Ceisteanna ar Sonraíodh Uain Dóibh - Priority Questions ›
Insurance Industry
Rose Conway-Walsh pressed for a clear, transparent mechanism ensuring savings from lower injury awards reach SMEs through reduced premiums, rather than increasing insurers’ profits. Peter Burke cited falling motor premiums, lower claims and the insurance reform plan, and said passing savings to consumers was critical, while acknowledging continuing pressure on business insurance.
80. Deputy Rose Conway-Walsh asked the Minister for Enterprise, Tourism and Employment in light of his proposal to cap minor injury payouts, the action that will be taken to ensure the savings being made by insurance companies from reduced claims will be passed on to business owners to reduce the cost of doing business. [79456/26]
Comment on this
This question relates to the cost of doing business, which is becoming increasingly unsustainable for SMEs. Small businesses are being squeezed from every direction and insurance premiums remain one of the most significant pressures facing employers. I welcome the measures to reduce excessive personal injury awards, but reducing payouts cannot simply mean increasing profits for insurance companies. What concrete action will the Minister take to ensure the savings from capped injury awards are passed on directly to SMEs through reduced insurance premiums, rather than pocketed by insurance companies?
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Conway-Walsh for her question in this important area on which I am working, alongside my Cabinet colleagues, to continue to bring down the cost of insurance in line with the programme for Government. Our focus is to deliver a comprehensive series of actions aimed at improving affordability, availability and transparency across the insurance sector.
One of the first steps to deliver on these commitments was the new action plan for insurance reform, which was published on 24 July 2025. The action plan for insurance reform includes a range of actions under six themes, including competitiveness, legal reform, fraud reduction, innovation and skills, and climate protection. Responsibility for the actions lies across a number of Government Departments and public sector bodies. The Injuries Resolution Board, an agency of my Department, is tasked with several actions under the plan, which are intended to strengthen its remit and maximise the number of claims resolved through its non-adversarial processes, thereby reducing unnecessary, expensive and time-consuming litigation.
In October 2025, under action 4 of the plan, I published an independent report, a review of compensation for minor soft-tissue injuries in Ireland and the UK. The report analysed compensation for minor neck and back soft-tissue injuries sustained in road traffic accidents, comparing Ireland with England and Wales. It found that over the three-year period reviewed, the average assessment made in Ireland was 3.9 times higher than the average in England and Wales, while the average Irish insurer settlement was 4.9 times higher for minor neck or back injuries. On foot of this, I have asked the Injuries Resolution Board to conduct a second, more extensive, piece of research to be delivered in the first quarter of 2027, which will strengthen the evidence base and support the Judicial Council in its review of the personal injuries guidelines.
In 2025, data from the Injuries Resolution Board showed that 67% of the claims received by the board were for minor injuries. Awards were only accepted in under 40% of assessed claims under the board's consent-based model. These findings demonstrate the importance of examining the more significant measures of reform set out in action 22 of the plan.
Comment on this
Insurance costs are crippling small businesses. Not only do we have a situation where there are enormous energy costs, but insurance costs are continuing to rise. I know that from my own insurance costs. They have risen 15% this year. Employers are paying enormous premiums just to keep their doors open, and many are struggling to remain viable. We need competition in the insurance market to challenge the dominance of major providers and address the lack of meaningful choice available to businesses. It is all well and good introducing caps on injury awards but let us be clear about what that means. Insurance companies will be paying out less money. The question is whether businesses will see any of those savings.
Meanwhile, the cost of doing business continues to spiral. We have heard the plans to permit further toll increases. For a small business using these roads multiple times each day, those additional charges quickly multiply into significant annual costs. Every increase matters when running a small business, employing people and trying to keep the doors open. Businesses need reductions in their costs, not more promises while their bills continue to rise.
Comment on this
We have seen 20,000 claims go through the Injuries Resolution Board last year, which saved about €88 million in avoided legal costs. That is a significant saving for the business community. Claims are 35% lower compared with 2019 and the median award is 24% lower. That demonstrates that we are making progress. We are on the 11th consecutive month in which the cost of motor insurance has continued to fall. Again, that continued reduction is a significant and important asset.
We are currently looking at the potential of bringing in a cap for minor injury claims that could go forward. Essentially, it would be similar to an adjudication made by the Residential Tenancies Board, RTB, or the Workplace Relations Commission, WRC, which would be proportionate and set by the Oireachtas. Essentially, it would streamline a lot of cases and build more capacity into the system. Obviously, we would provide a right to recourse on a point of law that could be challenged through the courts. If we could have a cap in place for both the courts and the Injuries Resolution Board, it would provide significant savings to the sector. The need to get those savings passed onto consumers is critical.
Comment on this
To whom will those savings go? I want to bring the Minister back to the fundamental question. He needs a clear and transparent plan to ensure the savings from the reduced personal injury awards reach the SMEs that desperately need them. Insurance companies are already generating substantial profits. There is absolutely no justification for a situation in which the Government reduces the amount insurers have to pay, only for businesses to continue to be ripped off while insurance providers enjoy greater corporate profits. What specifically is the Minister going to do to ensure those savings for insurance companies are passed on to small and medium businesses that need every help they can possibly get at this particular time? No Government policy should be done simply on the basis of providing more profit for insurance companies. We already have a lack of transparency on the raw data within the sector. We need measures in place to ensure that if this initiative goes ahead, the extra profits are passed on.
Comment on this
That has been our key objective. As I pointed out, we have seen significant success with motor insurance. There have been 11 consecutive months in which the cost of motor insurance has reduced. Motor insurance costs have reduced by approximately 5% in the past year. The critical challenge has been public and employer liability.
When it comes to competition in the marketplace, we have got new insurers in. A key focus of the Government, through our new insurance action plan, is to demonstrate that when we work in partnership with consumers and insurance companies in bringing in reforms – we must remember the previous Government brought in more than 90% of the reforms it was asked to do – we will be ensuring those reforms result in reduced consumer quotes on the other side of the coin. It must go in partnership. That is the bargain we have with insurance companies. We need to ensure we see reduced premiums, such as those we have seen with motor insurance. I know there is a challenge with other business insurance, but we are working hard through our new action plan to see reduced premiums.