Saincheisteanna Tráthúla - Topical Issue Debate ›
Health Services Staff
Rose Conway-Walsh urged immediate approval of full-time clerical posts at Swinford and Belmullet hospitals, warning that reduced or insecure support burdens clinicians and delays rural patient care. Minister of State Jennifer Murnane O’Connor cited HSE staffing and budget controls and said she would raise the concerns with the Minister and obtain a response from the HSE.
I want to outline for the Minister of State today the impact that the dead hand of the Minister for Health is having on healthcare delivery in County Mayo, starting with clerical support staff. They are essential to safe, accessible community healthcare. Their roles must get agency conversion approval in order to maintain clinical capacity in rural healthcare services. Agency conversions must get approval before the existing clerical officer contract finishes in Swinford. I am talking about the hospitals of Swinford and Belmullet.
I am talking about the clerical positions, of which there is one in each hospital. Those posts represent a tiny amount of money but provide a lot of support. In Swinford, for example, one person supports five physiotherapists and two speech and language therapists. In Belmullet, one clerical post supports several different therapists and medical staff. They are agency staff and because of the dead hand of the Minister, they are not being allowed to convert those posts into full-time positions. Patients are now facing longer waits and rescheduled appointments as staff are no longer available to manage referrals, records and scheduling. The physiotherapists, public health nurses and other clinicians cannot simultaneously do their jobs, manage patient-facing workloads and also absorb clerical duties. Every hour spent on administration is an hour not spent on treating patients.
The communities in Belmullet and Swinford already face geographical and transport barriers when accessing healthcare. Removing local support disproportionately impacts rural patients in these cases. The promise of care closer to home is completely undermined when the staff who keep the local services functioning are withdrawn. One post may look minor on a national staffing spreadsheet but it is crucial to the day-to-day running of a rural healthcare facility. The clerical officers in Swinford and Belmullet have built up months of practical knowledge of local patients, referral pathways and physiotherapy services. The loss of experienced staff means a loss of that institutional knowledge, of continuity and of relationships that cannot be replaced immediately. It makes no sense to lose staff who are already performing essential duties while their posts await agency conversion approval. It is a complete waste of money as well.
Through my correspondence with the HSE, I have received confirmation that these posts are in an agency conversion approval system but no firm decision date has been provided. Agency conversion is subject to national pay and staffing controls, budgetary restrictions and available funding. This is the dead hand of the Minister.
This matter is urgent because I have been made aware that the current clerical support in Swinford is due to finish tomorrow but the agency conversion cannot take place unless the role is active. I am calling on the Minister of State to relay to the Minister for Health the need for immediate approval and funding of agency conversion for the posts in Belmullet and Swinford, without further delay. I would also like to remind the Minister that there are healthcare assistant posts in Belmullet hospital that have been waiting four years to transfer from agency to full-time staff. The positions are there and are permanent but the Minister insists on keeping them as agency staff. She must restore the appropriate clerical cover on site during the approval process rather than transferring the clerical duties to clinical staff.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Conway-Walsh for raising the issue of clerical support at Belmullet Community Hospital and Swinford District Hospital. I can hear the Deputy's passion and I do understand that she is in an area where there are concerns. I am taking this issue on behalf of the Minister for Health and I recognise the importance of both hospitals to their communities. I am aware of the important role that they play in their local communities for families and for everyone involved. The concerns that the Deputy raises today have implications for patients and clinical staff.
Belmullet is a 13-bed facility that can cater for step-down, respite and palliative care, providing an important service. Swinford District Hospital is a 40-bed model 1 rehabilitation and community inpatient facility. As part of the HSE's ongoing measures to reduce reliance on off-framework agency staffing, one whole-time equivalent, WTE, agency administrative post in Swinford District Hospital was reduced to 0.5 WTE. The HSE has advised that administrative duties associated with the reduced hours are currently being managed locally through existing staffing arrangements. In Belmullet Community Hospital, the agency administrative post remains in place at one WTE and the HSE has advised that there are no issues currently arising in respect of administrative staffing.
The management of staffing and the allocation of resources within these facilities are operational matters for the HSE. That does not diminish the importance of the concerns raised for patients and families who need confidence that local services have the support necessary to deliver safe and effective care.
Clerical and administrative staff make an important contribution to patient care. Their work supports records management, communications and the scheduling of the day-to-day operation of services. Appropriate administrative support helps clinical staff to focus on the work they are trained to do. It should therefore be considered as part of the overall staffing needs of a service, rather than in isolation. The Deputy has raised concerns about changes to clerical support and the implications for clinical staff. I understand the region is dealing with financial challenges at the moment which may be impacting on recruitment decisions. There are some challenges and I am sure the Deputy is aware of that. My expectation is that the HSE considers the full-service implications of any staffing changes and ensures that appropriate staffing supports are in place. The focus must be on maintaining patient care and making effective use of staff across both hospitals.
On the wider recruitment position, there is no blanket recruitment freeze. Recruitment, including the replacement of existing staff, can continue within approved pay allocations, subject to the necessary approvals. This does not mean that every vacancy is automatically filled. The HSE must prioritise recruitment according to patient need, service requirements and resources available. Additional recruitment approval requirements apply to HSE West and North-West as part of the measures to address regional overspending. I recognise that these requirements form part of the context in which local staffing decisions are being made. They provide a process for assessing recruitment proposals on the basis of service need, patient safety risk and affordability. In applying these controls, the HSE must take account of the support needed to maintain essential services, including the contribution of administrative staff to patient care. The objective is to align expenditure with approved funding while protecting essential services and making the best use of available resources. The HSE remains responsible for the delivery of services and for assessing the management of patient safety risks. Financial oversight and the effective delivery of care must be considered together.
Comment on this
The problem is that the Minister is wasting money hand over fist by not having the services available in the community for a small cost. That is why you have the back-up in Mayo University Hospital. You cannot send people home without having the therapies and supports in the local community. It costs multiple times more to do that. This carry-on is happening in hospitals because the Minister obviously did not allow enough for existing levels of service. She just did not do that. I do not know if she fully understands the impact of that in terms of overcrowding, ambulances queuing up outside Mayo University Hospital and people staying in beds longer than they should because services are not available in the community. I listened to the Fine Gael Ard-Fheis at the weekend, and I heard talk about the dole. I want the Minister of State to ask the Minister why she is forcing young nurses onto the dole who were given jobs in Mayo University Hospital and in Sligo and Galway hospitals. They are now being told the jobs are not going to start after all. Why are we pushing nurses and clinical staff onto the dole and then not doing within the community what we need to do by putting supports in there? I do not know if it is that the Government does not understand the systems or if it has wrecked the systems to the point where things are collapsing. I am telling the Minister of State that healthcare delivery in Mayo is collapsing and the workers are collapsing with exhaustion. The Minister is standing back to say that the Government does not have enough money for the west and the north west. She had better make the money available. There is money there to waste. She insists on the continuation of waste while she is presiding over what she is presiding over here.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. I can always say, working with the Minister, that patient care and delivery is always very important for all of us.
I recognise the concern is about staffing decisions, which means, in practice for patients, the staff delivery of care at Belmullet and Swinford. The Deputy is talking about clerical supports that help clinical staff to focus on patient care and contribute to the effective running of services. My expectation is that the HSE considers wider benefits than assessing staffing needs at both hospitals so that available resources are used effectively to support patients and staff.
I understand that the concerns the Deputy has brought up today are very important. I know the commitment from the Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, and from all of us in the Department of Health. I will raise these concerns. The Deputy can be assured that I will have the HSE respond directly to the Deputy on the issues raised in both Belmullet and Swinford. I assure the Deputy that there is access to safe, effective care. The staffing decision supports and the objectives are important.
Rather than reading out the reply again, it is important to say the Deputy can be assured that I will have the HSE come back to her. I will go back to the Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, and highlight the concerns the Deputy raised today.
As someone whose daughter is a nurse, I appreciate the work done by our nurses, clerical staff and everybody in the HSE. As the Deputy said, timely access to services is important. The HSE is saying it is working on them. I will come back to the Deputy.