We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Ceisteanna ar Sonraíodh Uain Dóibh - Priority Questions ›

Legislative Process

Summary

Peter Burke defended publishing the Short-Term Letting and Tourism Bill before the committee’s pre-legislative scrutiny report, citing the absence of a report after an extended period and the need to establish the register and meet EU obligations. Rose Conway-Walsh said scrutiny could not be completed without planning guidelines and accused the Government of creating confusion and uncertainty for hosts.

79. Deputy Rose Conway-Walsh asked the Minister for Enterprise, Tourism and Employment the reason for not waiting for the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Enterprise, Tourism and Employment to finish its pre-legislative scrutiny of the Short-Term Letting and Tourism Bill 2026 and to publish its PLS report, with its recommendations, before the final Bill was introduced. [79774/26]

Comment on this

This question relates to the Short-Term Letting and Tourism Bill 2026. There is a real anger towards the Minister among hosts for rushing ahead and publishing this Bill without waiting for the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Enterprise, Tourism and Employment to complete the pre-legislative scrutiny and submit the report and its recommendations. This shows an extraordinary disregard for the committee, its members and the organisations that engaged with it in good faith.

The Minister is ramming the Committee, Report and Final Stages through the Dáil in a single day tomorrow simply to meet his own self-imposed deadline of 1 December. What was the point of pre-legislative scrutiny if he had no intention of waiting for its conclusions?

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Conway-Walsh for her very important question.

The general scheme of the Short-Term Letting and Tourism Bill was approved by the Government in April 2025 and was referred to the Joint Committee on Enterprise, Tourism and Employment on 16 June 2025 to be considered under pre-legislative scrutiny following the transfer of the tourism function to the Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment. The Bill provides the statutory basis for the introduction of regulatory controls, including a national register for the short-term letting sector. The tourism sector has broadly welcomed the introduction of this register.

Pre-legislative scrutiny commenced on 15 October 2025 and my Department has fully co-operated with the process set out in the Oireachtas handbook. My officials have also engaged extensively with stakeholders at national and EU level and established a dedicated webpage with information for short-term letting operators and platforms.

The current pre-legislative scrutiny framework was revised in 2022 to address concerns regarding delays arising from open-ended scrutiny processes. As part of those reforms, a standard timeframe of eight weeks was established for committees to undertake pre-legislative scrutiny and furnish a report to the Minister. The Oireachtas guidance also states that committees are empowered, but not obliged, to undertake pre-legislative scrutiny and that the process should not operate as an indefinite barrier to the publication of legislation. Having allowed more than sufficient time for scrutiny, and with no report forthcoming, it was necessary to progress the legislation.

Publication of the Bill ensures that the necessary legislation is in place to enable Fáilte Ireland to implement the short-term letting register in December. It will also provide legal certainty for the sector to enable Ireland to fulfil its obligations under the EU short-term rental regulation, which came into effect on 20 May 2026.

It should be noted that, in line with Oireachtas guidelines, the committee's report would ordinarily have been expected by mid-December 2025. The Department allowed a further period of almost 11 months beyond that date before progressing the legislation, during which no report was furnished.

Comment on this

I have never heard a more disingenuous answer. It is disrespectful to the Chair of the committee, its secretariat and members, because the Minister knows the pre-legislative scrutiny could not be completed without the planning guidelines. It would have been absolute nonsense to complete it without the guidelines. We waited and waited for those guidelines. It is the Minister who has made a shambles of this legislation and turned the entire pre-legislative scrutiny process into a farce.

The committee spent considerable time and resources engaging with organisations such as Fáilte Ireland, Threshold, the Department of housing, the County and City Management Association, Historic Houses of Ireland, the Irish Self-Catering Federation, booking.com, and even the Minister's Department. They all gave their time, expertise and evidence in good faith on the understanding their contributions, alongside the committee's recommendations, would inform the final Bill. The pre-legislative scrutiny could not be completed without the national planning guidelines. The Minister needs to put that on record.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy for her response. As Minister for tourism, I am responsible for the tourism aspect of the legislation. We engaged with the committee. I cannot be responsible for the planning aspect and planning statement, which the Minister, Deputy Browne, has responsibility for. However, I point out that we held a number of joint stakeholder meetings with a number of those affected, including representatives of the Irish Self-Catering Federation. We attended its annual conference and answered questions. We had a number of meetings at the Department with it on 29 April and 20 June 2025. I also engaged extensively with the sector.

As we are all aware, this debate has been going on for a long time. We know what the issues are in connection with it and it is important to get a balance to ensure we can have vibrant tourism accommodation in rural areas and that, in the 25 towns and cities where there is significant housing pressure, we ensure we bring more units back onto the long-term rental market. That is the objective of the legislation. We have a fair balance in doing that.

Comment on this

This is a crisis entirely of the Minister's making and he is asking everyone else to pay the price for his failure to prepare and the failure of the Minister for housing. I agree with the Minister, but there should be joined up actions in the Government between the Minister for tourism and the Minister for housing. This legislation is far too important to get wrong and the Minister has created enormous confusion and uncertainty for short-term letting hosts. His communication has been abysmal.

People are genuinely panicking. Family businesses are worried about their livelihoods and they still do not know where they stand. Incredibly, it appears their legislation could allow for commercial investors operating for more than seven years to continue, while, at the same time, penalising small, family-run businesses in rural Ireland. That does not make sense. He is potentially protecting the very commercial operators this legislation is supposed to address, while punishing ordinary families.

Then there is the 31 December deadline, which is right in the middle of the Christmas holidays. Offices will be closed. Services will be stretched and hosts will be scrambling to register properties before the deadline. This should not be happening.

Comment on this

To be clear, this legislation does not go far enough for the Deputy's party. Sinn Féin wants to impose a stricter regime so the families the Deputy is talking about would be precluded from having short-term lets. The Sinn Féin housing spokesperson is on the record as saying this does not go far enough.

The legislation I brought forward ensures the family businesses to which the Deputy referred can pay €25, register from 1 December and have two years to become planning compliant and that for family businesses that have existed for seven years - not commercial operators, but family businesses that have been providing accommodation for more than seven years - there is a presumption that planning permission will be granted to them. It is clear and concise. It is an express administration process.

The Deputy needs to be clear about one thing. I listened to her speech and that of Deputy Ó Broin last week. There is no consistency there. He said we need a stronger regime and almost that short-term lets are a scourge. That is what he said, that we need more long-term accommodation across the country. If the Deputy is being decent about this, she should say a figure. What figure does she want our population to be? What does she want us to work on?

Comment on this

The Minister needs to differentiate them from the commercial.

Comment on this

I did not hear anything put forward.

Comment on this

There are two Ministers involved in this.

Comment on this

The Deputy should at least be open and upfront and say we will go for 10,000 or 5,000, because when I went for 20,000, which exempts a lot of short-term lets in her constituency, Sinn Féin said I was wrong. Let us be clear on that.

Comment on this
Conor Sheehan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

The Minister is over time. We will move to the next question.

Comment on this

That is an arbitrary figure plucked from the air.

Comment on this