We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna ó Cheannairí - Leaders' Questions

Oversight of engineering complaints

Summary

Ward calls for independent oversight of complaints about engineers’ professional conduct, particularly in the defective concrete crisis. The Tánaiste points to building-control laws and enforcement powers, disputing that professional bodies can simply regulate themselves without wider safeguards.

I raise serious issues of accountability and public protection in the engineering profession in Ireland. Engineers play a critical role. Their reports can determine whether a home is safe, whether a family can remain in it or whether homeowners have any route to redress when things go wrong. In the defective concrete crisis serious concerns have been raised. Complaints have been made to Engineers Ireland about professional conduct. When this issue is raised in the Dáil the response has been that it is a matter for Engineers Ireland. My questions are straightforward. Given the State's recognition of Engineers Ireland's role and the professional framework it provides, does the State accept responsibility to assure independent oversight? What independent mechanism exists for the public when complaints arise? Will the Government commit to an independent review of the current arrangements? I am not asking the Tánaiste to intervene in any individual complaints but to ensure proper, independent accountability where professional standards affect public safety and people's homes.

Comment on this
Simon Harris The Tánaiste Fine Gael

Gabhaim buíochas leis an Teachta for raising this question. It is an issue he has been pursuing through a variety of the fora and avenues available to him, including parliamentary questions, in recent times.

In order to ensure the safety of people within the built environment, the design and construction of buildings in Ireland is regulated under the Building Control Acts. There are clear administrative procedures in place for demonstrating compliance in respect of an individual building or works, and they are set out in the building control regulations. These empower competence and professionalism in construction projects but they also endeavour to establish a chain of responsibility that begins with the owner. With certain limited exceptions, the owner must assign competent persons to design, build, inspect and certify the building works. These, in turn, must account for their role through the lodgement of compliance documentation, inspection plans and statutory certificates. Under those regulations, chartered engineers on the register maintained by Engineers Ireland under section 7 of the Institution of Civil Engineers of Ireland (Charter Amendment) Act 1969 may be appointed and may be signed as an assigned certifier, provided they are competent in relation to the particular works involved. That assigned certifier is assigned by the building owner to inspect and co-ordinate the inspection activities. There are also strong powers of enforcement under the Building Control Acts to ensure compliance with both the building regulations and the building control regulations. Enforcement is delegated to the local building control authorities which are independent in the exercise of their statutory powers. That is the factual position. It is slightly technical but it is important to put on the record of the House.

In answering this question, I am aware of the context in which the Deputy raises this and the real trauma people in his county and others, though perhaps particularly in Donegal, have gone through with the mica situation. While not in any way like the Deputy, I have been in homes in Donegal affected by this and seen the devastation - the pain, stress, anxiety and the rest - it has caused people. I wanted to acknowledge that.

To be helpful in terms of what Deputy Ward is suggesting, there is a programme for Government commitment to establish a new building standards regulatory authority. The Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage is currently implementing this two-stage process. The aim of this new authority is to strengthen the oversight role of the State in respect of the design and construction of buildings. I wonder perhaps if this is an issue the Minister could engage further with the Deputy on because the aim is that the new authority will ensure stronger oversight of design and construction and give greater confidence about those standards as well. There is the programme for Government commitment on that. On foot of the Deputy raising this issue in the Dáil, I will send the transcript of this discussion to the Minister for housing and ask that he engage with the Deputy on that basis.

Comment on this

I accept that and I understand where the Tánaiste is coming from regarding this. However, engineers are administering their own profession, so their disciplinary processes are being done in-house when a problem arises. A problem is arising now. We have hundreds, potentially thousands, of houses affected and this will be something we will have to come back to retrospectively. When it comes to precisely these concerns the public has serious questions and the operation of these processes needs independent oversight. There is no doubt about that. The Department of enterprise has no responsibility and when we try the Department with responsibility for public bodies, there is no responsibility. Basically, Engineers Ireland is marking its own homework. There is no process and no accountability. People are in this scheme and there are issues with it, but there is no accountability for engineers who are not doing their job. I am asking the Government to identify the responsibilities and the areas and to ensure we have some form of independent statutory mechanism going forward to make this scheme work.

Comment on this
Simon Harris The Tánaiste Fine Gael

I do not want to be argumentative on this issue, but I respectfully suggest there are some laws that already underpin a number of these issues of building control and standards. In my previous answer, I specifically referenced the Building Control Acts and the strong powers of enforcement that are there to ensure people comply with the building regulations and the building control regulations. I would not fully align with the idea that Engineers Ireland or any other professional body can just have its register and do its own thing. Obviously Engineers Ireland does the register and that is an important thing. It has its professional standards and it is the professional body, but we all operate under the laws of the land. The bigger question perhaps is whether the laws of the land and the structures are adequate. Do they need to be more robust? As I said, the programme for Government agrees with Deputy Ward to a point, in that there is certainly a need for a new building standards regulatory authority to try to better co-ordinate, strengthen and enhance the oversight role of the State when it comes to the design and construction of buildings. I will feed the Deputy's comments back to the Minister, Deputy Browne, as part of that process.

Comment on this