Written answer
Childcare Services
92. Deputy Paul Murphy asked the Minister for Children, Disability and Equality if she is concerned at the impact on children's rights of the use of a private company for supervised access resulting from court cases which has previously been barred from being used by Tusla due to concerns over its practices; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [78284/26]
Comment on this
In relation to this organisation, Tusla has confirmed that it has not commissioned its supervised access services since 8th October, 2024. Tusla has also taken additional steps to strengthen the controls in place to ensure that the company is not used again.
In a small number of cases, Tusla uses external providers, such as supervision and access centres, often at the direction of the courts. These services are typically used when a child is in the care of Tusla.
Regarding the commissioning of services by Tusla, a process exists for all external third-party providers, to register with Tusla. This involves a governance process, including confirmation of qualifications, Garda vetting, mandatory training, and membership of relevant professional bodies, among other checks.
Regarding safeguarding and the rights of the child, all organisations, including private supervised access services, are duty bound to follow Children First: National Guidance for the Protection and Welfare of Children (2017). This is the primary statutory policy framework designed to help organisations identify, report, and manage concerns regarding the safety and welfare of children.
Under Children First, supervision/access centres are classified as a 'relevant service' as they provide care and supervision of children whilst in the centre. Therefore, any such service providers working with Tusla are required to have a Child Safeguarding Statement, and provide relevant policies and procedures for reporting child protection and welfare concerns.
It is important to acknowledge the independence of the courts in family law proceedings. Tusla is just one of a number of parties that may contract or arrange supervised access services, where such supervision is ordered.
Where a court orders that contact be supervised, it may specify which provider or person should be used. However, normally it will be for the parties themselves to propose arrangements. This may be through a private provider, a local family-support organisation, or in many cases a relative to one of the parties, acting as a supervisor.
In most family law cases, Tusla will have no involvement at all, as the case may be entirely between the parents.
I appreciate that issues around supervised access are sensitive, and these are matters for the Courts. As the courts are independent, it would not be appropriate for the Department to comment further. It would also be inappropriate for the Department to comment on the continued use of a particular provider's services by courts or private individuals. This would be a matter for the parties involved and for the court.
Questions around which private or voluntary providers should be used by the courts might more appropriately be considered in the wider context of private family law, and directed to the Department of Justice, Immigration and Home Affairs, or the Courts Service.