We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna ó Cheannairí - Leaders' Questions

Grandchild awaiting speech therapy

Summary

Doherty highlights a grandfather on dialysis who offered to give up his treatment so his non-verbal three-year-old grandson could receive speech therapy. The Tánaiste says children should not face that choice, notes rising CDNT staffing and funding, and reports that the national waiting list has fallen while remaining too high.

John McGuinness An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I welcome the Birr Historical Society to the Public Gallery. They are welcome and are here at the invitation of Deputy Nolan. I hope they enjoy their day in Dáil Éireann.

Comment on this

Tá mé tar éis labhairt le seanathair a bhfuil garmhac trí bliana d’aois aige atá neamhbhriathartha agus ag fanacht le teiripe urlabhra. Tá an seanathair seo 52 bliain d’aois agus ag fáil scagdhealaithe – dialysis – trí huaire in aghaidh na seachtaine. Tá sé i ndiaidh ofráil deireadh a chur lena chúram leighis ionas go mbeadh a gharmhac ábalta an cuidiú a bhfuil de dhíth air a fháil. Ní féidir an grá nó an crá croí a shéanadh. Tá na mílte leanaí ag fanacht le teiripe urlabhra agus teanga. An ndéanfaidh An Tánaiste idirghabháil i gcás an linbh seo chun cinntiú go bhfaighidh sé an teiripe? An ndéanfaidh sé gníomh a chuirfidh deireadh leis an mhoill seo?

I received an email during the week from a grandfather, who also contacted the Tánaiste. It stopped me in my tracks. I want to read it to the Tánaiste. It is very brief. He states that he is getting in touch regarding his only grandchild, who is three and is non-verbal but is a beautiful, happy, funny boy, and that his heart breaks for the child as he cannot talk and gets so frustrated. This grandfather states that his daughter has the child on a waiting list to be seen and he feels he is being left behind. He states that he himself is not well, he is on dialysis three times weekly and he is sure a lot of problems boil down to money. He states that he will do a trade-off; he will cease his treatment, saving the State a lot of money, if his grandson can get speech therapy. He further states that he knows what his outcome will be but he would give anything to hear his grandson's little voice. He asks the Tánaiste to treat his email seriously as he is 100% certain of his choices, and that he is still young at 52 but is at peace with his decision.

I have spoken to this man since and I have told him to continue his treatment. He gets that, but he is desperate. His love for his grandson is unmistakable and his heart is broken. He is 52 years of age, as he said. He is on dialysis three times a week and he was prepared to stop that treatment in order for that young, three-year-old grandchild to get the therapy he needs. What he needs is a direct, compassionate response and his grandson needs the help.

This is part of a wider failure in community care which gets far less attention than hospital waiting lists. HSE figures at the end of August show that there were 6,170 children waiting to begin their initial speech and language therapy. Across the Clare and County Limerick service area, 305 children are waiting on speech and language therapy. The longest waiting for assessment in that area of County Clare is 91 weeks. In my own county of Donegal, for children waiting for initial therapy the longest assessment was 44 weeks and families who cannot afford private therapy have no alternative but to wait.

Sinn Féin have told the Tánaiste time and time again. We have called for more therapists. We have called for clear waiting times. We have called for targets. We have called for monthly publication of community care waiting lists. We have proposed legislation requiring the National Treatment Purchase Fund to publish those lists. I am sure that when the Tánaiste stands up, he will say that 24,000 people were removed from the waiting list for therapy by the end of July, but the real question is how many of those children received treatment because removal from a list is not the same as care being delivered. Will the Tánaiste publish the results?

Today, I want to make a plea for that grandfather - that grandfather whose heart is broken. When I spoke to him, all I could hear from every syllable that he uttered was love, desperation and care for his grandchild. I am asking the Tánaiste to intervene in this particular case. I am asking the Tánaiste that this child's needs are reviewed and to ensure that he gets the speech and language therapy. This man's grandson cannot wait for another acknowledgement. I am asking the Tánaiste to intervene for this family now, but crucially to get this system fixed for the thousands of families like his who are just as desperate as he was and need the support for their children also.

Comment on this
Simon Harris The Tánaiste Fine Gael

I thank Deputy Doherty for raising this issue. I also thank that gentleman for emailing the Deputy and me in relation to his little grandchild. I share the Deputy's view, at the outset, that it shows the love and the bond that exists between a grandparent and their grandchild, and every grandparent or every parent wanting the very best for their grandchild or child and all of us wanting to see the very best done for children in this country as well. It should never be, and indeed never is, a choice between that man receiving the treatment he so desperately requires and wanting and expecting his young grandchild to also receive the speech and language therapy that he so badly needs and requires. I am sorry to hear, in the first instance, of the clear stress and anxiety that man is feeling. The Deputy said I received an email, which I will check now. I will certainly raise it with the Ministers and pass that email on to the HSE.

The Government recognises that primary care waiting list and therapy waiting lists are still too long and a number of initiatives are being taken to try to reduce the primary care waiting list. I am always conscious when I stand up and say these things that it matters little to the person who is wondering when their three-year-old grandchild is going to get the therapy. I take that point, but I want that grandfather to know, and I want all grandparents or parents who have their children waiting to know, that this is an area we are working on very intensively.

In September 2025, the Minster, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, provided funding for a long waiters initiative, with a specific focus on physiotherapy, occupational therapy and speech and language therapy waiting lists. There has been progress made through that. The important aim there is not only to reduce the numbers on the waiting lists in the short term, but to try to build a system that can stay on top of it in the longer term, and to have a lasting impact in addressing those backlogs and building capacity for the future. We expect further progress to be made on that through the next HSE service plan too.

The Minister of State, Deputy Higgins, also here today, has pointed out to me the progress that is being made in terms of our children's disability network teams. What I would say to that gentleman is that we have funding in place to hire more therapists, specifically to work in those teams. These are the network teams we all know in our constituency and in our community that work with children with disability needs. We have seen progress being made in reducing CDNT waiting lists. In fact, waiting lists were reduced by around 28% in 2025, with a commitment to build on that reduction during this year too.

People will know - those opposite will know this as constituency TDs - that funding can be allocated to hire more people. We also need to build up the pipeline of therapists that we have available to hire in the system. The Minister, Deputy Lawless, is increasing the number of student places. Indeed, the programme for Government commits to doubling the number of college places for speech and language therapists, physiotherapists, occupational therapists, dietitians, psychologists and social workers, providing up to 461 additional student places by 2028. For the three-year-old child today, I know that is not the answer, but it is the answer for building up the capacity of the system to make sure we do not find ourselves in a situation where any grandparent is worrying whether their grandchild will get access to the treatment they so very much require.

I thank that gentleman for bringing this issue in relation to his grandchild to my attention. I want to assure him that I will make sure the HSE has access to that information but I also want him, more importantly, to know that we are working on this as a priority issue. We are expanding our children's disability network teams right across the country, we are increasing the number of therapists working on them, we are increasing the number of training places to make sure we have an even further pipeline and we have, thankfully, seen waiting lists for CDNTs falling as a result of that investment.

Comment on this

We all deal with people but there has rarely been a time in my life that I was as taken aback as I was by this email. It was the lengths this person was willing to go to and the idea that he was trying to help the State provide speech and language therapy for his young grandson of three years of age, as he says. He would do anything just to hear his little voice. He was willing to give up his own treatment, knowing that would have an adverse impact on his own life and thinking that by saving the State a few pound, his young grandson would get treatment. That is the desperation that families feel.

The Tánaiste is talking about what the Government is doing. I could roll back the clock, with respect, and the Tánaiste would give the same speech last year and the year before. There are hundreds of children who are waiting for speech and language therapy for more than two years - not weeks and not months but two years. Seven hundred children are waiting on speech and language therapy for two years. The waiting time is 204 weeks in parts of Dublin for initial assessment. What comfort is the Tánaiste going to give to the thousands of parents out there whose children are non-verbal and who know that with the support of the State they can speak and talk, yet the system and the Government is failing them over and over again? I ask the Tánaiste to look at the crisis the Government is causing in relation to this and what measures he will put in place to adequately address it in the coming months.

Comment on this
Simon Harris The Tánaiste Fine Gael

What I would say to that individual, and to anybody whose child is awaiting therapies, is that the number of people working in our CDNTs is increasing as is the amount of funding going into them and that the wait times are now decreasing. The HSE preliminary data shows that the national CDNT waiting list has reduced by 62% from 16,522 children awaiting contact with a team in 2023 to 6,217 at the end of June 2026. Of course, that number is still too high but it is important that, as a Government, we give parents both hope and a way forward or direction of travel. That, by any measure, is a significant reduction in waiting times for CDNTs. We will and we must go further but we also have to tell people that we have to build the entire system here as well. We have to make sure we have enough people available to hire because, as the Deputy knows, we often put funding in place and run recruitment campaigns and find we cannot fill the necessary posts. That is why the Minister, Deputy Lawless, is significantly increasing the number of therapy places. This is a priority for Government, progress has been made and we will build on that progress in the time ahead.

Comment on this