na hÉireann, lena n-áirítear dúnadh trí chaibidil bhreise le Montainéagró agus caibidil breise amháin leis an Albáin. D’éascaíomar freisin d’oscailt dhá bhraisle eile leis an Úcráin agus leis an Moldóiv. Tá sé de rún againn dúnadh na gcaibidlí uile leis an Montainéagró a éascú faoi dheireadh na bliana, ar choinníoll go gcuirfidh Montainéagró na hathchóirithe uile atá fágtha chun feidhme. Tá an pointe seo an-tábhachtach, agus d’ardaigh an Teachta McAuliffe é sin.
Mhalartaigh na ceannairí tuairimí freisin faoi thograí an Choimisiúin Eorpaigh maidir le hathchóirithe inmheánacha an Aontais Eorpaigh i bhfianaise tuilleadh méadaithe, comhtháthú de réir a chéile agus clásail chosanta le haghaidh conarthaí aontachais amach anseo. Bhí plé straitéiseach ag na ceannairí maidir le cur chuige cuimsitheach an Aontais Eorpaigh i leith imirce, agus mheas siad dul chun cinn i gcur chun feidhme a gconclúidí roimhe sin.
Tá an tAontas Eorpach in áit níos fearr anois ó thaobh imirce neamhrialta de ná mar a bhí sé le breis agus deich mbliana anuas ó tharla go bhfuil laghdú ag teacht ar líon na ndaoine a thagann isteach, go bhfuil an comhshocrú maidir le himirce agus tearmann i bhfeidhm ó mhí an Mheithimh, agus gur ghlac an Chomhairle leis an rialachán maidir le filleadh go foirmiúil go luath i mí Dheireadh Fómhair.
Ceann de thosaíochtaí uileghabhálacha atá ag Uachtaránacht na hÉireann is ea leanúint de chur chuige atá cóir, daingean agus bunaithe ar rialacha a chur chun cinn maidir le himirce, tearmann agus filleadh. Tá an méid sin bunaithe ar cheithre phríomhthosaíocht: an Comhshocrú maidir le hImirce agus Tearmann a chur chun feidhme go hiomlán; cosaint theorainneacha seachtracha an Aontais Eorpaigh a neartú; ullmhacht do ghéarchéimeanna ag na teorainneacha sin a mhéadú; agus leanúint de chomhpháirtíochtaí a chothú le tríú tíortha. Ina theannta sin, táimid ag obair leis na ballstáit agus leis an gCoimisiún chun gníomhaíochtaí a chur chun cinn, ar gníomhaíochtaí iad a bhunaítear sa Phlean 5 Phointe chun Cosc a Chur ar Theacht Isteach Neamhdhleathach Líon Ollmhór Daoine, chun Teacht Roimhe agus chun Freagairt dó, rud a foilsíodh tar éis na n-imeachtaí in Ceuta.
D’fhill na ceannairí ar thopaic shlándáil agus chosaint na hEorpa ag Comhairle Eorpach mhí Dheireadh Fómhair. Ar fud an Aontais Eorpaigh, tá níos mó á infheistiú ag na tíortha ina gcumais slándála agus cosanta náisiúnta. Tá na cinntí á ndéanamh acu ina dtíortha féin. Tá siad uile ag déanamh amhlaidh ar bhealach lena bhfuil ciall dá staid agus dá gcur chuige beartais féin ar leith, agus do shaintréithe sonracha bheartas eachtrach gach ballstát. I gcás na hÉireann, is éard atá agus a bheidh ann ná beartas neodrachta míleata. Mar sin féin, tá sineirgí ann ar féidir linn iad a bhaint amach trí bheith ag obair le chéile ar leibhéal an Aontais Eorpaigh ar bhealach lena gcomhlánaítear a bhfuil á dhéanamh againn ar an leibhéal náisiúnta, inar tháinig méadú 43% ar mhaoiniú le haghaidh cosanta ó bhí 2020 ann.
Chuir na ceannairí fáilte roimh an gcéad tuarascáil ullmhachta cosanta bhliantúil mar mheasúnú bonnlíne tábhachtach ar ullmhacht chosaint na hEorpa. Uirlis luachmhar atá ann chun faireachán a dhéanamh ar dhul chun cinn ar fud na réimsí cumais tosaíochta agus príomhchumasóirí ullmhachta cosanta a shainaithint; lena n-áirítear ceanglais chumais a chomhchuibhiú, rochtain ar mhaoiniú don tionscal a fheabhsú, spleáchais ar an slabhra soláthair a laghdú agus amlínte soláthair a ghéarú chun tacú le nuálaíocht. Le roinnt seachtainí agus míonna anuas, bhí tionchar suntasach ag gníomhaíocht hibrideach ar na ballstáit, ar gníomhaíocht í atá ag titim amach níos minice agus atá níos místuama ná riamh. Tá treocht shoiléir ann: feachtas hibrideach comhordaithe atá ann atá dírithe ar shlándáil, athléimneacht agus boinn dhaonlathacha an Aontais Eorpaigh, a bhallstáit agus a chomhpháirtithe a chur i mbaol, agus ar an mbonn a bhaint díobh sin. Is mian leis an Rúis muid a scaradh ó chéile agus ár dtacaíocht don Úcráin a lagú. Ní éiróidh léi. Tháinig an Chomhairle Eorpach ar chonclúidí láidre maidir le feachtas gníomhaíochta hibridí na Rúise. Fáiltím roimh ghlao na gceannairí go dtreiseodh an tAontas Eorpach ár n-iarrachtaí agus go mbainfeadh sé úsáid iomlán as na hionstraimí agus na sásraí uile atá ar fáil chun cur i gcoinne na gníomhaíochta sin. Bhí rudaí eile ar an gclár, ar nós chúrsaí COP31, cúrsaí faoin Artach, agus Ceuta agus Melilla. Bhí an Taoiseach ag caint faoin tSúdáin freisin.