Ceisteanna ar Sonraíodh Uain Dóibh - Priority Questions ›
Industrial Relations
Ireland’s collective bargaining coverage is estimated at 33%–34%, but the Minister of State said it is too early to measure any change from the 2026–2030 action plan, which is focused on engagement and improving data. Rose Conway-Walsh criticized the lack of tangible progress and called for enforceable bargaining and union-access rights; the Government reaffirmed its voluntary industrial relations model.
77. Deputy Rose Conway-Walsh asked the Minister for Enterprise, Tourism and Employment to report on the measurable improvements in collective bargaining coverage in Ireland in the year since the publication of the Government’s action plan to promote collective bargaining. [79772/26]
Comment on this
It is now a year since the Government published the action plan to promote collective bargaining and workers have seen precious little action in that time.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for her question. Collective bargaining coverage in Ireland is estimated at 33% to 34% of employees, drawing on figures informed by survey-based evidence and research sources, including the workplace industrial relations survey and the OECD ICTWSS database, together with analysis by Eurofound and other national and international sources.
Ireland's Action Plan to Promote Collective Bargaining 2026-2030 includes measures to close data gaps and provide reliable and up-to-date evidence on collective bargaining coverage. The Department is working with the Central Statistics Office, ICTU, IBEC and research bodies to develop appropriate metrics and improve the quality and regularity of available data. The action plan's content was reviewed by the EU in October. The plan is being actively implemented in line with the social partners. Regular progress reports on the suite of actions are regularly provided. The plan provides for a mid-term review in 2028.
Implementation of the plan is progressing across a range of measures. Key developments in 2026 include: seven dedicated meetings under the Labour Employer Economic Forum, LEEF, umbrella between Department officials, ICTU and IBEC to support and monitor the implementation of the action plan; quarterly engagements between my Department, the Workplace Relations Commission and the Labour Court to align priorities and progress relevant actions; a new award category celebrating excellence in collective bargaining practices launched in August; and progressing the research commitments with a view to developing and collating more robust and representative data on collective bargaining coverage during 2027 in advance of Ireland’s next reporting obligations to the European Commission in 2028.
Comment on this
I do not see where the action is being implemented. As the Minister of State said, there are a lot of meetings and other things but I cannot see the working out of that. Unions and workers are still concerned the plan was little more than a box-ticking exercise to comply with that EU directive on adequate minimum wages. A year on, those concerns seem to be well-founded. I am still trying to find out what measurable progress has been made. How many more workers are covered by collective bargaining arrangements as a direct result of this plan?
The Government’s action plan acknowledges the enormous benefits of collective bargaining: better pay, improved working conditions, addressing the power imbalance between workers and employers, increased productivity and better work-life balance. Yet, a year after it was published, we have seen little meaningful action to deliver those benefits for workers. Ireland remains among the worst performers in the EU when it comes to collective bargaining coverage. That is not something we should accept.
Comment on this
Ireland continues to have a robust industrial relations framework. There is active engagement with employers and workers’ representatives across multiple structures. Through this action plan, we are taking a practical approach. That involves, first, improving the evidence and data. We want to continue to strengthen social dialogue, support voluntary collective bargaining and deliver on commitments contained in the action plan.
The honest answer is it is too early to reliably measure any national change in collective bargaining. The action plan is in its early stages. However, we are continuing conversations and engagements through my Department with employer and employee representative organisations. Progress is being made.
Comment on this
Before the last election, the Minister of State’s party signed the respect at work pledge promising to support the legislation promoting collective bargaining, protect workplace representatives and guarantee trade union access at work. I cannot believe the number of workplaces in our own county that do not allow union access. Does the Minister of State genuinely believe he has honoured that pledge? The workers and unions I talk to certainly do not.
Last year, I and Sinn Féin tabled a motion calling for a legal right to collective bargaining and a legal right for trade unions to access workplaces. The Government voted it down. We recognise improving collective bargaining coverage requires legislative action. Workers do not need another action plan sitting on a shelf; they need rights that are enforceable by law. The consequences of failing to strengthen collective bargaining are very real for workers and their families.
Comment on this
The Government's role is very much to support constructive engagement while respecting the autonomy of employers, workers and trade unions. As the Deputy knows, Ireland operates a voluntary industrial relations model. That has been developed over many decades. Other countries have different arrangements. The Government's focus now is on the implementation of the action plan that has been agreed between trade unions and the employers' representatives. It ensures that Ireland complies with the directives while respecting Irish law and practice. We are doing that by strengthening the enabling conditions. We are also strengthening the social dialogue and improving the evidence base. Policy should be focused on data. That progress is being properly monitored, and it will be informed as we move through the action plan.