Saincheisteanna Tráthúla - Topical Issue Debate ›
Water Services
South Tipperary Deputies condemned prolonged water outages and safety notices, including a month-long delay before the Ardfinnan “do not consume” warning, and called for Uisce Éireann to be accountable to the Oireachtas. Minister of State Cummins acknowledged poor communication and promised improved responses; the Ardfinnan warning has been lifted, but its boil-water notice remains pending further testing.
I thank the Minister of State, Deputy Cummins, for taking this Topical Issue matter. On Tuesday last myself and my Oireachtas colleagues from south Tipperary met with the CEO of Irish Water and his leadership team such is the crisis in the water supply across the constituency of Tipperary south. The CEO described Tipperary as its most challenged area. That in itself tells a story. We have tens of thousands on a boil water notice. Some of those are on a do not consume notice for a period of time. There are multiple outages and very poor communication. Cordangan, which supplies Tipperary town's population of 5,000, has been on a boil water notice since February of this year. The Ardfinnan supply, which supplies the bulk of Cahir and surrounding areas and comes into the west of Clonmel, is on a boil water notice since June this year. For a period of time those 11,000 customers are on a do not consume notice. There are multiple outages across Clonmel and huge changes across Clonmel, with large parts of Carrick-on-Suir without water as well.
This is a significant public company in receipt of significant funding from taxpayers and offering an essential service. Yet, it remains unaccountable to Dáil Éireann. It is extraordinary to think that I, as a Member of Parliament, cannot table a parliamentary question. This needs to change. Everyone in this House of democracy agrees with that. My question to the Minister of State is: how can we make this happen?
Comment on this
I thank the Ceann Comhairle for accepting this Topical Issue matter today. South Tipperary's water crisis has exposed a serious failure of accountability at the heart of our water governance system. Families and businesses were left in the dark while agencies passed the responsibility from one to another. I am speaking about the Ardfinnan scheme. We know that the HSE was informed about aluminium exceedance on 9 September this year but a do not consume order was not issued until 9 October, which was a month later. During that period, more than 60 of the 72 samples exceeded guideline levels with some exceedance up to 12 times EU limits. It is shocking. It was two and a half times the WHO limits. The public deserves answers as to why it was more than a month before the do not consume notice was issued. Who knew? When did they know? Why was action not taken sooner? Who made the decision to wait for a month before issuing a warning? The HSE said it is a matter for the Environmental Protection Agency, EPA. The EPA says it does not provide public health advice and directs questions back to the HSE. The Minister for Health says it is an operational matter for Uisce Éireann. The role of the Commission for Regulation of Utilities, CRU, has been virtually invisible throughout the crisis. The obvious questions are: who is accountable, who is going to be accountable and who is going to take charge of this?
From the public's perspective, that was shocking. We had a meeting in Clonmel last night covering the whole of south Tipperary. I salute the committee there, which is working very hard under Richie Gleeson and Joe Hawkins. Indeed, we all attended to listen to people. In Cordangan in Tipperary, the well went down in February. If my well or anyone else's went down, it would be fixed by now. Uisce Éireann has not fixed it and we will not have water for Christmas. It is like waiting for Santy Claus. We met the CEO. He left after 50 minutes. We want another meeting with him. There is no responsibility or accountability; the Minister of State's former colleague, Phil Hogan, set this up in such a way. Please, we must make somebody accountable. We must have answers for the public, county councils, including local councillors, and Oireachtas Members. It is not happening at the moment. That is not right.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputies for raising these important matters. The Minister, Deputy James Browne, sends his apologies for not being in a position to answer this Topical Issue in person.
Uisce Éireann is the national authority for water services and a statutorily independent body with responsibility for all aspects of water services, as prescribed by the Water Services Acts. It was formed and registered under the Companies Acts and is a commercial State company. Neither the Minister, Deputy Browne, nor I have any operational role. That is a matter for Uisce Éireann. These arrangements are not particular to Uisce Éireann. They apply to the generality of State bodies that have statutorily assigned functions that are not, as a result, functions of a Minister of the Government.
However, given the level of Exchequer funding provided to Uisce Éireann, it is subject to additional layers of governance and accountability by the Oireachtas, including audit by the Comptroller and Auditor General and accountability to the Committee of Public Accounts. There are also requirements for bodies funded by the State to have appropriate systems in place for the provision of information regarding their operations to Oireachtas Members, as detailed in Circular 25/2016, the protocol for the provision of information to Members of the Oireachtas by State bodies under the aegis of a Department. Uisce Éireann has a dedicated team to deal with representations and queries from public representatives. However, it is true that this engagement needs to improve significantly. It is something that I have addressed in my meetings with it over the last number of months. While progress is being made, significantly more work remains to be achieved. Uisce Éireann has also acknowledged that its engagement with public representative needs to improve and has informed me that it is in the process of taking additional steps to improve both the timing and quality of responses to inquiries made by elected representatives.
Turning to south Tipperary in particular, Deputy Michael Murphy has raised the ongoing issues with me in person over the last number of weeks. I have made inquiries on behalf of him and Deputy Mattie McGrath and have been informed that Uisce Éireann issued seven press releases since 9 October and communicated extensively and urgently with elected representatives on the matters that are affecting their communities.
The "do not consume" notice for customers on the Ardfinnan regional water supply scheme was recently lifted following consultation with HSE and the completion of critical works at Goatenbridge water treatment plant. However, the boil water notice remains in place and the public in south Tipperary should adhere to the guidance until a further update is provided by Uisce Éireann. Uisce Éireann has said that its focus now is on lifting the boil water notice as quickly and safely as possible. The completion of the works at the water treatment plant is an important step. Further testing and monitoring is necessary to provide the evidence required, in consultation with the HSE, to determine when the boil water notice can be lifted safely.
Comment on this
I could not make it up. I thank the Minister of State for being here but the Minister, Deputy Browne, should be here. I have not seen the like of it. How many press releases did the Minister of State say that Uisce Éireann had issued? Press releases will not give us clean water, lift a boil water notice or fix the burst pipes. I could not make this up. I have met the Pope. I have met the President of America. That was much easier than meeting the invisible CEO of Uisce Éireann. Uisce Éireann is not accountable to anyone. It is like Comical Ali during the Iraq War. When the bombs were falling down on him, he was issuing press releases. This is total baloney.
There is a democratic deficit and it must be addressed. I have drafted a water services Bill, called the accountability Bill 2026, to establish clear accountability for Uisce Éireann to the Minister - that will be the Minister of State if the Minister is not available - and the principle is simple: no public body should be beyond democratic scrutiny. That goes without saying. No public body should avoid accountability by using operational measures. We have to have clear measures like this. No public utility should be able to preside over a fiasco like Uisce Éireann is in south Tipperary.
Comment on this
The old adage was, "Where Tipperary leads, Ireland follows". If Ireland follows what we are doing with our water, it will be a complete and utter catastrophe.
Comment on this
We need Uisce Éireann to be reined in and be accountable to this House and, ultimately, the Minister.
Comment on this
I, too, attended that public meeting. It was attended by hundreds in the Talbot Hotel last night. Constituents of mine are angry and frustrated. There is huge anxiety within the community, particularly among vulnerable users, many of whom my office engages with on a weekly basis. I am reminded of the Tánaiste's contribution on 2 July last when he said:
... it is my very clear view that Uisce Éireann should be [more] accountable to Dáil Éireann through parliamentary questions [and select committee]. I do not understand why it is not.
Does the Minister of State agree with what the Tánaiste said in this Chamber on 2 July? It is extraordinary to think that I am a policymaker and a legislator, and we have a public utility in receipt of billions of euro that is not accountable to this house of democracy.
Comment on this
I understand the Deputies' frustration on behalf of their communities, which are being impacted as a result of the ongoing issues. There is no question that there is an information deficit and the response from Uisce Éireann is not where it needs to be in terms of the information that is provided to all Members of this Chamber. I agree with the Tánaiste in that regard. As I said in my opening contribution, though, I have raised this and there is an acknowledgement within Uisce Éireann that it is not where it needs to be.
We want to get to a situation where the information that is relayed to Members of the Oireachtas is accurate and done in a timely fashion and that Uisce Éireann is responsive to the needs and requests of Members of this House and the Seanad. When there is an issue, there is a call centre within Uisce Éireann that the public can reach out to-----
Comment on this
The Deputy might let me make the point. Yes, there is a phone number that people can call, but because I have been a public representative for over 16 or 17 years, I know that the phone call is oftentimes to the public representative. The Deputies have to be responsive to their communities as well and the only way they can do that is by having the correct and timely information.
It is also true to say that Uisce Éireann is responsible for appearing before the Committee of Public Accounts and subject to audit by the Comptroller and Auditor General. I sat on the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Housing, Local Government and Heritage. The officials have appeared before the committee as well as appearing before the Joint Committee on Infrastructure and National Development Plan Delivery.
The priority has to now be in terms of lifting the boil water notice. Testing and monitoring are ongoing in the area and that will be continued to be prioritised by Uisce Éireann. I can continue to engage with both Deputies offline.