We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna ó Cheannairí - Leaders' Questions

Colm Horkan family and inquiry referral

Summary

Kelly challenges the handling of Superintendent Brian O’Reilly’s protected disclosures and says the Horkan family were let down when their concerns were referred to Fiosrú without their knowledge. The Tánaiste defends the Ministers’ conduct, expresses sympathy for the family, and says the referral was intended as a mechanism to address their concerns.

Yesterday, the current and previous Ministers for justice, Deputies Jim O'Callaghan and McEntee, confirmed to this House that they acted without legal authority in the handling of Superintendent Brian O'Reilly's protected disclosures. The Minister, Deputy McEntee, admitted she interfered in the protected disclosure process when she should not have. She also admitted that Superintendent O'Reilly's correspondence to her was a protected disclosure in its own right but she sent it to An Garda Síochána. In doing so, she acted without legal authority. She did so using previous protected disclosures as some form of precedent for the handling of his case. That is ridiculous. She also tried to downgrade this protected disclosure by him "as a complaint rather than as a protected disclosure" and that it would be sent to GSOC, now Fiosrú.

The current Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, then came into office and actioned this by sending it as a complaint on 7 February 2025. In doing so, he also acted without legal authority. Those two Ministers acted without legal authority. That is very dangerous territory for this Government, and potentially fatal. Why? Because once the Office of the Protected Disclosures Commissioner made its statutory appointment of the then-Secretary General of the Department of Justice on 2 October 2023 to deal with this protected disclosure, it was locked in time. That is it.

Brian O'Reilly has been treated like dirt by An Garda Síochána and the Department of justice. His protected disclosures were left in abeyance for three years.

More important is the Horkan family, whom the Tánaiste knows. They have good time for him. Yesterday, they dismissed as "nonsense" the idea that the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, would ask Fiosrú to investigate their concerns regarding what happened to their son and brother on the night he was murdered. They feel let down and will not be co-operating with any such investigation.

GSOC was tasked with investigating this very issue in relation to these holsters, which I hold in my hand, in 2019, 11 months before Colm Horkan was murdered. It could not do it because it could not get the co-operation of An Garda Síochána. How is the family meant to have confidence in the same organisation, newly re-established, to do an investigation that it could not do back then?

This is unprecedented. A family is fighting the State to get an investigation into the circumstances of the capital murder of their loved one because of these holsters. The Government needs to change course. I am going to say out straight that this is not going to go away. The Government needs to stand up for this family. They are watching as I speak. I must say directly to the Tánaiste, whose party is meant to stand for law and order, that they are depending on him and his response.

Comment on this
Simon Harris The Tánaiste Fine Gael

I thank the Deputy. I say at the outset that I know the Ministers, Deputies McEntee and O'Callaghan, would always discharge their duties in line with the best possible advice available to them and with respect to the law. I know the Deputy has raised a range of broader issues there but I want to be clear in my view in relation to that.

I, like the Deputy, want today to focus my remarks on the specific point he made about the Horkan family and Detective Garda Colm Horkan. I reiterate that Colm's murder in 2020 shocked people right across this country. It stole a good, decent, honourable member of An Garda Síochána from his family and friends. He was a man who was beloved and kind, and served his country and community with duty and distinction. The Colm that his family and friends knew and loved so much became a personal loss for the Garda family but also for this country. I know he was a proud Mayo man and GAA man. Indeed, I was honoured, as Taoiseach, to meet his family, including his dad, and to open a pitch in his honour and memory. I could feel that day the love and respect that all of Colm's colleagues and community held for him. His murder reminds us of the risks that gardaí take every day to protect all of us and the burden that all Garda families carry in supporting them.

I want to say on the record of this House that Colm Horkan exemplified courage and dedication. Thinking of his family, imagine how any of us would feel. I do not know how any of us would feel, as a family, if our loved one was taken from us in such brutal circumstances. Of course we would want answers. I understand that fully.

The Deputy knows that the individual responsible for the murder of Detective Garda Horkan has been tried and convicted by a jury in a public hearing before the Central Criminal Court. There has been an appeal of that conviction. There is a reserve judgment from the Court of Appeal and neither I nor the Deputy are attempting to cut across that, nor should we. The Minister for justice met the Horkan family on 29 October to listen to their concerns. The Minister this week made the decision that the Deputy outlined, which was to request Fiosrú, under section 205(2) of the Policing, Security and Community Safety Act 2024, to conduct an investigation into matters concerning the safety and suitability of the holster used by Colm at the time of the incident at which he was murdered. My understanding is that Fiosrú has now agreed to conduct an independent investigation of these matters. It is also hoped that the criminal proceedings will conclude shortly and, thereafter, there will be a coroner's inquest to be held in public.

I know the Horkan family deserves answers. The Government will need to reflect further on yesterday's comments from the family. There will need to be further engagement with the family. We need to find a mechanism that works for them in terms of trying to get those answers. The Minister has said very clearly that he retains an open mind on a public inquiry. I reiterate that today. We need further engagement with the family and to work out how best to put a mechanism in place to address their sincerely held concerns about the brutal murder and loss of their loved one.

Comment on this

I thank the Tánaiste. I hope he has moved the dial on this. With all his colleagues beside him, I say, in all sincerity, that the Dáil has to move. It was not good that the Minister for justice met the family a week ago and then said that he was referring the matter to Fiosrú without them knowing and telling them it was happening. They were never going to co-operate with this. They feel let down and call it an absolute "nonsense" for the reasons I have outlined.

I hope what the Tánaiste is saying here today is going to be reflected in the coming weeks with a change whereby this family will be engaged with because they need to be met, perhaps by the Tánaiste and the Taoiseach, and that there will be a form of inquiry or process found - I am not hung up about what it will be - to absolutely meet their needs and questions. Will the Tánaiste please commit to that?

Comment on this
Simon Harris The Tánaiste Fine Gael

I thank the Deputy. A number of broader issues have been raised in this House in recent times and there have been responses from the Government and processes are ongoing. I note that. My comments are separate from and distinct to that.

Alongside and parallel to that, there is a grieving family who lost their son and brother, a serving member of An Garda Síochána. It is, in and of itself, rare to lose a member of An Garda Síochána in active service. They have concerns and questions. The Minister for justice met them in recognition of that and he brought forward what he believed to be a mechanism to try to provide answers. The family has now clearly given a view in relation to that and the Government needs to reflect further on that and engage further.

I appreciate what the Deputy says in terms of, to quote him back constructively, not being "hung up" on the format. It is about trying to establish the information and answers the family want about the loss of their son and brother, Detective Garda Colm Horkan. That is the way in which Government should and will engage on this matter and there will be further engagement with the family.

Comment on this