We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Written answer

Renewable Energy Generation

68. Deputy Naoise Ó Muirí asked the Minister for Climate, Energy and the Environment the assessment that has been made of Ireland’s capacity to produce HVO from indigenous feedstocks, including the need for imports and their carbon and sustainability implications; and if any studies have been undertaken in this regard. [78005/26]

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Minister for Climate, Energy and the Environment Fianna Fáil

Hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO) is a bioliquid which can be used as a renewable energy source for heating and which, in a transport context, is classified as a biofuel. HVO is currently available for consumers to purchase for use in both transport and heating. The Climate Action Plan includes a range of measures to address the use of fossil fuels in heating systems in buildings, with the National Heat Study (2021) published by the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland containing the detailed analysis that is informing the development of options to decarbonise the heating and cooling sectors in the period to 2050.

The National Heat Study considered a number of potential decarbonisation options for a wide range of dwellings and business premises. These included the use of liquid biofuels such as HVO, solid biomass, biogases, as well as heat pumps and district heating networks. The recommendation of the National Heat Study is that heat pumps are the optimal decarbonisation path for heating systems, with district heating also being an option that can be widely deployed. However, the National Heat Study also recognised the potential role for sustainable bioenergy for buildings that require alternative routes to decarbonisation, which is being considered as part of a suite of measures to decarbonise heat. The Government recognises that sustainable bioliquids, renewable liquid fuels and other lower-carbon heating solutions may have an important role to play in reducing emissions from rural homes as part of the transition away from fossil fuel heating.

My Department is also working on the introduction of a Renewable Heat Obligation (RHO) for the heat sector. Under current proposals, the RHO will obligate suppliers of all fossil fuels used for heating purposes to ensure a proportion of the energy they supply is renewable. As such, all renewable fuels, including HVO and other bioliquids used for heat that satisfy the sustainability criteria of the Renewable Energy Directive, will be considered eligible for certification under the scheme. Priority drafting of the RHO Bill is now at an advanced stage and nearing completion. Once finalised, I intend to submit the final Bill to Government seeking approval to publish.

There have been several studies which have considered the issue of the production and supply of HVO for the Irish market. This includes the Comprehensive Heating and Cooling Assessment (2026), which sets out that:

“Bioliquids such as HVO and bio-LPG offer a viable pathway for increasing renewable energy use in Ireland's heat sector in the near term and will be supported through the RHO. Security of supply is a factor, as Ireland would remain heavily reliant on imports for these fuels. While forecasting is difficult, high global demand is likely for the global supply of sustainable feedstocks as mandates are increased in road, aviation and transport in many regions, posing risks to availability and price stability of bioliquids into 2030s and 2040s. The choice of bioliquids for heat is also more limited than that for transport biofuels due to the stricter RED III maximum GHG savings thresholds for heat use. Sustainably sourced HVO is a limited resource globally and is most effectively prioritised for use-cases without viable low carbon alternatives, rather than as a bulk heating solution for heat in buildings. However, some heating demands will remain difficult to decarbonise by other means, and bioliquids can play a role in deep decarbonisation scenarios, as illustrated by the results of the alternative scenario.”

There have been several other studies published in recent years related to the use of HVO in transport.

In line with the objectives of Ireland’s Road Haulage Strategy 2022–2031, the published Assessment of the Availability of HVO for the Irish Heavy Goods Freight Sector (2025), indicates that, given the current Road Transport Fuel Obligation (RTFO) requirement on fuel suppliers, any incentives aimed at increasing the supply of HVO toward 100% in the HGV sector will simply shift biofuel supply away from other road transport use sectors with minimal additional decarbonisation benefit in the road transport sector overall. Additionally, the study forecasts that a subsidy to equalise the price of HVO with diesel, in a scenario of up to 100% HVO supply, could incur an Exchequer cost in 2030 alone of €502m.

In my role as Minister for Transport, I recently published the Hierarchy of Use of Hydrotreated Vegetable Oil (HVO) Across Transport and Other Sectors Report.  The Report examines the growing demand for HVO, and optimal focus for intervention to best promote efficient use of this renewable energy within and outside the transport sector both in the short-term and beyond 2030. The Report confirms a hierarchy of use of HVO in Ireland which aligns with several existing policies and measures, including the Sustainable Aviation Fuel Taskforce Report, the Road Haulage Strategy, the Renewable Transport Fuel Policy, the Ports Policy, and the design of the RHO. The Report will inform the continued development and implementation of Departmental policy and plans.

The published Biofuel Study Report 2022 A Review of Requirements and Constraints on Biofuels in Ireland Arising from RED II and National Targets, was conducted and prepared for the Department of Transport and the National Oil Reserves Agency. In its assessment the Report noted that:

• There is potential for indigenous production to scale up to between 435m and 735m litres of biodiesel/HVO in 2030, but with low recoverable feedstock supplies (potential for 70m litres of biodiesel from indigenous feedstock) reliance on imported feedstocks (used cooking oil and tallow) will continue to be high.

• In the absence of indigenous HVO production, Ireland would be relying on HVO imports that could amount to between 4% and 5% of European HVO capacity and 1% to 2% of global capacity.

The Renewable Transport Fuel (RTF) Policy 2025–2027 sets out a pathway for achievement of Climate Action Plan biofuel targets and European targets for renewable energy in transport as set out in the Renewable Energy Directive. This is achieved through the RTFO, an obligation on fuel suppliers to ensure a minimum proportion of renewable fuel in all road transport petroleum products supplied in Ireland. Among the aims of the RTF Policy is to ensure the principle of non-discrimination in the application of Renewable Energy Directive requirements, while promoting development of biofuel supply from indigenous feedstock production in line with the objectives of the Directive

Sustainability compliance is assured through an EU sustainability framework which involves the certification of economic operations globally (for feedstock collection, and renewable fuel production, storage and supply) by certifying bodies against standards established under EU approved voluntary schemes. The National Oil Reserves Agency (NORA) is the agency in the State responsible for ensuring the sustainability credentials of biofuel supply into Ireland under the NORA Act 2007.

Concerns over certain global feedstock supply chains are being addressed at a European level through the introduction of more rigorous verification requirements. These measures include the development of an EU database and new supervisory powers for Member States’ competent authorities to oversee certifying bodies responsible for ensuring the verification of information entered on the EU database by fuel suppliers. The European Commission is also reviewing EU legislation to strengthen EU-wide supervision of sustainability certification, and the enforcement of existing provisions, through a committee working group established under the Renewable Energy Directive, in which Ireland is an active participant.

My Department collaborates closely with relevant Government Departments and Agencies concerning biofuel sustainability through the Department of Transport-led Biofuel Sustainability Working Group established under the RTF Policy. Ireland continues to call for harmonised action at EU level concerning the risk of fraud, while also taking steps to safeguard renewable fuel supplies into Ireland, similar to action being taken by other Member States.

Comment on this